Search This Blog

De Omnibus Dubitandum - Lux Veritas

Sunday, March 4, 2018

Trump’s Spending Splurge Is a Long-Run Recipe for Higher Taxes and Less Prosperity

February 28, 2018 by Dan Mitchell @ International Liberty
 
I sometimes sardonically comment about Democratic politicians playing Santa Claus, but Republicans can play that game as well.

Trump and his allies in Congress recently agreed on a big-spending budget deal that lavishes more money on both the Pentagon and domestic programs, and that was only a few weeks after agreeing on a tax reform plan that lower taxes (though only for nine years).

Even if I like part of what’s been happening, that kind of populist approach at some point becomes unsustainable. And when the D.C. swamp ultimately has to choose between lower taxes or higher spending, they’ll go with the latter and make things even worse by jacking up the tax burden.

My frustration is apparent in this recent interview.



And I’m not the only one who sees the long-run dangers.

In a column for the Wall Street Journal, Professor Edward Lazear of Stanford explores the economic damage of ever-expanding government.
The budget deal President Trump signed earlier this month will send federal spending and the deficit skyrocketing. On top of this spending explosion, the administration now plans to add a $500 billion infrastructure bill. …over time high spending necessitates high taxes, and high taxes reduce work and restrain growth. Economic trends in developed nations consistently show that low taxes and hard work are linked to robust growth.
He looks at some of the cross-country evidence.
European countries trail the U.S. in working hard and controlling taxes, and their economies have lagged in comparison. France has a tax-to-GDP ratio of about 44%, and in Italy it’s 43%. The French and Italians work almost 30% fewer hours per person than Americans. Notably, the French economy has flatlined since 2010 while Italy’s has contracted. …Data from the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development suggests that a 1% increase in a nation’s tax rate is associated with a 1.4% decrease in hours worked per person in the working-age population.
Here’s the part that resonated with me. It’s excessive spending that ultimately is the problem.
…taxes are ultimately dictated by spending. Countries can borrow to finance short-run spending, but they must eventually levy taxes to repay the loans. Whether a government raises taxes now or later to pay for expenditures is a minor consideration compared with its decision to spend in the first place. …Higher spending goes hand in hand with higher taxes, higher deficits, fewer worked hours and less growth. The international comparisons suggest that a 4% increase in spending is associated with a decrease of roughly 0.5 percentage point in the average annual growth rate. Furthermore, it is spending—rather than the deficit—that correlates with sluggish growth. …Deficits often coincide with low growth because deficit increases are usually caused by heightened spending, not reduced taxes. Raising taxes, or keeping them high without lowering spending, stifles growth.
Heck, even the OECD has produced research on the negative impact of government spending on economic performance.

And this approach can lead to a downward spiral.
To the extent that government spending goes to programs such as welfare that directly discourage work, it has an additional growth-reducing effect. When fewer people work, those who do must be taxed even more to cover public expenses. These heightened taxes on labor discourage work in turn, pushing more potential workers toward government support.
In other words, if we stay on this path, we’ll eventually become Greece. Not a good idea, to put it mildly.

Since we’re on the topic, let’s look at some additional evidence. Three economists from Australia and the United Kingdom did a meta-analysis of studies on the relationship between government spending and economic growth. Here are some of the findings.
One of the most contentious issues in economics is whether ‘big government’ is good or bad for economic growth. …Theoretically, big government can have both negative and positive effects on growth. …In this study, we include all effect-size estimates reported by empirical studies that examine the direct effect of government size on growth.
Here’s what they found.
… findings indicate that: (i) total government expenditures have a medium and adverse effect on per-capita income growth in developed countries only; (ii) the effect of government consumption on per-capita income growth is also medium in developed countries and in developed and LDCs pooled together; and (iii) neither total expenditures nor government consumption has a significant effect on per-capita income growth in LDCs.
I’m not surprised that they didn’t find a strong link in poor nations. The data show that those countries are generally too mismanaged and corrupt to collect much revenue. Therefore, as I noted in my recent analysis of Indian economic policy, they can’t spend much.

What’s primarily holding back those countries is weak rule of law, excessive regulation, and protectionism.

But I’m digressing. The study also acknowledges the Rahn Curve, though they call it the Armey Curve.
…government size tends to have a negative effect on per-capita income growth as the level of income increases. This finding ties in with the Armey curve hypothesis (Armey, 1995), which posits an inverted-U relationship between government size and economic growth. The theoretical argument here is that government size may be characterised by decreasing returns. Another theoretical argument relates to the distortionary nature of taxes, which is minimal for low levels of taxation, but beyond a certain threshold, they grow rapidly and become extremely large.
Quite true.

Sadly, some people mistakenly conclude that if a little bit of government is associated with more prosperity, then a bloated public sector must be even better.

On a related note, Professor Alexander Salter dismisses the assertion (pushed by international bureaucracies) that big government is a pre-condition for prosperity. Here’s some of what he wrote.
Why are Western countries like the United States and Germany so much richer today than other countries around the world? …One explanation for the success of the West is, in a word, liberty. Over the last few hundred years, classical liberal ideas such as the rights of man and the rule of lawput constraints on European governments’ power, which resulted in a strong protection of private property rights. This resulted in meteoric economic growth, which delivered the modern cornucopia of wealth. …Free countries get rich; unfree countries stay poor.
But there’s a competing theory.
…another explanation — state capacity…is the idea that economic development requires strong, centralized states to uphold the rule of law and provide crucial public goods. …The state capacity literature in economics…places heavy emphasis on a single, strong, central legal authority. In this framework, the fractured and decentralized legal authorities in medieval and early modern Europe are now seen as antithetical to economic development.
Salter is skeptical of the second theory.
…it is undeniable that economic growth in the West did not take off until the rise of modern nation-states. … While governance institutions obviously began centralizing at the beginning of the modern era, …that’s insufficient as a causal explanation. …the state capacity literature has a hard time dealing with a very troubling counterexample: the totalitarian states of the 20th century: like the USSR and China. These states had plenty of capacity, as evidenced by their ability to murder millions of their own citizens… Needless to say, these kinds of things aren’t conducive to economic development.
So he concludes that the first theory must be the answer, at least in part.
…whatever is “doing the work” of promoting economic growth, it is upstream of the creation of states. …State capacity may or may not be a valuable steppingstone to an explanation, but it is not itself an explanation that social scientists should accept. …it seems the old hypothesis — that the big ideas of classical liberalism created Western economic growth — is worth another look!
My bottom line, for what it’s worth, is that the classical-liberalism approach is the necessary condition, but that doesn’t automatically make it a sufficient condition.

In a column last year on the emerging micro-state of Liberland, I tried to square the circle. Here’s some of what I wrote after looking at the literature on state capacity.
…the key to prosperity is having a state strong enough and effective enough to provide rule of law, but to somehow constrain that state so that it doesn’t venture into destructive redistribution policies. This is why competition between governments played a key role in the economic development of the western world. When governments have to worry about productive resources escaping, that forces them to focus on things that help an economy (i.e., rule of law) while minimizing the policies that hinder prosperity (i.e., high taxes and spending). …America’s Founding Fathers dealt with the same issues… Their solution was a constitution that explicitly limited the size and scope of the federal government. …that system worked reasonably well until the 1930s.
I find this issue fascinating, but I suspect most people are more concerned about the real-world consequences rather than the theoretical underpinnings.

So I’ll end on a pessimistic note by observing that we normally get bad fiscal policy from Democrats and worse fiscal policy from Republicans (Reagan being the only modern-era exception).

Free markets are…racist??

March 1, 2018 by , 4 Comments @ CFACT

 

South African Parliament Declares That All White Famers Must Be Punished

By Andrew West March 3, 2018

It is becoming increasingly difficult to discern where political correctness has drawn the line on racism these days, with a wide ranging and ever-mutating list of rules to be followed in order to clear your name. And, unless you’ve been living in a cave for the last decade, you are already a racist. It’s inherent in all of us, according the lunatic fringes on the left side of American politics, where you will always be considered guilty until proven virtuous.

It’s the democratic version of the oldest story of the Bible, in which you are all inherently sinners and only the Progressive Prophet of the week can truly save you.  This is precisely how American democrats retain what little power they have, by creating a savior of The State, and allowing their followers to subscribe only to that visage of divinity.  You have no free will, according to the left, because, with free will you could sin again.  Just relinquish control to a Clinton or an Obama, and allow them to be your own personal democratic deity.............“Mr Malema has a long-standing commitment to land confiscation without compensation. In 2016 he told his supporters he was ‘not calling for the slaughter of white people – at least for now’.”.............This is the face of radical political correctness without any sort of relativity to reality...........To Read More.....

This flawed UN health agency threatens America's food supply.

It's time for badly needed reform

by Jeff Stier and Julie KellyMarch 2, 2018 Foxnews.Com

Question: When is a carcinogen not necessarily a carcinogen?

Answer: When the labelling is done by the World Health Organization's International Agency for Research on Cancer (IARC), a French-based institution that is having a big and unjustified impact on American law and our economy.

That's the majority view from an investigation by the U.S. House Committee on Science, Space, and Technology, which is trying to understand how IARC classified the most commonly used herbicide in the world as a probable carcinogen, while nearly every government agency which evaluated the chemical, including our own EPA, reached the opposite conclusion.

Big money, and the future of American agriculture, is involved. The chemical is glyphosate, an ingredient in Monsanto's Roundup, which is used worldwide to boost agricultural productivity, increasingly  in conjunction with genetically modified crops. The product is a huge target for class-action lawyers and green activists who make a living sowing hatred of Monsanto and its products. (Neither of us has ever received funding from Monsanto.)........."An IARC working group collaborates behind closed-doors to select data, analyze data, and reach conclusions. So, without any public engagement or independent scientific peer review, the working group acts as hand-in-hand with IARC staff as judges, juries, and executioners.".........To Read More....

 

Saturday, March 3, 2018

The World as I See It: The 2018 Midterms

By Rich Kozlovich

When Harry Truman was running for his own term as President of the United States he was criticized by some in his party for not running like a Republican, whatever that meant at the time. Harry told them if the public had a choice between a Republican and a Republican they'd choose a Republican every time. So he created a coalition of blacks, the white working class and unions as his base, and he won, and it was a winning coalition for decades.

That coalition has changed a bit for the Democrats.

The ascendant coalition consists of abortionists, blacks, Hispanics, feminists, gays, public employee unions, environmentalists, college kids and wealthy white liberals, all of whom have drifted into fever swamps of the left. Many of whom don't think the Democrat Party is anywhere near sufficiently to the left in order to fulfil their hallucinatory visions. They "Feel the Bern".

California Democrats treatment of Diane Feinstein is just one such example. Remember - to a leftist- there are no boundaries to the left when it comes to undermining the Constitution and the foundational Judaic/Christian values of America.  They reject her because she's unwilling to drift entirely into leftist insanity.

The Democratic National Committee chairman Tom Perez criticized the Democratic Congressional Campaign Committee (DCCC) for not supporting a far left Democrat, Laura Moser, running for Congress in Texas. The DCCC criticized her saying, “Democratic voters need to hear that Laura Moser is not going to change Washington,” and criticizing her as a “Washington insider.” In short - the DCCC thinks she's too far to the left to be elected.

But Tom Perez doesn't care, and like all leftists he recognizes one vision and one vision only - there can be no boundaries to the left, there can be no distance too far to the left that’s unacceptable. Most importantly, there can be no compromise in attaining the goal of destroying the Constitution.

They've won a couple of special elections recently, but I view that as anomalous as to what will happen during the mid-terms.

The Democrats have abandoned the cause of the white working class considering them racist, sexist, Islamophobic, Xenophobic, homophobic who bitterly cling to their Bibles and their guns. All of whom Hillary Clinton declared are a "basket of deplorables". An irredeemable basket of deplorables, and according to Hillary, they're not America! And the Democrats applauded.

So, what are the only conclusions left for these deplorables? The government not only let them down, it has turned on them. The capital generation created by the baby boomer generation has been raided and mismanaged to the point their secure retirement is in question, including those retirement plans managed by unions, which have either degenerated or disappeared entirely. It's clear to them those in power are not interested in white middle class Christian conservatives, their children or their grandchildren, and will do anything to undermine them as a component of society until they no longer exist.
"This is the difference between liberalism and the kind of individual we are facing today with leftism. Leftism is an aggressive mutation of radical liberalism that not only has escalated its Marxist demands on the country but has shown little regard for the detrimental consequences it produces."- Rick Hayes
It's clear the generations behind the Baby Boomers do not have the numbers or the economic wherewithal to maintain the retirement needs and promises made to the boomers without huge tax increases or major cuts in benefits, and it might require both. Social Security will no longer be self-sustaining by 2020, and bankrupt by 2030, and it’s my view that after 2020 the debt load being incurred by the world’s nations is going to lead to a major worldwide economic downturn.

It’s also my belief China and Russia will face economic collapse and Europe will erupt into civil wars that will lead to major confrontations between Muslims and ethnic Europeans, and that will finally bankrupt Europe forever. Turning Europe into a proliferation of smaller states as is happening in Spain, and some nations will cease to exist as independent nations entirely. A trend I think will extend into Russia and China. All of which will create long term problems that may be unfixable in much of the industrialized world.

The Democrats will trend toward candidates even more to the left than those in office now, and the Republicans will be electing real conservatives in place of RINO's like Mitch McConnell.

Things will become even more rancorous in the Congress than anything we've seen in this country since the early days of the nation's founding when legislators challenged each other to duels or beat a member of the opposition with a cane.

I've predicted in the past the Congress will not only fail in finding collegiality, but leading up to the mid-terms they will in fact become even more divided and viscious than we’re currently seeing, much of which will be bordering on treason.

And that's the foundation and circumstances the Democrats confidently think will convince the nation to sweep them back into power in 2018!

Update: I've just watched a video which fits nicely with this article.  Please enjoy this Hillsdale College presentation, "Taking Stock of Trumpism: Where It Came From, What It Has Accomplished, and Where It Is Going.", by Victor Davis Hanson.


The Importance of Property Rights – with South Africa as a Sad Example of What Not to Do

March 2, 2018 by Dan Mitchell @ International Liberty
 
There’s an easy way to judge whether countries have good economic policy or bad economic policy. Simply look at the Fraser Institute’s Economic Freedom of the World and check out a nation’s absolute score as well as how it ranks relative to other nations.

The EFW report even allows readers to see how nations score in the five major policy areas the are used to produce the overall grade. These categories are:
  • Size of Government – A measure of the burden of taxes and spending.
  • Regulation – A measure of intervention and red tape.
  • Sound Money – A measure of monetary stability and financial freedom.
  • Freedom to Trade Internationally – A measure of liberty to engage in cross-border commerce.
  • Legal System and Property Rights – A measure of the quality of governance.
This last category sometimes doesn’t get enough attention. I sometimes refer to it as the rule-of-law measure. It’s basically a way of trying to estimate whether government is doing a good job with institutional public goods. The variables used include 1) Judicial independence, 2) Impartial courts, 3) Protection of property rights, 4) Military interference in rule of law and politics, 5) Integrity of the legal system, 6) Legal enforcement of contracts, 7) Regulatory costs of the sale of real property 8) Reliability of police, and 9) Business costs of crime.

Let’s look today at property rights. And I’m motivated to address this issue because of some horrifying news from South Africa. The Wall Street Journal opined on the issue this morning.
No country ever became rich through its government’s seizure of private property (exhibit A: the Soviet Union), but politicians in South Africa want to give it another go. That’s the disheartening news from Cape Town this week, where the National Assembly voted 241-83 on Tuesday to start a process to amend the constitution and allow land expropriation without compensation.
When I saw the headline and read the opening paragraph, my initial instinct was “so what?” After all, the whites probably stole the land from the blacks in the first place.
But then I found out that issue already has been handled.
Post-apartheid, the government bought land and offered compensation to South Africans whose property had been forcibly seized after 1913. Many of those claims are now settled… According to a 2016 Institute of Race Relations survey, less than 1% of South Africans think land is one of the country’s “serious unresolved problems.” Unemployment, public services, housing and crime rank far higher.
What’s actually happening is hard-core leftist populism. And it may turn South Africa into another Zimbabwe.
Julius Malema of the far-left Economic Freedom Fighters party…believes the state should be the “custodian” of the nation’s property… His party says the expropriation “should apply to all South Africans, black and white.”
Huh? Stealing property from everybody, regardless of race, while calling your party Economic Freedom Fighters?!?

I guess their idea of freedom means freedom to loot, which is sometimes called – rather perversely – positive liberty. But I shouldn’t laugh too hard because the United States actually had a president with the same twisted mindset.

In any event, the WSJ reminds us that this won’t produce good results.
The idea is likely to duplicate the awful experience of Zimbabwe during the Robert Mugabe era, a case study in the reality that bureaucrats can’t distribute resources more efficiently or productively than private markets. Mugabe’s confiscations spooked investors, the agricultural industry collapsed, and a once prosperous country became known for hyperinflation and poverty. …the ruling African National Congress is supporting the measure to distract attention from its own failed statist economic policies, which have produced subpar growth and denied opportunity to poor South Africans. …South Africa needs more capital, more investment and a favorable business environment. Seizing private property has produced misery everywhere it has been tried.
This is very troubling, especially since South Africa, compared to other nations on the continent, maintained semi-decent policies after dismantling the racist apartheid regime.

I wrote back in 2014 about South African economic policy and shared data about the nation’s EFW score. I was worried about the trend, and I’m now even more pessimistic.

Since today’s topic is property rights, let’s look at the global scores from the International Property Rights Index, which is published each year by the Property Rights Alliance.

As you can see, South Africa currently is in the second quintile. Best score of any African country, and above some European nations as well.


But if the South African constitution is changed and land expropriation is allowed, it’s a foregone conclusion that the country will suffer a precipitous fall in the rankings.

And here’s the map accompanying the study. The bottom line is that blue is good and purple/maroon (or whatever that color is…mauve?) is bad.


Switching to other nations, notice that all the Nordic nations are highly ranked. Indeed, they hold three of the top five slots. No wonder they score highly in that part of Economic Freedom of the World. Moreover, they also get very good scores for monetary policy, regulatory policy, and trade policy. Which explains why their economies get decent performance notwithstanding very bad fiscal policy.

And I’m certainly not surprised that New Zealand has the top spot.

The United States also does reasonably well. Not in the top 10, but at least in the top quintile.
P.S. In addition to moving in the wrong direction on property rights, South African politicians are making the tax code more destructive.

P.P.S. There is a country in sub-Saharan Africa to emulate.

A Post-Janus Agenda for California’s Public Sector Unions





Earlier this week the U.S. Supreme Court heard arguments in the Janus vs. AFSCME case. Mark Janus, a public employee in Illinois, is challenging the right of unions to charge “fair share” fees, because he disagrees with the political agenda which he claims his fees help pay for.

What if government unions were accountable to their members? What if the politics of these unions mirrored the politics of the members? Would Mark Janus still want out?

It’s already possible for public employees to “opt-out” of paying that portion of their dues that fund explicitly political activity, although in practice the unions typically make that opt-out process very difficult. But Mark Janus is arguing that all dues paid to public sector unions are political, because the consequences of collective bargaining in the public sector impact taxes, government debt, budgets and spending priorities. He is arguing that the agenda of public sector unions, including collective bargaining, is inherently political............To Read More....

House Democrat Introduces Bill to Completely Eliminate HHS's New Conscience Rights Division

Feb 28, 2018 Lauretta Brown

Rep. Michelle Lujan Grisham (D-NM) introduced a bill Tuesday called “Eliminating the HHS Discrimination Division of 2018” which would get rid of the newly created Conscience and Religious Freedom Division within the Department of Health and Human Services (HHS)......claiming that the division is discriminatory because it allows medical providers to “determine a patient’s care based on their personal religious beliefs.”  “A patient’s health and wellness should always come first and the Trump Administration has no business facilitating discrimination and creating barriers for medically necessary health care that will ultimately harm patient health and endanger lives,”
“This Division was created with the sole purpose of allowing hospitals, doctors, nurses, and even administrative staff to determine a patient’s care based on their personal religious beliefs, not on what is best for the patient,” she claimed. “I am proud to introduce this legislation to ensure that every American, regardless of their gender identity, reproductive health care choices, or need for any type of medical care, has access to quality, comprehensive health care.”
Grisham’s bill has been endorsed by the American Civil Liberties Union, Planned Parenthood Federation of America, the National Women’s Law Center, the American Civil Liberties Union of New Mexico, Equality New Mexico, the Transgender Resource Center of New Mexico, the New Mexico Religious Coalition for Reproductive Choice, and the National Center for Transgender Equality............However, members of Congress and some medical providers have praised the new division, citing instances of discrimination against religious medical providers under the Obama administration..........“Nuns have been forced to put aside their lives of service of the elderly and sit and have to go to court humbly requesting that they not be required to pay for practices that end the lives of children,” he said. .........To Read More....
My Take - It always amazes me how people who are trying to destroy people's rights do so by claiming they're protecting their rights.  The same is true when the issue is about abortion.  They call it a woman's right to good health care when it's really about murdering children.  One thing is clear -  if these groups are for it, it's an automatic you should be against it without doing one iota of research.

  • American Civil Liberties Union
  • Planned Parenthood Federation of America
  • National Women’s Law Center
  • American Civil Liberties
  • Union of New Mexico, Equality New Mexico
  • Transgender Resource Center of New Mexico
  • New Mexico Religious Coalition for Reproductive Choice,
  • National Center for Transgender Equality
Because if these groups are for something it's bound to be something that takes away liberty, undermines the Constitution by eliminating personal rights guaranteed in the Constitution and supports murdering the unborn. 

Michael Barone: Still saddled with the politics of the Seventies

by |

Not since James Monroe left the presidency in 1825, 48 years after he fought in the Battle of Princeton, has America had political leadership with careers running so far back in the past. Our current government leaders have political pedigrees going back to the 1970s.

Consider the Senate. Democratic leader Chuck Schumer was first elected to the New York Assembly in 1974. Republican leader Mitch McConnell was elected Jefferson County judge — the county administrator for Louisville, Ky. — in 1977.

Consider the House. Democratic leader Nancy Pelosi was elected Northern California Democratic Chairman in 1977. Democratic Whip Steny Hoyer was elected to the Maryland Senate in 1966 and was elected state Senate president in 1975.

Or how about California’s leading Democrats? Senator Dianne Feinstein was elected to the San Francisco Board of Supervisors in 1970 and became mayor in 1978. Governor Jerry Brown was elected California secretary of state in 1970 and to his first term as governor in 1974........To Read More......

David Perdue: Time to punish lawmakers if they can't do their jobs

by |

Sen. David Perdue says it's time to impose real penalties against lawmakers when they fail to pass budgets and spending bills on time, and thinks the new Joint Select Committee on Budget and Appropriations Process Reform might be the way to deliver those penalties.

Perdue and 15 other House and Senate lawmakers were appointed to the select committee over the last week. The group is hoping to agree on reforms that end the cycle of government shutdowns and omnibus spending bills that has dominated Congress for the last decade.............Perdue stressed that a big part of the reform needs to be real consequences for lawmakers if they fail to do the work...........some way needs to be found, such as the "no funding, no pay" bill that several lawmakers have proposed during the more recent funding failures.

"I personally agree with that,".........To Read More.....



Guns Don't Kill People, Ideas Do

Posted by Daniel Greenfield 5 Comments Friday, March 02, 2018 @ Sultan Knish Blog
“The copycat phenomenon is real,” Andre Simons, of the FBI's Behavioral Analysis Unit. One group of researchers found that up to 20 or 30 percent of attacks can be influenced by previous attacks.

During Omar Mateen's rampage at the Pulse nightclub, the Muslim terrorist searched for news coverage of the ongoing attack. He wanted to see what the media was making of his massacre.

Shootings that are widely covered by the media produce a cluster effect. After each attack, the risk of copycat attacks goes up for 13 days. If the media covers the attack, the copycat killers will come.

On Dec 3rd, 2012, Naeem Davis, a homeless Muslim refugee from Sierra Leone, shoved a middle-aged Korean man in front of an oncoming Q subway train in Times Square. A photographer snapped a shot of him waiting to die that appeared on the cover of the New York Post and then went around the world.

And that was that... except it wasn't.

On December 28, there was another shoving murder. After the round of murders, suicides and accidental deaths, seven people  had died under trains in 2013; a number that does not include the deaths previously mentioned. In Feb 2013, two people committed suicide by jumping in front of trains. Another was killed in a possible accident. One lost a leg. Two others were seriously injured. And then there was another suicide.

These numbers are not normal, but they are predictable. And that photograph and its consequences have dark implications for school shootings, mass shootings in general and human nature.

Around the same time that the American Revolution was getting underway, the German writer Goethe wrote a book that would become the Catcher in the Rye and Twilight of its day. "The Sorrows of Young Werther" had the dubious honor of being disowned by its author, starting a fashion trend and another deadlier trend.

Werther Fever spread around the world. Readers wrote parodies of the book or imagined different endings for the characters. Some wrote themselves into the story or wrote poems about the story. There were unauthorized sequels, people dressing up like the characters and all the usual things that we have now come to take for granted, but that were still somewhat new and surprising then.

And some committed suicide like Werther. The Werther Effect was born and it had a sneaky way of resurfacing whenever and wherever the book became popular again.

Some 200 years later, German television debuted "Death of a Student", a six-part series about Claus Wagner, a high school student who commits suicide by jumping under a train. Each episode began with Claus jumping under the train. The series was supposed to teach teenagers that suicide was wrong, but it had the opposite effect.

The real message of "Death of a Student" was the same message as that of "The Sorrows of Young Werther", if you kill yourself, lots of people will pay attention to you.  And suddenly the number of teenage boys killing themselves by jumping under a train increased by 175%. Having failed to prevent enough suicides, the show aired a second time. This time fewer people were watching and the suicide rate for teenage boys only went up 115%. 

A few years later in neighboring Vienna, suicides went up when they were featured on the front page rand fell 75% when they were pushed to the back page, run sans photos and without mention of the word, "Suicide." Young Werther, in his blue-tailed coat and yellow vest, stopped chasing the trains of the Vienna underground.

The suicide cluster is a well-known phenomenon, especially among teenagers; it is why the media avoids coverage of teenage suicides... with one exception. A teenager who hangs himself in his garage, jumps under a train or turns on the gas will generally not make the front page or even the back page. But if he takes a gun into a school, opens fire and then commits suicide,  Young Werther will be front page news for days, weeks or even months.

"No man is an island entire of itself," John Donne wrote, "every man is a piece of the continent." And some pieces of the continent are more easily invaded than others.

Suicides spike after front page coverage of a suicide. After Marilyn Monroe's death, 197 more people killed themselves than the statistical norm. Suicides rise even after fictional suicides on soap operas. And murders are also influenced by the coverage of real and fictional murders. The rise in the number of shootings after a heavily publicized shooting isn't a mysterious conspiracy, it's Werthers being Werther or Lanza or Holmes.

People are not mere machines who repeat back what they are given, but nor are ideas empty signals shouted into a void. Society is built on such signals. As is civilization. And it is foolish to pretend that the streams of communications that surround and connect those islands do not also influence the direction in which they drift. In a society where fame is the object, media coverage acts as both reward and punishment. And like any other training method, it produces its results.

Stick a photo of a man about to be hit by a train on the cover of a citywide newspaper, and more people will be pushed under trains and jump under trains. Spend weeks making a mass shooter famous and others will decide that resolving their problems with a shooting spree makes sense. Bad ideas are like bad signals, even if disapproved of, they are imitated if they are broadcast loudly enough. And the modern media is a deafeningly loud broadcast mechanism with many hypocritical agendas.

That does not mean that we ought to push the 1st Amendment under the train, the way that the media has been trying to do to the 2nd Amendment, but it does call for soul-searching and responsibility not by the people who make guns or defend the right to carry them, as the media insists, but by the people who make school shootings and subway suicides. The people who insist that everyone must search their souls, but them.

Stephen King, who recently jumped into the fray with his own gun control screed, was credited with inspiring one of the first clusters of school shootings in the United States. To his credit, King has wrestled with the question, withdrawing "Rage" from sale and conceding that it had an incendiary effect on troubled minds. To his discredit, King has used that action to argue that gun owners, manufacturers and civil rights groups should agree to a ban on the mythical assault rifle.

Ideas are more powerful than weapons. Weapons can kill a man, but ideas can cause a man to kill. Nevertheless the United States is a country built on the premise that ideas and weapons should be available to all. We are a country with high capacity magazines of both kinds. That experiment in human liberty is a dangerous one, and even though some Americans get on the wrong track, it is a profoundly worthy experiment because it allows us to choose who we are.

A totalitarian society cannot be moral. It can only be immoral. The few moral people in it retain their morality only by defying authority. In such a society, the Young Werther isn't a screwup, he's a saint. In our society, morality is a choice. Even as we drift into a totalitarian consensus that exchanges choice for obedience, individual opinions for mass media and civilian weapons for a police state, the power of choice still allows us to choose the right track or the wrong track.

The American can still choose to push a man in front of a train, kill a class full of children or vote to turn over his freedom and that of his friends, neighbors and countrymen to the state. Those are all choices that come up on the wrong track. The wrong track is the mass track. It is the track of letting the signals make the choices and of a willingness to kill and die just to appear for a moment as a ghost in the media's fame machine.

Choice requires a moral culture. It requires a weight of decency to overcome the darker impulses that lead men to take the wrong track. It requires us to think not only of our destination, but how we get there. It demands that we see ourselves not as the train running over a fragile body or as the passengers clumping together for safety while turning over the movement of the train to the driver, but as the drivers of our own train.

A moral society is based on the awareness of choice. Not the empty Wertheresque drama of it, but the knowledge that our choices define our lives and those of our neighbors. They call on us to be good people because the goodness of our society does not come from the law or the state, but from ourselves.

When the American society was hijacked from a consensus of the people and transformed into a top-down programming mechanism, its morality also became a top-down operation, rather than a bottom-up faith, and as the media management has decayed, its mixed signals and the ugly madness that it often broadcasts for its own profit and entertainment have become the ugly madness and mixed signals that lead some of its viewers and listeners to seek fame and power at any cost.

 

Thursday, March 1, 2018

Cartoon of the Day!

Political Cartoons by Bob Gorrell

Bob Gorrell - Wednesday, February 28, 2018

‘But Gorsuch’ Is More Than a Slogan

U.S. Supreme Court’s Janus deliberations will likely usher in a substantive and lasting victory over noxious power of public-sector unions.

March 1, 2018 Steven Greenhut

We’ve got a box of red balls at the office imprinted with a simple line drawing of U.S. Supreme Court Justice Neil Gorsuch and the words, “But Gorsuch.”

Whenever someone complains about President Donald Trump — and I routinely complain about his crude personality and some of his policies — we can chuck the ball at the wall and remind ourselves of a redeeming feature of his presidency. It was a fun idea, courtesy of the think tank that employs me. This hasn’t relieved much stress, but reading about the latest high-court deliberations and realizing that Gorsuch is on the court has done wonders for my soul. This week, the court began oral arguments in Janus v. American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees.

The case centers on these questions: Should public-sector workers be forced to pay dues, even though they might vigorously oppose the agenda of their union representatives? Does this violate their First Amendment rights?

Practically speaking, this case could — and probably will — dramatically roll back the power of government unions in non-right-to-work states. My writing focuses on California, where such unions essentially control all levers of government. The results are clear: massive pension and other debts to pay for crazy levels of public-sector compensation, the obliteration of public budgets and services, the protection of bad teachers and other workers........To Read More.....

The judges challenge Trump

March 1, 2018 By James Simpson

On Tuesday, U.S. District Court Judge Philip Gutierrez issued an order preventing President Trump from revoking DACA protections, and is ordering the administration to reinstate all those who have been dropped from the program.  This is more astounding judicial overreach in a year marred by such actions.  The initial DACA program was a memo, not legislation, not even a legitimate executive order or regulation.  Trump has every right as president to revoke it and enforce that revocation, but this judge has the gall to say he can't........If these jurists can successfully usurp the authority of a democratically elected president, it essentially negates the election.  ......Read more

Muslim Radio Station Fined a Measly $2,750 For Broadcasts Saying Violence Against Unbelievers Brings “Honor To Islam”

From now on they will broadcast nothing but fiercely patriotic calls to obey the British government and never try to wage jihad or impose Sharia in the UK. Won’t they?

Robert Spencer

A £2,000 fine! That will show those Misunderstanders of Islam at Radio Dawn!

From now on they will broadcast nothing but fiercely patriotic calls to obey the British government and never try to wage jihad or impose Sharia in the UK.

Won’t they?

“Muslim radio station fined for broadcasting ‘hate speech,'” by Jon Pritchard, Nottingham Post, February 27, 2018:
A radio station broadcasting to Nottingham’s Muslim community has been fined £2,000 after a talk played on the radio was found to constitute ‘hate speech’.
Watchdog Ofcom today (February 27) ruled a nasheed – a chant or speech often set to music which are popular in the Islamic world – broadcast by Radio Dawn breached its code on hate speech...........To Read More.....

Another federal judge goes off the rails

March 1, 2018 By Peter Skurkiss
 
This one is Judge Juan R. Torruella, of the United States Court of Appeals for the First Circuit in Boston. This 84-year-old dinosaur was nominated to the court in the pre-Reagan era, in 1974, by President Gerald Ford.

As a Puerto Rican native and strong advocate for the island, the judge is so troubled by his home island's financial difficulties that he's calling for a federal grand jury investigate to see if criminal cases can be made against those responsible for the Puerto Rican government's monumental debt.

To quote him: "I request an investigation by a federal grand jury to determine if there are criminal cases against individuals and organizations inside and outside of Puerto Rico in relation to the economic crisis facing the country.". ............More

How Harry Reid's Greed Led U.S. District Judge to Dismiss Bundy Ranch Case For "Flagrant Prosecutorial Misconduct"

By Jerome R. Corsi, Ph.D., Law Enforcement Charitable Foundation, Inc., February 28, 2018
 
WASHINGTON, D.C. — On January 8, 2018, U.S. District Judge Gloria Navarro dismissed "with prejudice" the federal criminal conspiracy and weapons charges against Nevada rancher Cliven Bundy, two of his sons, and an independent militia member because of "flagrant prosecutorial misconduct."

The story behind the Bundy Ranch standoff and subsequent criminal cases cannot be fully understood without knowing that the case was precipitated by former Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid, a Nevada Democrat. Reid coveted the Bundy Ranch grazing areas because Reid needed that land to advance the plans for him and his family to profit from the Obama administration's push to develop renewable energies...........To Read More..........

Muslims Were America's Top Mass Shooters in Last 2 Out of 3 Years

Posted by Daniel Greenfield Tuesday, February 27, 2018 2 Comments @ Sultan Knish Blog
Turn on CNN and you get the impression that mass shootings are mainly carried out by mentally unstable teenagers with assault rifles in high schools. But the data points to a very different picture.

In the last 5 years, five major mass shootings were carried out using AR-15 or similar rifles.

The perpetrators of the Parkland school massacre, the Las Vegas massacre and the Texas First Baptist Church massacre were Americans. Muslim terrorists however were responsible for the mass shootings at the Pulse nightclub and in San Bernardino. While the Vegas shooter was responsible for the deadliest attack last year, the deadliest attacks of 2015 and 2016 were both carried out by Muslim terrorists.

Two of the last three years were dominated by mass shootings carried out by Muslim terrorists.

In the last decade, there were only 10 major mass shootings where the death toll went into the double digits. Three of those were carried out by Muslim terrorists. That’s all the more remarkable since Muslims make up less than 1% of the United States population, but account for 33% of major mass shootings. Proportional to their representation in the population, Muslims are responsible for far more mass shootings than Americans.

The trend is worrisome. Since 2015, not a single year has passed without a Muslim mass shooting. While 2017’s Muslim mass shooter Kori Ali Muhammad only managed to kill three people in Fresno, his expressions of racial and religious hatred make it clear that we are dealing with a hateful pattern.

Muhammad had sought to kill "as many white males as possible". He shouted, “Allahu Akbar” when captured by the police. While the media has emphasized Dylann Storm Roof’s racist attack on a black church in Charleston, he was only 1 of 3 racially motivated mass shooters in the past 5 years, 2 were African-Americans, Muhammad and Micah Xavier Johnson, the Black Lives Matter protester who murdered 5 Dallas police officers. Johnson’s massacre of police officers and September 11 were the deadliest attacks on American police officers in this century. Both were carried out by Muslim attackers.

Johnson and Muhammad allegedly both had Nation of Islam ties. As did Gavin Long, who shot six police officers (three fatally), in a spree of racist violence. The funeral of Lovelle Mixon, who murdered 4 police officers in Oakland, included a minister from the Nation of Islam. A hate group championed by Obama’s church, by the Congressional Black Caucus and by a top figure in the Democratic National Committee.

The Nation of Islam is the racist hate group whose leader had met with Obama. Rep. Keith Ellison, No. 2 at the DNC, was a longtime member and it was recently revealed that he had also met with its leader.

It is deeply disturbing to learn that two-thirds of the racist mass shootings in the past 5 years were carried out by murderers with ties to a racist hate group that had connections inside the White House, whose leader had met with members of the Congressional Black Caucus and whose man has the second top job at the DNC. When asked about his Farrakhan connections, Rep. Ellison attempted to deflect by urging the media to look at white nationalist gun violence. But black nationalist gun violence is just as important. And it is rarely discussed because its existence taints top Democrats like Obama and Ellison.

John Allen Muhammad, also known as the Beltway Sniper, was also a member of the Nation of Islam. The racist terrorist and his accomplice murdered 17 people. The NOI has less than 50,000 members and yet it has managed to account for a disproportionate number of mass murderers in this century alone.

Can gun control stop Muslim mass shootings? Gun control advocates urge us to be more like Europe.

The Muslim terrorists who attacked the offices of Charlie Hebdo came packing assault rifles, submachine guns and a grenade launcher. The Bataclan terrorists had assault rifles and hand grenades. The total death toll from that wave of attacks stands at 130. Last year, a Muslim terrorist opened fire on police officers on the Champs Elysees with an AK-47 rifle. Gun control doesn’t stop Muslim terrorists.

Gun control doesn’t stop terrorists, but immigration laws do. They can’t kill us, if they can’t come here.

Even as lefties demand the suspension of the Second Amendment, they vehemently oppose common sense Muslim migration reform. Even as cable news filled with vocal demands for gun bans, the 4th Circuit Court of Appeals announced that President Trump wasn’t allowed to protect our children from Muslim migrant terror. The decision was met with unanimous cheers by the media.

But despite the claims by various lefty activist judges there is nothing in the Constitution mandating that Muslim terrorists be allowed to enter the United States. There is however an explicit right to bear arms.

An op-ed in the Washington Post declares that, “The Second Amendment is being turned into a suicide pact.” But it’s open borders migration from terror states that is turning immigration into a suicide pact.

Mass shootings remain a small fraction of the shootings that take place every year. Most fatal shootings are still suicides. Mass shootings, especially those carried out with rifles, are a fraction of a fraction. But Muslim mass shootings represent a growing percentage of that fraction. If the media is truly concerned about mass shootings, it must discuss the role that Muslim terrorists play in these mass shootings.

And if not, there’s no reason to take the fake concern of fake news about mass shootings seriously.

Likewise, if the media is serious about racist violence, it needs to take the Nation of Islam seriously. Its literature and paraphernalia should receive the same treatment that the Dukes of Hazzard got after the Charleston church shootings. And when that doesn’t happen, the media’s hypocrisy must be challenged.

The media wants to talk about mass shootings as if they are the work of inanimate objects. It doesn’t want to talk about motive, whether it’s mental illness, Islamic beliefs or black nationalist racism. But inanimate objects don’t kill people. Media propaganda blames the NRA and gun owners for shootings carried out by the mentally ill, and by the Muslim terrorists and the black racists who are their allies.

After Omar Mateen murdered 49 people in the Pulse nightclub massacre, Obama blamed the Muslim terrorist’s gun. He demanded that Congress “end the plague of violence that these weapons of war inflict on so many young lives”. He pontificated that “those who defend the easy accessibility of assault weapons should meet these families and explain why that makes sense.”

But inanimate objects don’t “inflict” anything. And it was up to him to explain why he believed that Muslim migrants, like Omar’s immigrant Afghan parents, should have easy access to America.

Hillary Clinton had also denounced the “weapon of war”. Then Omar’s father showed up at her rally.

The media wants us to talk about guns instead of people. It’s time to stop talking about triggers and start talking about the killers who pull them. That’s not the conversation that Obama and Hillary, that CNN and the rest of the media want us to have. But the numbers show it’s the one we need to have.


Daniel Greenfield is a Shillman Journalism Fellow at the David Horowitz Freedom Center. This article previously appeared at the Center's Front Page Magazine.

Click here to subscribe to my articles. And click here to support my work with a donation.

A Visceral Cheer for the Motorist Who Destroyed D.C.’s Speed-Trap Cameras

February 27, 2018 by Dan Mitchell @ International Liberty

I periodically fret that individualism is dying in the United States and that Americans are morphing into handout-loving Europeans.

Well, the spirit of 1776 is not completely dead. There are still some Americans who stand up against the greedy, grasping, and oppressive state. I heartily applaud the guy in this video (and not just for personal reasons) for doing what I have thought about many times.
Sonny Bunch, writing for the Washington Free-Beacon, applauds pro-liberty vandalism.
Obviously we shouldn’t cheer all those who destroy the state’s property or all those who circumvent efforts to enforce the law. But some laws are unjust. Some of the state’s property serves to oppress. Sometimes you need a hero. …some laws are good and just. Prohibitions against rape and murder, for instance. We need them. Without laws we are savages. But speed cameras are not included in the “good and just” category. They are revenue-producing monstrosities designed to suck people of their money in order to fill the coffers of bureaucrats… If the corruptocrats in D.C. try to imprison this hero, I promise to lead the resistance in an effort to spirit him southward. We shall protect you, brother. You are one of us now.
I fully concur.

Moreover, this apparently wasn’t a one-off gesture. Washingtonian reports that numerous cameras were knocked out of action.
An unidentified man suspected of smashing 11 of the District’s traffic cameras that produce tickets for drivers who speed or run red lights is being celebrated by some as a hero after DC Police released footage of one camera’s violent demise. Police say that the cameras, located mostly around Northeast DC, were reported to be malfunctioning last Tuesday. When officers checked out the locations, they found the cameras damaged as a result of vandalism.
By the way, I have no objection to cameras that nail jerks who blow through an intersection 3 seconds after a light has turned red. Those are people who risk innocent lives.


But the cameras I’ve noticed are set in spots where the speed limit is set absurdly low. In other words, they are the modern-day version of the speed traps that used to characterize corrupt small towns.

Some people object to speed cameras but think red-light cameras are okay. As already noted, I agree with their safety concerns, but that’s not how government operates.

They’ve turned red-light cameras into a scam, as explained in this Reason video. Greedy politicians actually do dangerous things like shortening the yellow light simply because they want to produce more cash. No wonder they actually cause accidents!

Moreover, Holman Jenkins of the Wall Street Journal explained several years ago how cameras are first and foremost set up to generate money, not to promote safety.

And here’s something else that irritates me. I’m guessing that the cops will put a lot of time and energy into tracking down the guy who knocked the cameras out of commission. Why? Because this is an issue that generates revenue for politicians.

Which raises the bigger issue of whether law enforcement resources are wisely allocated. We saw in Florida that local cops ignored dozens of calls and warnings about the nutjob loser who killed the students in Parkland, Florida (the FBI also dropped the ball as well since they were tipped off). I wonder how often those same cops were busy operating speed traps, engaging in asset forfeiture, and otherwise shaking down residents for cash?

The good news is that the heroic vandal who has gone after D.C.’s cameras is just the tip of the iceberg. Arizona residents basically killed a revenue-camera scam with civil disobedience. And Houston voters voted to shut down the shakedown being operated by their city government.

This spirit of resistance should be nationwide.

Here are three closing observations.
  1. Let’s hope this guy doesn’t get caught.
  2. Let’s also hope that other motorists follow his example and destroy other speed-trap cameras.
  3. Finally, let’s hope that a jury will engage in nullification if the guy is caught.
P.S. There’s also a group of people in England who are acting to thwart greedy, grasping government, albeit in a less revolutionary way.

 

The Cascading Failures of Government

The aftermath of the mass shooting in Parkland shows a breathtaking cascade of failures by various government agencies that are supposed to protect us.

William F. Marshall

The Marjorie Stoneman Douglas High School shooting illustrates the sad reality that my organization, Judicial Watch, ceaselessly tries to expose through its investigative and legal efforts: that the left's constant attempts to usurp the sovereignty of the individual in favor of the sovereignty of the state lead to the loss of liberty, self-reliance, and life itself.

These are not abstract concepts.

 As Judicial Watch has demonstrated countless times through its work, the operations of the government – at the federal, state, and local levels – and its failures are a direct threat to American lives, as we've ceded personal control to this growing monolith.............. More

Half a Century of Blaming White Racism for Black America's Problems

By Thomas Lifson March 1, 2018

For half a century, the federal government has pursued a disastrous strategy in addressing the problems of black Americans. They were designated a victim class, and enormous sums of money were expended on incentives to perpetuate that status. The welfare state has perpetuated multi-generational pathologies, while the encouragement of victimology and the blame placed on white racism have poisoned race relations instead of healing them.

It's fair to say the United States government began its long and catastrophic commitment to this approach fifty years ago today (or yesterday): February 29, 1968.

 On that day, the Kerner Commission (officially the National Advisory Commission on Civil Disorders) delivered its report (official summary; full 400-plus pages), and white racism was officially blamed for the problems of black America............. More

Worst. Oscars. Ever.

Posted: Mar 01, 2018 Derek Hunter

Have you seen more than one of the movies nominated for best picture this year at the Oscars? The answer is probably not. While two of the nominees actually found sizable audiences (Dunkirk and Get Out), the rest of the field consists of small movies the general public doesn’t care about. Coupled with what many Americans expect to be a 3-hour left-wing political seminar, the broadcast of the 90th annual Academy Awards this Sunday is shaping up to be a Spinal Tap concert-level disaster.........To Read More......

My Take - For years Hollywood spewed out trash and then told the public if they didn't like it don't see it.  Well....they're getting their wish. 

Sports and Hollywood are entertainment enterprises where the participants forgot they produce nothing society needs.  They're the beneficiaries of a financially successful society who may enjoy what they do - but no one needs them!

Sports is about watching grown men play kid's games for obscene amounts of money whose egos out of control, and Hollywood is about people who are better than most at memorizing lines someone else wrote and repeating them at someone else's direction on stage or before a camera, and somehow they're under the impression that qualifies them to tell us how the world should function? 

In the real world - no one cares two farts about what they think.   

Most of them will be out of work in a few years and broke, and no one will care.  But best of all - we won't have to listen to their idiotic rants any longer.


 

ICE chief says Oakland mayor’s warning helped criminal aliens escape raid

Washington Times February 28, 2018

More than 850 illegal immigrants managed to elude deportation officers conducting operations in Northern California this week, and the head of the deportation force on Tuesday blamed Oakland Mayor Libby Schaaf for helping some of them escape.

 More than 150 migrants were nabbed in the operations, according to U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement. Half of them had criminal convictions, ICE said.

One of the men arrested was a 38-year-old Mexican who belongs to the Sureno gang, and who had been deported four times before, authorities said. Others had weapons, domestic violence and drunken driving convictions.

But some 864 criminals ICE was seeking remain at large in the Oakland and San Francisco region, ICE said.  The operation gained attention after Ms. Schaaf issued a very public warning to her community that ICE was making arrests. She said she wanted them to be aware and to take needed steps to protect themselves.  Thomas D. Homan, the top official at ICE, said by doing that she put his officers at risk, and likely endangered her own citizens by giving some criminals a chance to escape...........To Read More....

My Take - What the mayor did is a crime.  Why hasn't the federal government arrested her? 

 

Wednesday, February 28, 2018

Fixing the Deep State Without an Article V Convention

By Rich Kozlovich

There's been a great deal of talk about convening an Article V Constitutional Convention of the States to fix the mess the federal government has become.  Well, I've decided that's potentially even more dangerous.  When the Convention was convened that created the Constitution it wasn't convened for that purpose.  The United States was organized under something called the Articles of Confederation, and it was clear from early on that arrangement had flaws that needed to be fixed, so they convened a Convention to fix that document.  The convention never fixed the Articles of Convention - they threw it out entirely, and replaced it with the Constitution.

No matter what anyone says - once an Article V Convention is convened there's absolutely nothing in the Constitution that gives Congress, or anyone else, any power over what's going to be discussed, who the delegates will be, or how they would be apportioned among the states.  Nor would anyone have the right to overturn anything they present to the States, and once it's been voted on and approved by the States, that now would become law of the land.  Neither the Congress, the Executive or the Judiciary can prevent the formation of such a Convention or overturn anything that comes out of such a convention. 

That falls entirely under the purview of the States, and pretty much the only power left to the States.  And that's a dangerous right. It takes 34 states to call a Convention of States and 38 to ratify what's presented.  Currently 28 States have passed resolutions calling for a constitutional convention, but that's based on the idea only a balanced budget amendment would be discussed.  That's an illusion!  A frightening illusion!

The problem lies in who and what America was in 1787, and what America is now.   As a society all the State's citizens functioned under a Judaic/Christian moral paradigm, and that's reflected in the Constitution.  But that nation no longer exists.  Neither party - no matter what anyone claims - functions with those moral restraints, and one of those parties fails to recognize any moral limitations.  I hate to think who the representatives would be at that convention, and what they would do. 

So, can the Deep State be fixed? There is no fixing the Deep State unless you can fix the fundamental underlying problem that created it, and it can be done without the dangers of an Article V Convention.

Nineteen thirteen was a seminal year in American history. Under the progressive movement, to which Teddy Roosevelt gave personality, they managed to pass the 16th Amendment, the 17 Amendment and created the FED, which gave almost unaccountable power over the currency to others rather than the Congress.

The 16th was income tax, and the 17th gutted the balance of power created in the Constitution by the Founding Fathers by having Senators chosen by popular vote instead of being chosen by the State governments. Senators were supposed to be de-facto ambassadors to the central government to keep it from getting out of control.  Those two amendments gutted any ability of the States to curtail the growing and out of control malignancy the federal government has now become. 

Here’s the fix! Eliminate all that excess testosterone by abolishing the FED, repeal the 16th and 17th Amendments and pass a 28th amendment.

The federal judiciary is out of control.  There's nothing in the Constitution that gives them the unbridled power they've assumed.  And the only federal court created in the Constitution is the Supreme Court.  All the rest are creations of the Congress.  And, in point of fact, the Constitution gives Congress the power to determine the jurisdiction of all the federal courts.  Congress can also overturn any federal court ruling by passing a bill that overturns any decision by any federal court. 

The federal judiciary has gotten into the mistaken belief it's their job to rewrite the laws, or make up new laws according to their personal liking.  If the Constitution is going to really be the document that governs government - and is to recognized as the real and only legitimate law of the land that governs government - it's in serious need of reinforcements. It’s time for a 28th Amendment that would impose strict term and age limits on the federal judiciary.

There are three levels of the federal judiciary- the District level, the Appeals level and the Supreme Court. Each level should have a ten year limit with a review after five years requiring a majority approval by the Senate. At each level each nominee would have to go through the same process, even if nominated to a higher court before they finish their term in a lower court. If their term runs out and they’re not nominated to a higher court they may be nominated at some point in the future.

No jurist can return to a lower court if their term runs its course at a higher level, and no jurist can ever be appointed to a court if their nomination to any court has ever been rejected by the Senate. No jurist may serve after the age of seventy.

Repeal the 16th and 17th Amendments, eliminate the FED, pass a 28th Amendment and everything else will fall into place.