Search This Blog

De Omnibus Dubitandum - Lux Veritas

Tuesday, November 12, 2013

The Political Debate We Need to Have

Today, we treat politics as a sport, but it’s really a conflict of ideologies between federalists and technocrats.
by Bruce Thornton November 6, 2013
The media and pundits treat politics like a sport. The significance of the recent agreement to postpone the debt crisis until January, for instance, is really about which party won and which lost, which party’s tactics are liable to be more successful in the next election, and which politician is a winner and which a loser. But politics rightly understood is not about the contest of policies or politicians. It’s about the philosophical principles and ideas that create one policy rather than another—that’s what it should be about, at least.
From that point of view, the conflict between Democrats and Republicans concerns the size and role of the federal government, which is no surprise to anyone who even casually follows politics. But more important are the ideas that ground arguments for or against limited government. These ideas include our notions of human nature, and what motivates citizens when they make political decisions.…….during the Constitutional convention……the basis of the Constitution was the view that human nature is flawed…..men are “ambitious, vindictive and rapacious,” and are motivated by what James Madison called “passions and interests.”…….Hence the people “are daily misled into the most baneful measures and opinions by the false reports circulated by designing men,” as Elbridge Gerry said during the Constitutional convention debates…..To Read More….

No comments:

Post a Comment