Search This Blog

De Omnibus Dubitandum - Lux Veritas

Showing posts with label Billionaires. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Billionaires. Show all posts

Friday, July 4, 2025

Since Upper-Income Taxpayers Finance the American Welfare State, Leftists Should Be Nice to Rich People, Part II

July 3, 2025 by Dan Mitchell @ International Liberty

Back in 2016, I sarcastically opined that our leftist friends should be nice to upper-income 

taxpayers.

Why? Because those are the people who pay a hugely disproportionate share of taxes. So if you like big government, you should be very friendly to the people who are making it possible.

Today’s column updates this analysis.

 

I’m motivated to address this issue because the “champagne socialist” nominee to be Mayor of New York City, Zohran Mamdani, has joined other crazy leftists (see here and here) in asserting that billionaires should not exist.

In a column for National Review, Christian Schneider explains why this is very foolish. Here are some excerpts.

 

Zohran Mamdani…indicated that the wealthy had no place in his America. “I don’t think that we should have billionaires …,” he told Kristen Welker on Meet the Press. …it is that untold wealth to which people aspire that funds virtually the entirety of the federal government. We all know the numbers by now: In 2022, the top 5 percent of income earners paid 61 percent of the income taxes collected, while the bottom 50 percent of wage earners paid 3 percent of the total tax load. … 

As for the tax rates paid by the very wealthy, the U.S. Treasury Department estimates that the top 1 percent of income earners pay a tax rate of 31 percent, while the bottom 10 to 20 percent actually pay a negative tax rate of 4.6 percent. (Their rate dips into negative territory because of the benefits they receive from the tax system.) …wealthy people actually fund the programs that progressives crave… More rich people means more revenue. … 

If Mamdani rides his TikTok-fueled wave into the mayor’s office, the billionaires of New York may take their investments and innovations elsewhere. At that point, the young socialist will finally get schooled in economics.

Let’s examine some more data on tax burdens for upper-income taxpayers. Here’s a chart showing that the top-10 percent pay a hugely disproportionate share of income taxes.

What about the super-rich as opposed to run-of-the-mill upper-income households?

Well, in the last year of the Biden Administration, some economists at the Treasury Department calculated tax burdens on these households (top .0005 percent and above).

Scott Hodge then put this data into an easy-to-understand chart. As you can see, these people pay absurdly high tax rates.

This data should be compelling. Our tax system targets rich people and those upper-income taxpayers finance the lion’s share of a bloated federal government.

Sadly, I don’t think this will be persuasive to our friends on the left because maximizing revenue is not their top goal.

Sensible people, by contrast, want there to be more rich people (assuming, of course, they earn money honestly).

Tuesday, May 13, 2025

Billionaire-Funded Communists Rally Against Billionaires

By Daniel Greenfield @ Sultan Knish Blog 

The first of May for most people means flowers and springtime, but for Communists it’s May Day, a time to wear red, scrawl something on a poster and shout at people at a big rally.

And perhaps block traffic.

May Day 2025 is being billed as a major protest turnout event. In New York City, the Democratic Socialists of America, the Communist Party, a few useless unions, and Bend the Arc will be rallying in the streets to “stop the billionaire takeover”. Since Bend the Arc is run and funded by Alex Soros, a billionaire scion notorious for his Hampton parties, the takeover is already here.

George Soros, Alex’s dad, put his billions to work building up the American Left.

The Working Families Party, which benefited from hundreds of thousands of dollars in Soros money for its candidates, is another participant in the May Day anti-billionaire rallies. Its Instagram motto is “in this house we bully billionaires.” A video put out by WFP claims that the fight is “regular folk against the ultra wealthy” and warns against a “government run by billionaires.” That didn’t seem to be a problem when Soros handed out $20 million to a WFP coalition or when his pro-crime Justice and Public Safety PAC made the WFP’s New York party its third largest recipient of campaign cash in the 2020 election cycle or when the same Soros PAC provided $700,000 to the campaign of a pro-crime WFP prosecutor in Texas.

The WFP doesn’t bully billionaires: it’s wholly owned by a family of billionaires.

The NYCLU, another participant in the anti-billionaire rally, is a revolving door for Soros people, including Aryeh Neier, who went on to be the first president of Soros’ Open Society Institute, and Sebastian Krueger, NYCLU’s comms chief who formerly served that role for Open Society.

Swing Left, yet another participant, was backed by the Democracy Alliance whose members include not only Soros, but Progressive Insurance chair Peter Lewis, a billionaire, Taco Bell heir Rob McKay, San Francisco billionaire Tom Steyer, and Facebook co-founder Chris Hughes, but now hosts a “Mothers and Others Standing Against Bullies, Billionaires and fascism”.

The Center for Popular Democracy will be holding a ‘virtual’ May Day rally against “billionaire profiteers”. The Center was funded by Hansjörg Wyss, the richest man in Switzerland who made his money through medical technology that ended up killing 5 people after admitting to illegally experimenting on its patients. That’s a whole other kind of billionaire profiteering.

Other “popular democracy” donors to the Center include the Ford Foundation, with assets of over $16 billion, the W.K. Kellogg Foundation and the William and Flora Hewlett Foundation of the Hewlett-Packard co-founder. There’s nothing popular or democratic about any of this.

The May Day rallies are going to send a message to Trump, Musk “and the rest of the billionaire oligarchs trying to destroy our democracy” warned Saqib Bhatti, a Pakistani Muslim immigrant who heads the Action Center on Race & the Economy. The Center, also known as ACRE, was funded through the ARCA Foundation started by R. J. Reynolds tobacco heiress Nancy Susan Reynolds, and presided over by Smith W. Bagley, the next heir in line, a major Democrat donor, once indicted for stock manipulation (Biden appointed his wife Elizabeth as the ambassador to Brazil) and the foundation is now headed by the latest tobacco heiress: Nicole Bagley.

R.J. Reynolds brands include everything from Newports to Camels to Lucky Strike cigarettes.

Saqib Bhatti, Acre’s head, funded by a billionaire’s ‘memorial grant’ rails against billionaires and will rail some more at the May Day rally even though he owes his career to them which included a fellowship from the radical leftist Nathan Cummings Foundation funded by by the Cummings heirs of the Sara Lee company.

Billionaires: what would the Left do without ‘em?

The anti-billionaire May Day rallies are a billionaire-funded astroturf campaign. They’re not actually against billionaires or even against billionaires buying political influence. They’re radical leftists funded by leftist billionaires insincerely attacking Trump using anti-capitalist rhetoric.

Subtract the billionaires, millionaires, heirs and heiresses to famous companies and the American Left would consist of a few hundred Marxist grad students and the leaders of some of the more useless unions who are also showing up and holding their own May Day events.

Billionaires built the American Left. They provided employment for thousands of Marxist grad students who became professional full-time activists. They created professional organizations and used the dot com model to create accelerators, funding models, consultants and an entire complicated network of organizations that make the old Communist Party look crude and clunky.

The May Day rallies carry the logos of hundreds of organizations, many of them fake or shells for other groups, to manufacture the illusion of a movement. The old school Communist front groups long ago went digital with a social media presence, bots and interchangeable employees who move between one front group and another. These aren’t new ideas, but the slickness and sleekness, the corporate logos and the sheer complexity of it is corporate Communism.

It turns out that the revolution will be brought to you by, if not Xerox, but by Hewlett Packard, it may not go well with Coke, but it will go well with a Camel, and it will not only be televised but featured on Instagram, TikTok, Facebook and Twitter , it will be hailed as transformative by NBC, CBS and CNN, because the revolution is fake. It’s as fake as billionaires funding anti-billionaire rallies to convince the American people to oppose the billionaires they don’t like.

All the leftist agitprop rhetoric about fighting billionaires to save democracy is an attempt to distract the public from the fact that they are a plot by billionaires to destroy democracy.

The Left has never been a movement of the people. It’s an elitist psyop led by the children of the rich to seize power and destroy the power of the people. Its heroes and leaders, whether Lenin, Mao or Che came from the elites, not the working class, and the only outcome of its revolutions was the destruction of the hopes and the future of the farmers and workers they championed.

After suffering a stinging defeat in 2024 from the working class, the billionaire-funded Communists want to pretend that they’re against billionaires and for the working class, but no matter how many grad students wave posters in public squares, no one is buying it anymore.

Daniel Greenfield is a Shillman Journalism Fellow at the David Horowitz Freedom Center. This article previously appeared at the Center's Front Page Magazine. Click here to subscribe to my articles. And click here to support my work with a donation.  Thank you for reading.

 

Thursday, June 13, 2024

Three Cheers for (the Right Kind of) Rich People

June 12, 2024 by Dan Mitchell

My view on rich people is very simple.

I applaud them if they earn their money honestly (through voluntary exchange in a free market economy). And I want more people to become rich in the same way.

" />

Especially since the rest of us get richer when they get richer.

But if they get rich by looting the public (via interventionist policies such as bailouts, subsidies, protectionism, or industrial policy), then they deserve disdain.

The good news is that most super-rich people in the United States are in the first category.

But that’s not true everywhere. In nations with dirigiste policies, such as Russia, you’re more likely to find rich people from the second category.

Some of our friends on the left, however, fail to distinguish between good rich people and bad rich people. For some of them, all rich people are the enemy.

Today’s column will provide a different perspective.

Michael Strain of the American Enterprise Institute recently wrote that billionaires should be celebrated.


…we should want more billionaires, not fewer. Billionaire innovators create enormous value for society. In a 2004 paper, the Nobel laureate economist William D. Nordhaus found “that only a minuscule fraction” – about 2.2% – “of the social returns from technological advances” accrued to innovators themselves. The rest of the benefits (which is to say, almost all of them) went to consumers. …Amazon founder Jeff Bezos is worth $170 billion.

Extrapolating from Nordhaus’s findings, one could conclude that Bezos has created over $8 trillion – more than one-third of the United States’ annual GDP – in value for society. For example, Amazon has reduced the price of many consumer goods and freed up an enormous amount of time for millions of Americans… Bezos, meanwhile, has received only a tiny slice of those social benefits. …the same logic can be applied to billionaires from any professional background.

For example, Wall Street titans create value by efficiently allocating capital throughout the economy. Over time, this lowers costs and spurs productivity and innovation, all of which benefit millions of households and businesses. …Take a look at the top ten billionaires…

They are largely self-made innovators who have changed the way we live… None of them are “policy failures.” Rather than wishing they did not exist, we should be thrilled that they do. The value they have created for millions of people around the world dwarfs their net worth.

On the other side of the Atlantic Ocean, James Quarmby expressed similar sentiments in a column for the Telegraph.

Here are some excerpts.


In most of the world wealth is celebrated; people aspire to be wealthy and admire those who accumulate it. …This notion, and the concomitant aspiration for wealth, has built the most successful and dynamic economy the modern world has ever seen. …but here in the UK and the rest of Europe, …we are witnessing increased suspicion and hostility towards the wealthy. …

The super-rich are often portrayed in the media as responsible for all manner of social evils… Overall, the top 1pc of taxpayers pay nearly 29pc of all income tax, and the top 10pc pay a full 60pc – that’s funding a lot of doctors, nurses and other front-line services and, without them, the rest of us would pay even more. So perhaps it’s time for phrases such as the “filthy rich” to disappear. Instead of vilifying the wealthy, we should celebrate them.

So why do folks on the left have such hostility to successful people?

 

In part, the answer is naked envy. They resent that others have been so successful and want to tear them down.

In part, the answer is economic illiteracy, especially the zero-sum belief that rich people mean less income for everyone else.

The bottom line is that a society that rewards entrepreneurship and success will be much better off than a society that penalizes those traits.

Monday, May 27, 2024

Bring in the Clowns, There Needs to be Clowns!

By Rich Kozlovich

The title to this piece is based on the song, Send in the Clowns.  Did you ever ask what that means?  '“Send in the Clowns,” is a metaphor for the moment in a play when things are falling apart and, to keep the audience diverted from the chaos, somebody tells a few jokes."   In the play that made this song popular the story was about the unhappy and painful chaos that can take place in peoples lives, and that fits with the story I'm trying to tell.  The difference is in the play, there were no clowns.  The story I'm telling is full of clowns.

On September 5, 1651 Oliver Cromwell's forces defeated the forces of Charles II.  Later as they were marching into London the crowds cheered vigorously, and one of his followers was enthralled with the cheering.  Cromwell put a reality damper on that saying: 

“Do not trust to the cheering, for those very persons would shout as much if you and I were going to be hanged.”

Around 25,000 cheering Bronx citizens attended a Trump rally, and it shocked Democrats, after all, this is New York, this can't be happening!  The governor of New York called them "a bunch of clowns", and the media insisted it doesn't mean anything. 

As my regular readers know I'm a real fan of American Thinker, which I consider one of the very best news sites in the nation.  On Saturday Monica Showalter, one of my favorite writers, posted this piece, What the Bronx voters who've flipped to Trump are saying, quoting one of the attendees:

Jerry Evans, a registered Democrat in New York City, had never attended a political rally before Thursday.  But speaking with Newsweek at Donald Trump's campaign event in the South Bronx, Evans said that he turned out to show support for the former president because he feels "very strongly about how the border's going."...... "You know, I said, why is Biden giving them the red carpet treatment?"...... "He's giving them everything—giving them housing, giving them shelter, giving them money, cash—and people who live here can't get that."

She went on to ask:

How many thousands of them in that 25,000 crowd are thinking the same thing?

No matter how many are thinking along those lines, here's what we need to ask.  Is this enlightenment permanent?   Answer: Nah, it isn't!  This is just a “my ox is bring gored” reaction. If their ox wasn’t being gored they’d be just fine with Biden and all the insanity and treason being promoted by the left.

It will be the same with secular Jews. If they vote for Trump over Biden’s abandonment of Israel and Trump wins, once Trump has dealt with that crisis, and their ox is no longer being gored, they’ll abandon Trump and the Republicans in a nanosecond.  They will revert to type, because culture is king, and leftism is part and parcel of the culture of secular Jews.

I'm reading about all this outrage over these antisemitic protests on America's college campuses, and the downward spiraling standards that's created a lack of adequate education, all very expensive mind you, from parents and donors.  And of course were expected to believe these were just unorganized spontaneous grass roots eruptions at 47 universities....at the same time.  And we're expected to think those declining standards to allow incompetent DEI students to graduate was all brand new.    

Well, I'm sorry, I just have to role my eyes and chuckle. All of a sudden they're outraged?  This insanity has been going on for decades and its wasn't obvious to them for all these decades?

These are really smart, successful, and intelligent people, and yet.... they're shocked...shocked I tell you....... just like Captain Renault, to find that corruption has been going on there. They're shocked academia has been corrupted with collapsing standards, to meet idiotic DEI demands.

They're shocked that academia is a cultural, intellectual, and morally corrupt mephitic ooze of inbreeding, being led by grossly overpaid, blatantly incompetent DEI racists, and leftist/Marxist/anti-American ideologues, many of whom are now being exposed as plagiarists, who have been turning out graduates who can't read, write, or have a working knowledge of history, geography, or how and why America is unique in all of world history, or are even competent in their fields of study.  And that it's been going on for decades.

UCLA is turning out medical students that are a disaster, all due to the admittance of low-performing students based on affirmative action preferences.  DEI admittees, which couldn't cut it, so that required lowering the standards across the board in order to graduate unaccomplished students.   Unqualified doctors who will soon be killing people because they're incompetent, and most likely weren't very smart or very motivated in the first place. 
 
Let's try and get this right once, just once, please.  Diversity without accomplishment is philosophy without form and incompetence without consequence.  And we're expected to believe they just now noticed all that? Now, I'm shocked, shocked I tell you!

Billionaires like Stephan Schwarzman all over the nation are claiming they're going to support Trump.  Wow!  That's great, right?  Let's try and get this right once, just once, please.  Billionaires are at best leaky vessels as allies, and would easily and quickly abandon Trump in the blink of an eye. Just like Schwarzman, they are not conservatives, and the only moral foundation they have is opportunistic.  “I’m in it for me, get used to it.... peasant”!  They would sell the nation and everyone in it for 12 pieces of silver.

One of the foundational truths I’ve discovered in my 78 years there is no Book of Fair, and what's fair is always predicated on “who’s ox is being gored”.  Right now Biden is goring the oxen of his entire base, and they don't think it's fair. But understand this, if Kennedy was the Democrat pick, they would vote for Kennedy in a heart beat, and just because he got a couple of things right, that doesn’t change the fact he’s just as radical as Biden. 

What should shock every conservative who supports traditional values is all this outrage, and all this discontent, will soon pass and they'll be right back to being part and parcel of the problem once again.  Leftism is a cultural mental disorder, predicated on greed, envy, lust, hate, violence, and self interest, from which most leftists cannot be cured, and culture is king!  

So, don't let the cheering fool you.  People without a solid moral foundation have meandering values that allow them to rationalize their reversion to acts of self interest and corruption.   Cromwell defeated a corrupt King in 1651, and then had to dissolve Parliament in 1653 for becoming corrupt for their own ends.  Here's one of my favorite quotes from Oliver Cromwell, that is totally applicable to our modern day state of corruption. 

“It is high time for me to put an end to your sitting in this place, which you have dishonored by your contempt of all virtue, and defiled by your practice of every vice; ye are a factious crew, and enemies to all good government; ye are a pack of mercenary wretches, and would like Esau sell your country for a mess of pottage, and like Judas betray your God for a few pieces of money.

Is there a single virtue now remaining amongst you? Is there one vice you do not possess? Ye have no more religion than my horse; gold is your God; which of you have not barter'd your conscience for bribes? Is there a man amongst you that has the least care for the good of the Commonwealth?

Ye sordid prostitutes have you not defil'd this sacred place, and turn'd the Lord's temple into a den of thieves, by your immoral principles and wicked practices? Ye are grown intolerably odious to the whole nation; you were deputed here by the people to get grievances redress'd, are yourselves gone! So! Take away that shining bauble there, and lock up the doors.

In the name of God, go!  

Do I hear a Second for that motion!

Friday, November 17, 2023

Exclusive—Seamus Bruner Blows the Lid Off the Agenda of Billionaire ‘Controligarchs’

 
 Members of the billionaire class have an agenda to control the masses and grow their own profits, Seamus Bruner reveals in his new book, Controligarchs: Exposing the Billionaire Class, their Secret Deals, and the Globalist Plot to Dominate Your Life. Bruner, the director of research at Peter Schweizer’s Government Accountability Institute, spoke with SiriusXM’s Breitbart News Daily about Controligarchs, which hits bookstands Tuesday. He began by reading the following quotation from billionaire David Rockefeller’s 2002 memoir, which Bruner used to open the first chapter of Controligarchs:

Some even believe we are part of a secret [club] working against the best interests of the United States, characterizing my family and me as “internationalists” and of conspiring with others around the world to build a more integrated global political and economic structure–one world, if you will. If that’s the charge, I stand guilty, and I am proud of it.

Bruner said he was “stunned” to discover that this quote is authentic.............To Read More...Much More.....

Tuesday, September 15, 2020

The Billionaire Backers of the ‘Insurrection’

The mostly behind-the-scenes attempt between Election Day and Inauguration Day to prevent Donald Trump from taking office the first time will go public in 2020.

 

As I reported last week, a cabal of Democrats and NeverTrump Republicans are plotting a post-election civil war of sorts to make sure Joe Biden assumes the presidency even if Donald Trump legitimately wins. “It’s insurrection,” President Trump said on Fox News last week when asked about the widely-circulated plan. “We’ll put them down very quickly if they do that.”

Let’s hope. A document released last month by the Transition Integrity Project, a headfake name to give the depraved group the appearance of decency, is a shocking battle plan that would plunge the country into more chaos. The same agitators on the Left and NeverTrump Right who’ve stoked nonstop political upheaval over the past four years will exploit our current instability to throw the election to the Democrats. 

But this is more than the far-fetched hallucinations of political outcasts. The mayhem they’ve been war-gaming will be heavily funded by a number of Trump-hating billionaires, and those people have no intention of losing out on their investment.

The mostly behind-the-scenes attempt between Election Day and Inauguration Day to prevent Donald Trump from taking office the first time—one that miraculously failed despite help from the media and the most powerful government agencies in the world—will go public in 2020. And instead of help from James Comey, Jim Clapper, or John Brennan, the 2020 version will be bolstered by the likes of George Soros, Tom Steyer, Pierre Omidyar, a member of the Rupert Murdoch family, and Big Tech titans among others...........To Read More....

Sunday, March 3, 2019

Are Billionaires Good or Bad?

February 23, 2019 by Dan Mitchell @ International Liberty
 
I don’t always fully agree with Will Wilkinson of the Niskanen Institute, but I’m an avid reader of his work because he writes intelligently on issues that I care about.

I especially like it when we’re on the same side. A good example is his recent column about billionaires in the New York Times. He starts by observing that politicians such as Bernie Sanders and Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez are demonizing the super-rich.
Socialists have long held that large stores of private wealth are tantamount to violence against those in need. …Thanks at least in part to Bernie Sanders and the sizzling rise of Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez,… Enthusiasm for radical leveling is whistling out of the hard-left fringe… Ms. Ocasio-Cortez’s policy adviser, Dan Riffle, contends that “every billionaire is a policy failure”… He’d like to see the 2020 Democratic primary contenders answer a question: Can it be morally appropriate for anyone to be a billionaire?
Will answers Mr. Riffle’s question by noting that the world’s most successful nations operate on the principles of classical liberalism.
…the existence of virtuous three-comma fortunes is a sign not of failure but of supreme policy success. …The empirical record is quite clear about the general form of national political economy that produces the happiest, healthiest, wealthiest, freest and longest lives. There’s no pithy name for it, so we’ll have to settle for “liberal-democratic welfare-state capitalism.” There’s a “social democratic” version, which is what you get in countries like Sweden, Norway and the Netherlands. And there’s a “neoliberal”  (usually English-speaking) version, which is what you get in countries like Canada, New Zealand and the United States. …in comparative terms, they’re all insanely great. The typical citizen of these countries is as well-off as human beings have ever been. …guess what? There are billionaires in all of them. Egalitarian Sweden, an object of ardent progressive adoration, has more billionaires per capita than the United States.
Spot on.

Nations with a lot of economic freedom produce both billionaires and a high quality of life for ordinary people.

And, yes, that does include some Northern European welfare states (though, if I wrote the column, I would have noted that those nations became rich before welfare states were adopted).

But let’s not digress. Here’s the accompanying chart for Will’s column, which compares how nations score on the U.N.’s Human Development Index (based on lifespans, education, and income) and how many billionaires they have as a share of their populations.


I can’t resist pointing out that Hong Kong and Singapore both score highly, so the “welfare-state” part of “liberal-democratic welfare-state capitalism” certainly isn’t necessary to get on this list.
Indeed, the same is true of the other countries on the list if you look at the history of their economic development.

But I’m digressing again. Let’s get back to the column.

Will issues a very relevant challenge to the class-warfare crowd.
So what’s the problem? Preventing billion-dollar hoards guards against the bad consequences of … having the best sort of polity that has ever existed? …Inspect any credible international ranking of countries by democratic quality, equal treatment under the law or level of personal freedom. You’ll find the same passel of billionaire-tolerant states again and again. If there are billionaires in all the places where people flourish best, why think getting rid of them will make things go better?
And he makes a final point about how honestly earned wealth (i.e., not using government coercion) produces big benefits for the rest of us.
…there’s a big moral difference between positive-sum wealth production and zero-sum wealth extraction — a difference that corresponds to a rough-and-ready distinction between the deserving and undeserving rich. The distinction is sound because there’s a proven a way to make a moral killing: improve a huge number of other people’s lives while capturing a tiny slice of the surplus value. …According to William Nordhaus, the Nobel Prize-winning economist, innovators capture about 2 percent of the economic value they create. The rest of it accrues to consumers. Whatever that is, it’s not a raw deal. The accumulation of these innovations over time is the mechanism that drives compounding economic growth, which accounts for a vast improvement over the past 100 years in the typical American standard of living. Some people may have made an ungodly sum in the course of helping make this humanitarian miracle happen, but that’s O.K.
It’s not just O.K., it’s great news.

This is what has produced the unparalleled prosperity of western nations.

Though I fear some of our friends on the left won’t be convinced. At least not the ones who are fixated on inequality.

Some of them very openly admit they are willing to hurt lower-income and middle-class people so long as rich people suffer even more. The International Monetary Fund has even produced studies (yes, more than one!) justifying this harsh ideological view.

Margaret Thatcher is spinning in her grave.

P.S. There is a “Modest Proposal” to “solve” inequality by eliminating the rich.