Search This Blog

De Omnibus Dubitandum - Lux Veritas

Showing posts with label Term Limits. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Term Limits. Show all posts

Friday, August 29, 2025

It's Time For Term Limits

Government of the people, by the people, and for the people can mean any kind of government. It’s our duty to make it mean only one kind uncorrupted, free, united. - John Josephus Grant, an Associate Justice of the Supreme Court played by Frank Morgan in the movie, A Stranger in Town. 

By Rich Kozlovich 

Recently a writer who claimed to be a conservative also claimed there were valid conservative arguments against term limits. As far as I was concerned his arguments against term limits are inaccurate, and truth be told, is one great big red herring fallacy. 

The arguments supporting term limits are; they get old, they get ineffective, but most importantly, they get rich, they get connected, they get corrupt, they get egos so out of control, they can't be reasoned with, and they get gutless, many of whom start out gutless and it becomes a way of life as a legislator.

The one most missed is once they're there, they get re-elected over and over again in spite of their failures, and those failures are legion. And yes, it is right to make it a law to tell voters they need elect someone else, and bring an end, or at lease reduce the number of life long professional politicians, something the founding fathers never wanted or even expected. They never even expected to see national parties.

The idea term limits make it impossible for activists to become effective, is hardly an argument against term limits, and the idea lobbyist love term limits is inaccurate. I was active in my industry's trade associations in Ohio and a bit at the national level. We have term limits in Ohio and things get done much better, so the lack of institutional knowledge is a red herring fallacy. In point of fact, term limits created less complicated government, and all the lobbyists I know hated term limits.

Term limits means they have to start all over again creating influence. As for the unions, interest groups, and corporate interests being the real power, that's also a red herring. They're less powerful with new elected officials as they have to make their pitch over and over again, because new representatives are new opportunities for those in opposition with each other to make their arguments, and the new ones listen.

Term limits do not check voters rights on politicians, it expands them, and this malarkey about we end up losing good ones, while that's true, the fact is losing the bad ones is far more important, because the really bad ones have been an unending disaster, like Schiff, Waters, Pelosi, McCarthy, McConnell, and the list goes on endlessly, on both sides of the aisle. With term limits the damage bad ones can do is limited, and it forces voters to pay attention and "exercise their authority" wisely.

Any argument against term limits is nothing short of an effort to rationalize the corruption of the current system and what doesn't work to the benefit of the nation.

Wednesday, July 31, 2024

The Biden-Harris Plan to Upend the Constitution

Another leftist crusade driven by hate, fury, envy – and desperation. 

By | Jul 30, 2024 @ Liberty Nation News, Tags: Articles, Opinion, Politics

It came off almost like a schoolyard taunt from a lame-duck president desperate to restore his tainted legacy. It featured vintage campaign rhetoric, but from a man whose 50-year career in politics is now all but over, expressed in a series of proposals replete with lofty ideals for radical reform that he knows will go nowhere. Indeed, in a cliché-ridden op-ed in Washington’s most prominent newspaper on July 29, followed up by a speech at the LBJ Library in Austin, Texas, Joe Biden called for seismic reform: root-and-branch changes to the Supreme Court and a new constitutional amendment limiting executive authority.

If the 46th president had his way, he would end lifetime appointments to the High Court, limiting justices to 18-year terms, refresh the highest court in the land with new justices every two years, and institute a binding code of conduct. He also called for amending the constitution with what he amusingly calls the “No One Is Above the Law Amendment.” He left no doubt about his motivation when he added, “It would make clear that there is no (italics his) immunity for crimes a former president committed while in office.” One would think that a career politician like Biden would have masked his Trump derangement more effectively than that.

While it is hardly worth the time to examine the specifics of Biden’s plans any further since they will serve as little more than click-bait and talking points, the emotions and strategy animating them are worthy of discussion.

Root Causes: Hate, Fury, and Envy

First, let’s summarize the president’s agenda in plain language, shall we? Biden wants to upend the American constitutional system because he hates, fears, and envies Donald Trump.

We are already well aware of the president’s seething hatred for his predecessor and potential successor. But this op-ed revealed his passive-aggressive envy and fury. He is envious that Trump got three Supreme Court Justices confirmed in the space of four years while he got only one. He is furious that the Supreme Court has ruled on presidential immunity in a way that benefits Trump. He is envious that a single branch of government is delivering one victory after another for the right. He is furious that every indictment of Trump is crumbling. And he is both envious and furious that Trump is in a position to recapture the presidency.

To the matter of a law — or constitutional amendment — transparently aimed at a single person, Article 1 of the Constitution is clear. It specifically prohibits what’s called a bill of attainder — legislation declaring an individual guilty of a crime and allowing the government to punish the person for the perceived crime without due process. The provision is designed to strengthen the separation of powers by preventing Congress from assuming the functions of the judicial branch. While this is not directly applicable to Biden’s proposals, it captures the spirit of the framers and effectively defines the principle in play. Put another way, it is designed to assure that no man is either above or below the law.

In the wake of the recent High Court decision defining the parameters of executive privilege, Biden claimed “there are virtually no limits on what a president can do.” Of course, that is not true; a president’s protection is limited to official duties, and Biden knows it every bit as much as he knows Trump never actually called white supremacists very fine people. But, undaunted, he goes on to describe a court “mired in a crisis of ethics” — which apparently arose suddenly, as soon as Trump completed his trifecta of Supreme Court appointments assuring a 6-3 conservative majority. This is simply another broadside at the conservative justices, particularly Clarence Thomas and Samuel Alito, both subjects of recent intense investigations by left-wing media.

Intent on putting the mayhem of Jan. 6 prominently before the electorate once again, Biden tied the issue of presidential immunity directly to the Capitol riot, essentially warning that it is an invitation to insurrection. What is especially disturbing from this man who has been holding down the job for more than three years is that he ignored the grave consequences of any president being subjected to prosecution for decisions of great consequence if his private deliberations are subject to public disclosure and debate. This should be obvious to anyone not suffering from Trump Derangement Syndrome.

There was also another inconvenient truth revealed in the president’s plans: This is yet another sign of leftists’ utter dependence on the courts to enable their unpopular progressive ideas to take root. And it signals their futility in seeing the Court overturn its most valued decisions, most prominently Roe v. Wade, knowing there is nothing they can do to stop it.

Unless, that is, the rules of the game are changed.

Rescuing the Supreme Court

Biden needs to answer a fundamental question about his “plans” for the Supreme Court and a 28th constitutional amendment: If these reforms are so vital to the future of the republic, why did you wait until the 11th hour when you were the lamest of lame ducks to advance these radical proposals to alter one of the three branches of government and amend the Constitution?

Biden knows full well that a lame-duck president no longer wields power with Congress, especially in the heat of a presidential campaign. That renders these proposals nothing more than political theater. It’s as true of Biden as any other president: Had he been really serious about these reforms, he would have prosecuted the case during his honeymoon, the first 6 to 12 months of his presidency, when his approval was highest. Revealing these proposals after he was forced out of his re-election campaign looks like little more than swinging wildly for the fences in a race Democrats are losing.

e

Another sign that these plans are not legitimate is that they should have been advanced by the person who would theoretically steward them through to completion. That would be Kamala Harris, not Biden. But by announcing these proposals himself, Biden lifts the burden from Harris of making such an explosive announcement while at the same time handing her a radical agenda consistent with her pronounced plans for a prospective administration. Sure enough, the VP added her endorsement to the plans shortly after Biden’s announcement.

When Republicans go big, they usually propose things like tax cuts or changes in energy or economic policies. When Democrats get ambitious, they attempt to pack the Supreme Court, remove justices they find objectionable, turn left-wing territories into states, and abolish the Electoral College – all designed to guarantee perpetual leftist control of the federal government. Put simply, while the GOP works within the constitutional framework built upon centuries of debate and deliberation, modern-day Democrats seem intent on dramatically altering the law of the land to reflect the current progressive age.

With one foot out the door, Biden is using the fading remnants of his bully pulpit to lecture the American people on the injustice of a system that he has upheld for more than half a century. In doing so, he has come to personify the famously depressing lamentation in Shakespeare’s Macbeth about life itself: “a walking shadow, a poor player. That struts and frets his hour upon the stage, and then is heard no more. It is a tale … full of sound and fury, signifying nothing.”

 Read More From Tim Donner

Thursday, June 8, 2023

It's Time For Serious Judicial Reform

By Rich Kozlovich 

In today's edition of P&D I've featured a number of articles that demonstrate the absolute need for serious judicial reform in America, for the local judges, and most importantly, the federal judiciary.  

Let's start with Andrea Widburg's It’s time for Congress to rein in the federal judiciary noting: 

One of Governor Ron DeSantis’s most admirable initiatives as Florida governor has been to lead the movement protecting kids from people and entities sexually grooming and medically mutilating them. Having lost at the legislature, leftists promptly fled to the federal court system. And sure enough, Robert Hinkle, a Clinton appointee in the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Florida, answered the leftist call and blocked portions of the law against medically mutilating children. His judicial overreach reminds us that an eventual Republican-led government must rein in the federal judiciary.

Briefly, Florida passed a law protecting children from so-called “gender-affirming care” achieved via toxic chemicals (sterilization, fragile bones, cancer, heart disease) and monstrous surgery. (For the latter, a very NSFW image explains what I mean.) Judge Hinkle promptly ruled as a finding of fact that “gender identity is real” and said that these “treatments” for children were too important to ban.  Florida’s battle with a judge who just nullified its law protecting children from medical mutilation perfectly exemplifies dangerous judicial overreach.

Dangerous overreach isn't the exception, it's the rule with the federal judiciary.  Please take note of this pattern of what can only be considered a violation of the separation of powers.  It' s not the judiciary's job to decide social issues, that's the job of the legislature, but this judge disagrees, and in fact believes he has the power to overturn an entire category of federal law dealing with immigration, which clearly falls under the purview of the legislature.   Obama Judge Says 14th Amendment Gives Muslim Migrants the Right to Invade America.  It appears now all immigration laws are unconstitutional, because this nitwit says they're unconstitutional.  Where did he get that understanding?  The 14th Amendment.  

Now that's really an incredible stretch of the imagination, which clearly goes way beyond the intent of that post Civil War Amendment.  An Amendment that needs to be repealed as the conditions by which it was passed no longer exist, but can be twisted by minds that are twisted, including Joe Biden's as he used it as a threat claiming he could raise the debt limit under that Amendment without Congressional approval.  A clear violation of the Constitution, and the separation of powers that gives the House of Representatives control of the purse.  This out of control judge openly and angrily attacked the attorneys opposing this view.  

Then we have this piece, Colorado Bans Controversial Court-Ordered Reunification Camps.  These judges are out of control and worse yet, they're lazy and intellectually corrupt.  Their job, along with law enforcement, is to be shepherds protecting the flock, and especially the lives of the weak, helpless and innocent, and children absolutely fall into that category.  But what they're doing is in effect becoming enablers to wolves who are destroying the flock.  What's wrong with these people? 

Finally we have the case out of my own state of Ohio, by Andrea Widburg, who is one of my favorite writers.  A criminal case out of Ohio shows how far down the crazy road America has gone, saying:  

"Judge David McNamee cleared Glines after agreeing that the size of "her" belly meant it would be impossible for anyone to see "her penis".  So according to this judge it's okay for this guy, who claims to be a woman....with a penis.....is permitted to infest the women's locker room because he's fat, and the fact he's assaulted a woman in the past is meaningless."

You really have to personally wonder about this judge?  Would he want his wife or daughters, if he has any, to be exposed to this?   This judge is a DeWine appointee, and must run for and win election in 2023 to keep the seat for the remainder of the unexpired term ending on Dec. 31, 2025.  He's coming up for election this year.  For my Ohio readers, please forward this to your nets.

At least at the state level these misfits can be voted out of office, but that's  not true of the federal judiciary which has lifetime appointments, which was the Founding Fathers greatest mistake, as the federal judiciary is filled with political hacks, and that's been true for decades, which I outline in my article The Federal Judiciary is Filled With Political Hacks saying:

On July 5th, 2020 Henry P. Wickham, Jr. published this piece, Watergate and the Corruption of the DC Judiciary, filled with interesting insights from two books, Geoff Shepard's book, The Real Watergate Scandal and the just published book by Garrett Graff, Watergate, a New History.  I've decided to break this piece down into sections.  The first dealt with John Dean and this next section deals with the federal judiciary, and Judge Sirica............  The author concludes with this statement: Among many lessons, Watergate shows us how power can corrupt and how investigations and legal processes can be abused. This is just what we saw with the case of Michael Flynn, among many others, post 2016, and as we now see with the selective and politically motivated prosecutions by the Biden Justice Department; Attorney General, Merritt Garland being every bit the light weight, political hack that John Sirica was. America is in crisis.

For those who followed the Congressional hearings dealing with Biden's appointees to the federal bench it's clear the left has placed extreme and incompetent radicals on the bench, for the rest of their lives.  As Senator Kennedy noted these nitwits aren't qualified to sit on a park bench let alone have a seat on a federal judicial bench. 

It's time for a Constitutional Amendment for age and term limits for the federal judiciary because America is facing an existential Constitutional crisis. A crisis of cultural suicide promoted by a corrupt administration, a corrupt legislature and a corrupt judiciary.

 

Thursday, March 30, 2023

Litigating The Government's Metastasizing Censorship Regime

March 28, 2023 @ Manhattan Contrarian

For years, conservatives have complained of apparent censorship of their voices on the principal social media platforms, like Facebook, Google and Twitter. Posts or tweets get taken down, or de-boosted, or de-monetized, or degraded in search results, or “shadow-banned,” or slapped with content warnings, or otherwise suppressed. But the response from Big Tech has always been, hey, we’re private companies, and we’re not subject to the First Amendment. We can do as we please.

Then Elon Musk took over Twitter, and followed by giving several journalists access to Twitter’s electronic archives to investigate any untoward government manipulation. The result has been the Twitter Files, an ongoing series of Twitter threads laying bare the coordination between pre-Musk Twitter and dozens of government actors to suppress disfavored speech. The most recent nineteenth segment of the Twitter Files series was published on March 20 by Matt Taibbi.

Now that it is clear that the systematic censorship of conservative voices is very real and has been largely directed and coordinated by the government itself behind the scenes, is there anything that can be done about that through litigation? There actually are some significant efforts under way in that regard. Probably the most important is the case titled Missouri v. Biden, pending in the Western District of Louisiana. The case seeks declaratory and injunctive relief against the government under the First Amendment to stop it from continuing to pressure social media platforms to suppress speech that the current government does not like. On March 20, the court issued a major opinion denying the government’s motion to dismiss. That opinion is available here. With the motion to dismiss denied, the case will proceed through full discovery and, presumably, trial.

The plaintiffs in Missouri v. Biden are the states of Missouri and Louisiana, plus a group of private plaintiffs that includes some prominent names in the area of Covid-19 response — most notably Jay Bhattacharya of Stanford and Martin Kulldorff of Harvard. The two states are represented by their offices of Attorney General. The individual plaintiffs are represented by the New Civil Liberties Alliance, the public interest law firm that is recently making a huge name for itself in cutting-edge civil rights litigation.

Being no dummies, the NCLA has brought this case in a Louisiana District Court where it was likely to find a favorable judge, and which is part of the federal Fifth Circuit, known as the most conservative of the federal courts of appeal. It’s the flip side of how the game of environmental and “climate” litigation has long been played by the Left. When climate activists brought federal lawsuits trying to get some judge to declare a constitutional right to shut down use of energy, they went to the federal courts in San Francisco and Oregon, known to be home to multiple activist judges, and both part of the liberal Ninth Circuit. OK, two can play this game.

Although the original Complaint in Missouri v. Biden pre-dates the Twitter Files exposé, the plaintiffs were able to compile substantial information about federal involvement in the suppression of their speech. And, as more information has come out, the plaintiffs have amended their complaint twice. Here are just a few examples from the court’s Opinion of allegations of speech suppressed as a result of threat from or coordination with the government. (The allegations in question come either from the plaintiffs’ Second Amended Complaint, or from declarations submitted by plaintiffs as part of the motion papers.):

  • “The Media Research Center found more than 640 examples of bans, deleted content and other speech restrictions placed on those who criticized [President] Biden on social media over the past two years.” . . . “The list of censorship targets included an array of prominent influencers on social media: Trump; lawmakers like Sen. Ted Cruz (R-TX) and House Minority Leader Kevin McCarthy (R-CA); news outlets like the New York Post, The Washington Free Beacon and The Federalist; satire site The Babylon Bee; and others.”

  • Jay Bhattacharya, one of the Private Plaintiffs, stated in his declaration, “Because of my views on COVID-19 restrictions, I have been specifically targeted for censorship by federal government officials.” . . . [T]he “Great Barrington Declaration,” which Bhattacharya co-authored, was subject to “immediate backlash from senior government officials who were the architects of the lockdown policies” for COVID- 19. . . . Bhattacharya alleges that “Google deboosted search results for the Declaration, pointing users to media hit pieces critical of it, and placing the link to the actual Declaration lower on this list of results.” Further, a “roundtable” discussion between Bhattacharya and others, posted via video to YouTube, was removed from the social-media platform, with YouTube claiming that the video “contradicts the consensus of local and global health authorities regarding the efficacy of masks to prevent the spread of COVID-19.” Additionally, Bhattacharya alleges that he and his co-authors of the Great Barrington Declaration were personally censored on social media, primarily on Twitter and LinkedIn.

  • [Martin] Kulldorff co-authored the Great Barrington Declaration and allegedly “experienced censorship on social media platforms due to [his] views on the appropriate strategy for handling the COVID-19 pandemic.” . . . As just one example, Kulldorff alleged that Twitter censored the following tweet in March of 2021: “Thinking that everyone must be vaccinated is as scientifically flawed as thinking that nobody should. COVID vaccines are important for older, higher risk people and their caretakers. Those with prior natural infection do not need it. Nor children.” Kulldorff echoed Bhattacharya’s belief that the censorship of COVID-19-related opinions on social media was driven by government officials.

There are numerous additional examples in the Opinion, and the Opinion indicates that it has only scratched the surface of the many allegations in the Complaint.

So is there precedent for the proposition that sufficient government involvement in speech suppression can turn what would otherwise be private activity into “state action” that violates the First Amendment? The court cites several precedents that have so found. Notable examples are:

  • Bantam Books, Inc. v. Sullivan, 372 U.S. 58, 67, is a 1963 case from the U.S. Supreme Court. In that case the Court held that a legislatively-created commission, by notifying publishing distributors, on official commission stationary, that certain designated books or magazines had been declared objectionable for sale or distribution, thereby engaged in a scheme of governmental censorship.

  • A more recent precedent is Backpage.com, LLC v. Dart, 807 F.3d 229, 230, from the Seventh Circuit Court of Appeals in 2015. That case involved threats by a local law enforcement official against MasterCard and Visa to get them to stop processing payments for the backpage.com website. (Backpage was known as a site featuring advertisements from people in the sex trade, although that was far from its only business.). The Seventh Circuit held “A public-official defendant who threatens to employ coercive state power to stifle protected speech violates a plaintiff's First Amendment rights.”

So it looks like the two states and the individual plaintiffs are going to get the chance to prove their cases. Given the material so far revealed in the Twitter Files, there may be no shortage of evidence of deep government involvement in widespread censorship.

In addition, the Louisiana court is giving the plaintiffs substantial opportunity to take discovery of the government players to explore their involvement in censorship. From November 2022 through January of this year, a series of depositions has already been taken of government officials on this subject. Deponents so far have included the likes of Anthony Fauci of NIAID and Elvis Chan of the FBI. The NCLA has posted the full videos of the depositions on its YouTube channel. The depositions average almost 7 hours in length, so there’s no way I have time to watch them, but I’m sure there are plenty of interesting revelations for those willing to watch.

It may be some considerable time before there is a trial in this matter. However, as discovery proceeds, more and more information about the government censorship regime is likely to come out. Thanks are due to NCLA for undertaking the large effort to expose this completely improper conduct by our authorities.

Monday, February 27, 2023

The Founding Fathers Greatest Error? Lifetime Appointments to the Federal Judiciary!

By Rich Kozlovich

How many Founding Fathers were there?  There were 115 Founding Fathers.  Shocked me also.  I ask this because I read the article, by Andrea Widburg, Biden is establishing radical leftist, anti-Constitution control over the federal judiciary, and commented on the need for a 28th Amendment, and listed what should be in it saying:

It's time to fix the one really big error made by the Founding Fathers, lifetime tenure of the federal judiciary. It's time to pass a 28th Amendment creating age and term limits for the federal judiciary, and if possible, all federally elected officials. If we can't have both, at least get age and term limits for the federal judiciary.

There are three levels of the federal judiciary- the District level, the Appeals level and the Supreme Court. Each level should have a ten year limit with a review after five years requiring a majority approval by the Senate. At each level each nominee would have to go through the same process, even if nominated to a higher court before they finish their term in a lower court. If their term runs out and they’re not nominated to a higher court they may be nominated at some point in the future.

No jurist can return to a lower court if their term runs its course at a higher level, and no jurist can ever be appointed to a court if their nomination to any court has ever been rejected by the Senate. No jurist may serve after the age of seventy. And make 9 Justices a Constitutionally fixed number to avoid the kind of court packing Joe Biden and the Democrats are attempting to do.

Pass this 28th Amendment, repeal the 16th and 17th Amendments, and everything else will fall into place.

A reader came back saying:  

It wasn't really an error when average lifespan was less than 40.

Well, depending on the situation, I'm not impressed with average lifespan arguments because average lifespan is misleading.  Well up into the 20th century Child mortality was high. My grandmother had seven children and two died before the age of three from pneumonia.  So while he was right about the "average" lifespan, normally, the lifespan was, and is, the "Biblical four score and ten", and a lot of people lived that long. However, as I said, his argument intrigued me so I took some time to find out how long the Founding Fathers lived, all 115 of them.

Many of the Founding Fathers lived long lives, however, two died in their thirties, the youngest 30 dying at sea.

  • 15 died in their forties. 
  • 24 died in their fifties.
  • 37 died in the sixties,. 
  • 20 died in their seventies.
  • 12 died in the eighties.
  •  4 died in their nineties,  the oldest being 96. 

Their average life span is rounded off at 64. 

  • If you eliminate all those who died in their thirties, forties and fifties, that leaves 74 Founding Fathers with an average life span of 73. 
  • If you eliminate those who died in their sixties, that leaves 37 with an average lifespan rounded off at 77.  
  • If you eliminate those who died in their seventies, that leaves 16 with a rounded off lifespan of 86. 

As I said, his argument intrigued me, however, in none of the arguments presented in the Continental Congress for or against lifetime appointments, was life span ever bought up. The argument was all about unbridled power.  

That was the argument.  That was the issue, and it was fought vigorously, and the arguments used by those who fought against lifetime appointments were absolutely prescient.    It's time to put age and term limits on the federal judiciary. 

Thursday, May 13, 2021

It's Time For a Twenty Eighth Amendment!

https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEgDdJXy3OAHLJn_MpiNbbpiEfmKMk5o52EaM_ErYTz_AQiD3zo-sQWOUuwWSVBiV4IJ3FlQV6T-I03A9NYvk-Cw_z_XUAGBaqiTjOITYXOGIJAACqAjGX9XDktXKqx-gc3w6FR9l1Ki6Us/w41-h54/My+Picture+2.jpg By Rich Kozlovich

(Editor's Note: I published this on June 26, 2015 and again on January 16, 2018.  Current events are proving just how true the writers concerns were, and should be even more concerning now. With current events and the outrageous behavior of the judiciary of the Federal courts, and the tyranny imposed by the federal and state governments, I feel the need to post it again. RK)

Yesterday (June 25, 2015) Mark J. Fitzgibbons penned this article, Sotomayor's 4th Amendment Time Bomb regarding: 

“A painfully slim 5 – 4 ruling this week by the Supreme Court in City of Los Angeles v. Patel”. He writes, “The court struck down a Los Angeles ordinance that allowed police officers to inspect hotel guest registries for any or even no reason, and without a warrant. The ruling that the Fourth Amendment applies to businesses and that statutes may be declared unconstitutional on their face is consistent with principles as old as, and even older than, the Constitution.”

But he also notes:

“Justice Sonya Sotomayor’s majority opinion is also a blueprint for a major power grab for the administrative police state” because “her majority opinion even seems to suggest that police departments may be given power to approve their own searches using administrative subpoenas instead of going to judges to obtain warrants”.

Administrative subpoenas? Is she serious? This isn’t something that should even be an option! The article goes on to explain why say it’s Constitutionally inappropriate for administrative subpoenas to be issued by federal bureaucrats saying, “Justice Frank Murphy’s short but powerful and prescient dissent from his all-Democrat appointed colleagues is spot on”:

"I am unable to approve the use of nonjudicial subpoenas issued by administrative agents. Administrative law has increased greatly in the past few years, and seems destined to be augmented even further in the future. But attending this growth should be a new and broader sense of responsibility on the part of administrative agencies and officials.

Excessive use or abuse of authority can not only destroy man's instinct for liberty, but will eventually undo the administrative processes themselves. Our history is not without a precedent of a successful revolt against a ruler who "sent hither swarms of officers to harass our people."

Perhaps we are too far removed from the experiences of the past to appreciate fully the consequences that may result from an irresponsible though well meaning use of the subpoena power.

To allow a nonjudicial officer, unarmed with judicial process, to demand the books and papers of an individual is an open invitation to abuse of that power. It is no answer that the individual may refuse to produce the material demanded. Many persons have yielded solely because of the air of authority with which the demand is made, a demand that cannot be enforced without subsequent judicial aid. Many invasions of private rights thus occur without the restraining hand of the judiciary ever intervening.

Only by confining the subpoena power exclusively to the judiciary can there be any insurance against this corrosion of liberty. Statutory enforcement would not thereby be made impossible. Indeed, it would be made easier. A people's desire to cooperate with the enforcement of a statute is in direct proportion to the respect for individual rights shown in the enforcement process.

Liberty is too priceless to be forfeited through the zeal of an administrative agent."

Does Sotomayor, who actually described herself as the “wise Latina”, really understand that?

The founding fathers created lifetime appointments for federal judges because they wanted them to be unafraid about losing their jobs for unpopular decisions. There were some differences between then and now. First of all there were few federal judges and nowhere in the Constitution does it outline exactly their duties. Originally the Supreme Court handled very common cases. Their authority developed over time and they pretty much created their own parameters of responsibility.

Secondly the federal government was amazingly small compared to today and everyone pretty much thought it would stay that way. However the passage of the 16th amendment (income tax) and 17th Amendment (popular elections of Senators) pretty much laid the foundation destroying the checks and balances between the branches of government and the vision of a limited central government, which the founding fathers believed was essential to individual liberty. They couldn't have been more right.

Although it’s true judges can be removed by impeachment. It’s also true the federal judiciary is filled with political hacks that have made decisions that can’t be construed as anything but high crimes. The high crimes of the Constitution means a “crime of high office”,which can simply mean they’ve failed to perform the duties they have sworn by oath to perform. It’s clear the federal judiciary no longer believe they have to "solemnly swear (or affirm)they will administer justice……under the Constitution and laws of the United States." They’re clearly not following the Constitution, and they clearly don’t believe they need to “preserve and defend the Constitution against all enemies foreign and domestic” since they are Constitution’s greatest enemy. If that’s so – and it is – and it’s so obvious – and it is – why aren’t more judges impeached? Because getting a two thirds majority to vote for conviction from the Senate is almost impossible.

As historian Dr. Clarence Carson wrote:

"Jefferson doubted that the fear of impeachment was little more than a paper tiger, or as he put it frequently in private correspondence, “not even a scarecrow.” He put the danger this way: “We already see the power, installed for life, advancing with a noiseless and steady pace to the great object of consolidation. [“The engine of consolidation,” he had said, “will be the federal judiciary . . . .”] The foundations are already deeply laid by their decisions for the annihilation of constitutional state rights, and the removal of every check, every counterpoise to the engulfing power of which themselves are to make a sovereign part.”

Has this occurred? It should be obvious to the most casual observer that it has and the Supreme Court’s recent decision King v. Burwell is a clear example the federal judiciary has become an out of control law unto themselves.  Justice Scalia’s scathing dissent is a simple, direct and easy to understand intellectual tour-de-force demonstrating how far they’ve sunk in their efforts to overturn the balance of power created by the Constitution.

Scalia states:

“We should start calling this law SCOTUScare ……the cases will publish forever the discouraging truth that the Supreme Court of the United States favors some laws over others, and is prepared to do whatever it takes to uphold and assist its favorites…

He went on to say:

“Words no longer have meaning …..Under all the usual rules of interpretation, in short, the Government should lose this case. But normal rules of interpretation seem always to yield to the overriding principle of the present Court: The Affordable Care Act must be saved……

He observes:

The Court tries to palm off the pertinent statutory phrase as “inartful drafting.’ This Court, however, has no free-floating power ‘to rescue Congress from its drafting errors.’”…..“The Court’s decision reflects the philosophy that judges should endure whatever interpretive distortions it takes in order to correct a supposed flaw in the statutory machinery. That philosophy ignores the American people’s decision to give Congress ‘[a]ll legislative Powers’ enumerated in the Constitution. They made Congress, not this Court, responsible for both making laws and mending them.”…..

Demonstrating just how dangerous the federal judiciary has become:

“More importantly, the Court forgets that ours is a government of laws and not of men. That means we are governed by the terms of our laws, not by the unenacted will of our lawmakers. ‘If Congress enacted into law something different from what it intended, then it should amend the statute to conform to its intent.’ In the meantime, this Court ‘has no roving license … to disregard clear language simply on the view that … Congress ‘must have intended’something broader.”…

He states what should be the understanding of all federal jurists:

“Rather than rewriting the law under the pretense of interpreting it, the Court should have left it to Congress to decide what to do about the Act’s limitation of tax credits to state Exchanges.”

If the Constitution is going to really be the document that governs government, and is the real and legitimate law of the land, it's in serious need of reinforcements. It’s time for a 28th Amendment that would impose strict term and age limits on the federal judiciary.

There are three levels of the federal judiciary- the District level, the Appeals level and the Supreme Court. Each level should have a ten year limit with a review after five years requiring a majority approval by the Senate. At each level each nominee would have to go through the same process, even if nominated to a higher court before they finish their term in a lower court. If their term runs out and they’re not nominated to a higher court they may be nominated at some point in the future. No jurist can return to a lower court if their term runs its course at a higher level, and no jurist can ever be appointed to a court if their nomination to any court has ever been rejected by the Senate. No jurist may serve after the age of seventy.  Make 9 Justices a Constitutionally fixed number to avoid the kind of court packing Joe Biden and the Democrats are attempting to do, and all federal judges must be natural born citizens. 

Here’s the fix! Abolish the FED, repeal the 16th and 17th Amendments and pass a 28th amendment. Everything else will fall into place.

Oh, two more things.

Monday, May 3, 2021

Bingo: How To Fix the Supreme Court

Editorial of The New York Sun May 2, 2021

The latest news about the Supreme Court is that most Americans want to end lifetime appointments for the justices. That’s the finding of a new Ipsos poll for Reuters. The poll discovered that 63% of adults support term or age limits for Supreme Court justices. Only 22% say they oppose any limits.

This strikes us as a moment for constitutional fundamentalists to do some creative thinking. We ourselves have always favored lifetime appointments for the Supreme Court and other federal benches. The Founders ordained that judges get to serve during good behavior. Yet we wouldn’t be averse to amending the parchment — keeping lifetime appointments but setting a minimum age for a Supreme Court justice.

What most reformers mean by age limits is that justices would have to step down upon reaching, say, age 70. What we favor is preventing them from acceding to the high bench until they’re 70.   The problem is an unintended consequence of life tenure.............These be-robed tykes might claim to be conservatives, say, or liberals, or mere umpires. Only when it’s too late do we discover that they’ve yet to develop a stable and mature judicial philosophy.........

Finally, establishing a minimum age of 70 would open a vast new field of possible Supreme Court nominees just in the population of circuit judges who have senior status or qualify for it. Or those on state supreme courts who have been forced to retire by age or term limits. They are all deemed too old. Yet such sages often have experience decades beyond the age of 50. Why seek callow youth for a long term rather than wisdom for a shorter one?........To Read More..... 

My Take - Well, at least he's got the general right idea.  Limiting their time in office, but I don't think his solution will correct the problem, which is, you can't trust these people, no matter what the system, and it will never be fixed to any degree if they continue with life time appointments, and I don't care what anyone says, after 70 senility starts to creep in, at least with most people. 

I'm almost 75, and I think I'm smarter, more knowledgeable and more insightful than I ever was, but I have no delusions that senility's creeping in on me.  So are we to think having senile old jurists is better?  I don't think so.  

Limiting their time in office and having reviews to keep them in office presents a better solution.  None will be perfect, but at least there will be a way of getting rid of people like Warren, Brennan, Roberts, Ginsburg, and others.  

So, here's the solution I posted in my Friday, June 26, 2015 article,  It's Time For a Twenty Eighth Amendment!,

If the Constitution is going to really be the document that governs government, and is the real and legitimate law of the land, it's in serious need of reinforcements. It’s time for a 28th Amendment that would impose strict term and age limits on the federal judiciary. 

There are three levels of the federal judiciary- the District level, the Appeals level and the Supreme Court. Each level should have a ten year limit with a review after five years requiring a majority approval by the Senate. At each level each nominee would have to go through the same process, even if nominated to a higher court before they finish their term in a lower court. If their term runs out and they’re not nominated to a higher court they may be nominated at some point in the future. No jurist can return to a lower court if their term runs its course at a higher level, and no jurist can ever be appointed to a court if their nomination to any court has ever been rejected by the Senate. No jurist may serve after the age of seventy.

Here’s the fix! Abolish the FED, repealing the 16th and 17th Amendments and pass a 28th amendment. Everything else will fall into place


Friday, August 30, 2019

The Case For Term Limits

There is no better case for term limits than made in the video below.



However, Congress will never vote for term limits. Few pigs in the trough have the talent necessary to obtain such a lifestyle outside of politics.

Tuesday, January 15, 2019

Why Term Limits Lost and Ranked Choice Voting Will Succeed





The top down innovation is ranked-choice voting, and the midterm congressional elections in Maine were the first federal contests to be decided by ranked choice. ..........The Constitution is silent as to how many times a congressional candidate may run and how long he can hold office. In his Thornton decision dissent Justice Clarence Thomas wrote, “Nothing in the Constitution deprives the people of each State of the power to prescribe eligibility requirements for the candidates who seek to represent them in Congress. The Constitution is simply silent on this question. And where the Constitution is silent, it raises no bar to action by the States or the people.”.......To Read More....

Sunday, January 6, 2019

Sen. Cruz, Rep. Rooney Propose Constitutional Amendment Which Would Severely Impact Members of Congress

Beth Baumann Jan 05, 2019

Sen. Ted Cruz (TX) and Rep. Francis Rooney (OK), both Republicans, introduced a Constitutional amendment on Thursday that would place term limits on members of Congress. The amendment would limit U.S. senators to two six-year terms and members of the U.S. House of Representatives to three two-year terms.

“For too long, members of Congress have abused their power and ignored the will of the American people,” Cruz said in a statement. “Term limits on members of Congress offer a solution to the brokenness we see in Washington, D.C. It is long past time for Congress to hold itself accountable. I urge my colleagues to submit this constitutional amendment to the states for speedy ratification.”......To Read More......

Sunday, December 16, 2018

But Richard, For Wales?

By Rich Kozlovich

I do wish the movie, “Man For All Seasons” was being shown now. Of the two I've seen, I prefer this one,with Paul Scofield as Sir Thomas More.

The movie was about Sir Thomas More who refused to accept the divorce and re-marriage of Henry VIII as legal. During the trial Richard Rich, having sworn under oath to tell the truth, lied about Sir Thomas, a lie which condemned him. Although the outcome was predetermined this lie justified the death sentence.

Sir Thomas More commented, "In good faith, Rich, I am sorrier for your perjury than my peril". As Rich was walking away from the witness stand, Sir Thomas says, "I have one question to ask the witness. That's a chain of office you are wearing. May I see it? The red dragon. What's this?" Cromwell replies, "Sir Richard is appointed Attorney-General for Wales". More says, "For Wales? Why, Richard, it profits a man nothing to give his soul for the whole world . . . But for Wales!"

“Thomas Cromwell was the chief enforcer for Henry VIII, and during his time England broke with the papacy and thus came one of the largest transfers of wealth in the history of England. The King, now the Supreme Head of the Church of England, transferred all the property belonging to the monasteries into his hands, which was about a third of all the land in England.”

“Cromwell’s career combined supreme prowess as an administrator with an unsqueamish ruthlessness in the practice of politics………His cynical Machiavellian qualities had somehow failed him………During Henry’s reign, high politics in England was a blood sport, and it’s clear that Cromwell thrived in this deadly environment and reveled in his triumphs, even when they proved fatal to others.”

"During his rise to power, Cromwell made many enemies, including his former ally Anne Boleyn. He played a prominent role in her downfall. He later fell from power, after arranging the king's marriage to German princess Anne of Cleves. Cromwell had hoped that the marriage would breathe fresh life into the Reformation in England, but Henry found his new bride unattractive and it turned into a disaster for Cromwell, ending in an annulment six months later. Cromwell was arraigned under a bill of attainder and executed for treason and heresy on Tower Hill on 28 July 1540. The king later expressed regret at the loss of his chief minister."

Imagine that!

Being beheaded for finding a bride for a corrupt King the King didn’t like. Well, how could anyone find fault with that, clearly that constituted treason and heresy.......right? And after all, the King regretted beheading him! Imagine that!

When I see what passes for integrity in politics, I can't help but see Scofield in my mind saying, "But Richard, for Wales"! And I chuckle to myself.  Being a man for all seasons isn't for the faint of heart and it requires a strong moral foundation that's hard to maintain once in politics, assuming it was there in the first place.

We see massive corruption in the FBI, and DOJ, not to mention the rest of the Federal bureaucracy which is filled with corrupt self-serving out of control leftist officials who spend enormous amount of money promoting regulations in order to control every aspect of our lives.

I've had any number of people say to me that I should be in politics on both sides by the way, and they say it's because they believe I will say what I believe and do what I say. But I say the same thing every time:
“I could never be elected because the first thing that would come out of my mouth would be: "You're all wrong and I'm going to tell you why, and that would be to my own party!"  
 And truth be told, I’ve been involved in my industries affairs for many years and I’ve met any number of politicians during that time, and I just have no idea why anyone wants to be a politician. However, if I did get elected would it be possible to be a man for all seasons year after year, surrounded by self-serving peers, self-serving bureaucrats and even self-serving constituents?

My strength is in that I don’t want anything. I don't want power, I don't want prestige, I don't want position, I don't want money and I’m more than willing to go unliked for long periods of time. But, would that last? I've become convinced the longer anyone is in political office the more likely they'll become corrupted by all that's going on around them.   Would I be any different? I would like to think so, but people will always be people, and no one can be sure until the time comes when they come to the fork in the road that will determine their destination.

So, what to do?

There should be a sunset law on all government agencies, taxes and regulations. Term limits for all elected officials and jurists in the Federal government. Each state should be able to decide for themselves what they want for state officials, but the Federal government needs to be purged of Members of the House of Representatives and Senate, many of them who've been there too long with a constitutional amendment.

Three terms for the House members (six years) and one term for the Senate (six years).  If two four-year terms are enough for a President, six years is enough for the members Congress.

Saturday, October 6, 2018

Save the Supreme Court: Impose Term Limits on Justices

It needs to become “the least dangerous branch” again.

Doug Bandow October 5, 2018
The poison of vicious political partisanship infects virtually every aspect of policy today. Judicial appointments, which a couple decades ago resulted in overwhelming votes for well-qualified nominees, have turned into brutal battles with no prisoners taken……Even more significant, however, is the increasing importance of the federal judiciary and especially Supreme Court. While envisioned by Alexander Hamilton as “the least dangerous branch” and “the weakest of the three departments of power,” intended to settle disputes rather than make policy, the judiciary has turned into a quasi-legislature, where disappointed activists turn if they lose political battles………… Abortion may be the touchstone issue. In 1980 Democrats criticized presidential candidate Ronald Reagan and the GOP for allegedly adopting a pro-life “litmus test.” Today, of course, it is the Democrats who insist on absolute fealty to Roe, a respect for precedent which overturned previous widespread precedent………
Although interest groups may be most responsible for the transformation of the judiciary’s role, legislators and presidents share the blame. Instead of making tough decisions, they have created incomplete and ambiguous laws, leaving the details to the courts in the name of “interpretation.” ………how to roll back the judiciary’s role?............Of course, a life-time appointment is supposed to insulate justices from politics. But that very same life tenure is what ensures that nominations will trigger a political maelstrom. An opening might be the only one for years. Appointments are worth all-out political war………..Imagine, in contrast, Supreme Court terms. Appoint a justice to serve for ten years. He or she could be reappointed once, subject to Senate reapproval........To Read More....