How did a 13-year-old boy end up in an alley with a gun at 2:30 on a Monday morning?
On March 29, just after 2:30 AM,
Chicago’s ShotSpotter alert system detected eight or nine gunshots in
the West Side, largely Latino, neighborhood of Little Village, where
gangs like the Latin Kings and Two Six have made gunplay a regular part
of life. Chicago police officer Eric Stillman and his partner sped
toward the gunshots once they received the ShotSpotter alert, doubtless
hoping to nab the perpetrators and spare the community additional
carnage. When they arrived on the scene, almost immediately after those
shots were fired, they happened upon two individuals. One of them—who we
now know to be 13-year-old Adam Toledo—took off on foot and, at one
point, pulled a gun with his right hand. Stillman gave chase, and the
world saw what happened next—at least the part highlighted (and, in one
case, deceptively edited) by media outlets, many of which elided the actual events of Toledo’s shooting.
The immediate cause of Toledo’s death was the bullet fired by Officer
Stillman. But it’s worth examining how a 13-year-old boy ended up in a
full sprint through a dark alley at 2:30 AM with a gun in his hand and a police officer on his tail.
Start a few minutes before the shooting. Though it hasn’t gotten much
attention, a video compilation that the Chicago Police Department
released includes footage
that seems to show Toledo walking with a young man before one (or both)
fired the eight or nine shots at a passing vehicle near the alley where
the police encountered Toledo. Exactly who pulled the trigger remains
unclear (the footage is grainy), though CNN reported
last Friday, citing prosecutors, that both Toledo’s hand, and the
gloves of the man he was with, tested positive for gunshot residue.
According to police, that man is a 21-year-old named Ruben Roman, who
was arrested at the scene for allegedly obstructing Officer Stillman as
he gave chase.
All indications are that Roman was exactly the kind of negative
influence to Toledo that loving parents stuck in high-crime
neighborhoods stay up nights worrying about. Chicago’s publicly
available arrest database shows that Roman has been collared at least
six times by the Chicago Police Department (CPD) since 2017. He has at
least one felony conviction, for a gun offense, for which he was
apparently sentenced
to probation. According to a Chicago police officer (who spoke with me
on the condition of anonymity), Roman is listed as a member of the Latin
Kings street gang in the CPD’s database.
Local thugs often lure impressionable children into the gangster
lifestyle they glorify by promising protection and brotherhood, and
Roman seems an illustrative example. But he didn’t protect or care about
his young charge the morning of March 29. In fact, as shown on the
body-worn camera footage
of the officers arriving after Toledo was shot, Roman didn’t shed a
tear after Toledo was shot but pretended not to know the 13-year-old at
all. Roman’s decision not to provide police with information about
Toledo’s identity meant that the boy would be listed as a “John Doe” in
the CPD’s paperwork,
and his family couldn’t be notified. Toledo’s body remained
unidentified in the morgue for two days before the police were able to
contact his mother.
This is a common story, sadly. People like Roman corrupt kids like
Toledo, and put them on paths that lead to untimely deaths,
incarcerations, and perpetrations of evil. Street gangs recruit child
soldiers into their turf wars, which turn playgrounds into battlefields
and leave parents holding the bodies of the children caught in the
crossfire; and they should be shamed for it.
Some reformers, in Illinois and elsewhere, have been pushing
proposals to raise the age of criminal responsibility to 18 or 21, which
could make this phenomenon worse. A 2015 report in the Chicago Tribune quoted
the now-former state’s attorney of Kane County, Illinois, who expressed
concern that such a reform would heighten the incentive for “more adult
members” to “push the responsibility to carry out shootings onto
juveniles.”
Yet while future changes to criminal justice policy might worsen the gang problem in neighborhoods like Little Village, the current
criminal justice system also plays a role in Chicago’s toxic gang
culture. How does a system that continuously releases known gang members
and other repeat offenders back into their communities—despite long
arrest records and serious criminal convictions involving firearms and
violent crimes—improve the prospects of children in Chicago’s South and
West Side neighborhoods, such as Austin, West Garfield Park, Englewood,
and Humboldt Park? It doesn’t.
In the end, Adam Toledo’s tragic death was caused not just by a
police officer’s bullet but by the forces that introduced him to gang
life—influences that won’t go away unless steps are taken to target the
incorrigible violent offenders who reduce the chances of kids like
Toledo living long and productive lives. That mission will require a
groundswell of support to carry out.
Rafael A. Mangual is a senior fellow and deputy director of legal policy at the Manhattan Institute for Policy Research, and a contributing editor of City Journal.
