Search This Blog

De Omnibus Dubitandum - Lux Veritas

Showing posts with label Rich. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Rich. Show all posts

Friday, October 4, 2024

Growth Should Trump Envy

October 3, 2024 by Dan Mitchell @ International Liberty

I frequently cite a column I wrote in 2017 about how 1980-2010 was a reasonably good era for China, thanks to a bit of economic liberalization.

My leftist friends will say that can’t be true because inequality increased during those decades.

I respond by pointing out that average incomes dramatically increased during those 30 years and there was a huge reduction in poverty.

The lesson to be learned (echoing my Eighth Theorem of Government) is that nobody should care if some people get richer faster than others get richer. The goal should be better policy so everyone has the chance to rise as far and as fast as possible, given their talents, abilities, and willingness to work hard.

Today, let’s look at American history to see the same principle at work.

Here’s a chart from Professor Vincent Geloso looking at data from 1870 to 1910. It shows what happened to inequality in various nations on the vertical axis (as measured by income share of the top 1 percent) and average income (as measured by per-capita income for the bottom 90 percent).

The first thing to notice is that inequality increased in every nation and per-capita income increased in every country.

But the data from the United States is particularly instructive. Here’s some of what Geloso shared in a tweet.

America had a very mild increase in inequality between 1870 and 1910… However, its also in America that the living standard of the bottom 90% surged the most. By 1910, their living standard had increased by a factor of 2.37. Only Canada got close to that increase and it was still immensely behind America. …only America went fast and hard at improving the living standards of the bottom 90%. By 1910, America not only had confirmed its historical position as the “Best Poor Man’s Country”, it had widened the lead. No country ever before witnessed such a level of living standards for the poor as witnessed in America.

Given this information (as well as the data about China), the challenge for my left-leaning friends who fixate on inequality is deciding which of these two options they prefer.

  1. Do they hate the rich so much that they are willing to reduce living standards for lower-income people so long as upper-income people suffer an even greater reduction?
  2. Do they love the poor so much that they are willing to let rich people get richer (even disproportionately richer) so long as poor people get to enjoy higher living standards?

Sadly, many folks on the left pick option #1. They hate the rich more than they care about the poor.

P.S. Readers interested in this issue will appreciate this column and this set of tweets.

P.P.S. This four-part series (here, here, here, and here) also is very relevant.

Thursday, June 13, 2024

Three Cheers for (the Right Kind of) Rich People

June 12, 2024 by Dan Mitchell

My view on rich people is very simple.

I applaud them if they earn their money honestly (through voluntary exchange in a free market economy). And I want more people to become rich in the same way.

" />

Especially since the rest of us get richer when they get richer.

But if they get rich by looting the public (via interventionist policies such as bailouts, subsidies, protectionism, or industrial policy), then they deserve disdain.

The good news is that most super-rich people in the United States are in the first category.

But that’s not true everywhere. In nations with dirigiste policies, such as Russia, you’re more likely to find rich people from the second category.

Some of our friends on the left, however, fail to distinguish between good rich people and bad rich people. For some of them, all rich people are the enemy.

Today’s column will provide a different perspective.

Michael Strain of the American Enterprise Institute recently wrote that billionaires should be celebrated.


…we should want more billionaires, not fewer. Billionaire innovators create enormous value for society. In a 2004 paper, the Nobel laureate economist William D. Nordhaus found “that only a minuscule fraction” – about 2.2% – “of the social returns from technological advances” accrued to innovators themselves. The rest of the benefits (which is to say, almost all of them) went to consumers. …Amazon founder Jeff Bezos is worth $170 billion.

Extrapolating from Nordhaus’s findings, one could conclude that Bezos has created over $8 trillion – more than one-third of the United States’ annual GDP – in value for society. For example, Amazon has reduced the price of many consumer goods and freed up an enormous amount of time for millions of Americans… Bezos, meanwhile, has received only a tiny slice of those social benefits. …the same logic can be applied to billionaires from any professional background.

For example, Wall Street titans create value by efficiently allocating capital throughout the economy. Over time, this lowers costs and spurs productivity and innovation, all of which benefit millions of households and businesses. …Take a look at the top ten billionaires…

They are largely self-made innovators who have changed the way we live… None of them are “policy failures.” Rather than wishing they did not exist, we should be thrilled that they do. The value they have created for millions of people around the world dwarfs their net worth.

On the other side of the Atlantic Ocean, James Quarmby expressed similar sentiments in a column for the Telegraph.

Here are some excerpts.


In most of the world wealth is celebrated; people aspire to be wealthy and admire those who accumulate it. …This notion, and the concomitant aspiration for wealth, has built the most successful and dynamic economy the modern world has ever seen. …but here in the UK and the rest of Europe, …we are witnessing increased suspicion and hostility towards the wealthy. …

The super-rich are often portrayed in the media as responsible for all manner of social evils… Overall, the top 1pc of taxpayers pay nearly 29pc of all income tax, and the top 10pc pay a full 60pc – that’s funding a lot of doctors, nurses and other front-line services and, without them, the rest of us would pay even more. So perhaps it’s time for phrases such as the “filthy rich” to disappear. Instead of vilifying the wealthy, we should celebrate them.

So why do folks on the left have such hostility to successful people?

 

In part, the answer is naked envy. They resent that others have been so successful and want to tear them down.

In part, the answer is economic illiteracy, especially the zero-sum belief that rich people mean less income for everyone else.

The bottom line is that a society that rewards entrepreneurship and success will be much better off than a society that penalizes those traits.

Tuesday, April 13, 2021

Moral Inequality and Immoral Inequality

April 12, 2021 by Dan Mitchell @ International Liberty

While debunking OECD and IMF research on inequality, I explained that it’s important to distinguish between income that is earned honestly and loot that is obtained thanks to government cronyism.

That’s also the message of this video from the Hoover Institution.


In the video, David Henderson contrasts how our lives are improved when an entrepreneur develops a new product.

The entrepreneur almost surely gets richer faster than we get richer, but we all wind up better off. Indeed, there’s a clear relationship between the share of rich people in a society and overall prosperity.

 

And that’s a good description of what has actually happened in market-oriented nations such as the United States.  Heck, it even happened to some degree in China when there was partial reform. By contrast, government favoritism is a recipe for inefficiency and stagnation (and since LBJ was an awful president, I like that David used him for the example of corrupt cronyism). In a column for CapX, Andrew Lilico correctly differentiates between moral inequality and immoral inequality.


The only legitimate questions about the distribution of wealth concern whether it is truly the property of those that possess it, as opposed to having stolen or extorted it. …Wealth is property. If it has been innocently acquired, people should be able to enjoy their property without censure or the (quite incorrect) suggestion that their flourishing causes others harm.

Not only is it incorrect to suggest that one person’s flourishing causes harm to others, it is completely wrong.   As pointed out in the video, Nobel Prize-winning economist William Nordhaus calculated that entrepreneurs only capture a tiny fraction (2.2 percent) of the wealth they create for society. That means 97.8 percent for the rest of us.

Leftist Fairness

And other academic scholars have produced similar results. The bottom line is that the recipe for growth and prosperity is the same recipe for helping the less fortunate.

P.S. As you can see from his Wikipedia page, Professor Nordhaus is not a libertarian or conservative, so it should be clear he wasn’t trying to come up with a number to justify capitalism.

P.P.S. I also recommend my four-part series (see here, here, here, and here) on why we should care about poverty reduction rather than pushing for coerced equality, as well as my two-part series (here and here) on how statist policies produce the immoral type of inequality.

Monday, October 29, 2012

The “Evil Rich” Give Back By Creating Jobs! We Need To Get That!

By Rich Kozlovich
An article appeared on the 26th by Daniel Halper entitled, “Over $60,000 in Welfare Spent Per Household in Poverty”. The article went on to say that;
"According to the Census’s American Community Survey, the number of households with incomes below the poverty line in 2011 was 16,807,795," the Senate Budget Committee notes. "If you divide total federal and state spending by the number of households with incomes below the poverty line, the average spending per household in poverty was $61,194 in 2011."    It further went on to say that; "If the spending on these programs were converted into cash, and distributed exclusively to the nation’s households below the poverty line, this cash amount would be over 2.5 times the federal poverty threshold for a family of four, which in 2011 was $22,350 (see table in this link)."
The question I have always had when I hear this stuff about how much the nation spends on eradicating poverty I keep asking myself….where in the world has all that money gone?  Clearly it isn’t going to the poor.  If when President Lyndon B. Johnson started his Great Society programs we had given every poor man, woman and child in the nation a million dollars and told them they were then on their own, it seems to me we would have saved billions.  Let’s explore this whole problem. 
When the housing market collapsed due to the incentives created by Jimmy Carter's Community Reinvestment Act a lady, who I have known for years, told me she was going to lose her house.  I was amazed because for many years her husband had worked at a very well paying job, and they had been in the house for 27 years. Yet they still owned over $130,000, and now unfortunately her husband had lost his job permanently, and was having serious health problems that was going to keep him out of the job market.   And she wanted the government to bail her out…..and it was time for the rich need to start giving back. 
Sound familiar?  So I asked her what it was that she gave to the rich that required them to give back anything to her and how much?  Of course she touted the argument about the roads, bridges and ….well you get the idea.  An argument that is functionally ridiculous; after all, where did they think the money to build all that stuff came from in the first place anyway?  The government has no money except that which they extort (a necessary extortion to maintain a stable society, but it is nonetheless done by force of law, making it extortion) from the people, but that is what is heard on the news from the left stream media, politicians and bureaucrats, so why wouldn’t someone in this situation jump on this bandwagon? 
Then I told her that “The Rich” give back constantly.  She of course laughed, snorted and looked at me as if she was talking to an idiot child.  I then asked her how much tax was taken out of her paycheck.  I then went on to outline the percentages of who pays taxes, how much they pay, and how many are paying nothing in federal income taxes at all.  Then I told her that in point of fact it is the rich that pay all the taxes….100% of all taxes.  Then I asked her where that tax money came from.  None of that was her money until she received the check.  It was the owner’s money.  All the Federal, State, Local, Medicare/Medicaid and Social Security taxes paid started out as the owner’s money.  She had no money unless it was given to her from the owner of the company.  Of course she worked for it, but if the owner said she was fired…..then she had no money, because it is only her money when the owner gives it to her for labors performed…but it originated from someone else’s pocket.  That nebulous reviled evil group called…”The Rich”!
Then came the old class warfare red herring about how well they live compared to the rest of us.  Well….so what?  I personally could care less how big someone lives their life as long as they can pay for it.  I don’t care how they got that rich as long as they didn’t steal it.  I don’t care if it is worked for or it was inherited.  It isn’t my business nor is it my concern what they do with their money.  In America anyone can become wealthy if they devote their lives to it and their children can reap the rewards….and should reap the rewards.  It is obscene for the government to come in and steal a major part of a family’s fortune (a fortune that huge amounts of taxes had already been paid on) when the parents die due to death taxes. Those who believe this is right are morally defective. 
I went on to tell her of a man who built a five million dollar home, twenty years ago, when a five million dollar home was a lot more  money than it was just before the housing collapse.  She said that was the kind of thing she was talking about.  I said this is the kind of give back I am talking about.  She was clearly puzzled so I went on to ask her a series of question. I asked her how much cement did the man pour in laying the foundation?  The answer was none.  How many cement blocks did he lay in building the basement? None!  How many nails did he drive building the frame?  None! How many sheets of dry wall did he hang?  None!  How much paint did he put on the walls?  None!  He hired someone to do it all!  Then he filled the house with carpeting and furniture.  Stuff that someone had to produce, sell, transport and deliver!  Then after all of that was done he hired a housekeeper, a grounds keeper and an exterminator.  He keeps giving back because he created jobs.  All the giving back the “evil” and reviled “Rich” do is based on long term solutions that work.  They create jobs! 
I told her the only thing I resent about this man is that he didn’t build ten five million dollar houses, because every penny went directly back to the community, where they spent it on houses, carpeting, dining out, going to the movies or whatever else they darned well pleased, and without any strings attached as to what they could do with it,  All this was done without going through a government that wastes untold millions on themselves and frivolous spending that had done nothing to end the poverty targeted by Johnson’s Great Society programs.  If that five million had gone to the government first just how much does anyone think would have made it back to the community….and without strings?   
As for my friend; how did she get into this mess?  She loved credit cards; hating making payments and the high interests so kept taking out loans on her home to pay her credit cards off.  And she did it for years.  For the record.  I resent the government bailing out Wall Street, and General Motors.  Wall Street became seriously corrupted due to the Community Reinvestment Act; but they were still chose a course of corruption nonetheless, and should have been allowed to fail and many of them should have gone to jail….including the Fanny Mae and Freddie Mac bosses along with Sen. Chris Dodd and Rep. Barney Frank.  General Motors failed because it was the accumulation of years of bad decisions and they didn’t have the guts to stand up to the unions.  Their failure was of their own making and should have been allowed to go through the legal bankruptcy system instead of the governments illegal solution. 

Also….for the record.  I’m not one of the “Evil Rich”.  I wouldn’t mind being one of them, but having a great deal of money and owning a lot of things never interested me.  Perhaps that's a serious character flaw, but I never needed all of that to feel just as good as anyone else.  I never felt wealth made the man!  As long as they live honorable lives I don’t look down on people who have little, and I don’t look up to people because of their prominence in life or their income……as my friends will attest. 

I grew up in Southwest Pennsylvania, which during my youth was considered part of poverty stricken Appalachia.  I always thought they were talking about all the people around us.  Everyone had so little I didn't know we were poor.  I used to say there was something to be said for having grown up in poverty and not knowing it.  I have revised that.  I now realize that I grew up in a rural mountain area where many had gardens, farms, hunted, fished, and canned their own foods, which created a general attitude of being self sufficient.  That is what creates an attitude of worth in people.  Self sufficiency!  Knowing you can make it on your own.  That is what the “Rich” give back when they create jobs.     
If a society can't define things properly it can't fix its problems.  Perhaps we just need to reevaluate and find out who the "Evil" really are.   Because it isn't the "Rich"!