Search This Blog

De Omnibus Dubitandum - Lux Veritas

Showing posts with label Kangaroo Court. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Kangaroo Court. Show all posts

Saturday, June 1, 2024

The Trump Verdict: What Cost to the Republic?

May 30, 2024, is a day that will live in infamy.

Show me the man, and I will show you the crime. So said the right-hand man to Joseph Stalin, architect of the infamous show trial, the centerpiece of the Soviet system of justice. Today, many Americans are wondering whether their own justice system is any less capricious or politically biased. In less than 12 hours of deliberation, 12 supposedly unbiased jurors – guided by a judge whom many have suggested has displayed a nakedly partisan stance throughout the trial – convicted a former president and leading candidate to reclaim the Oval Office on 34 felony counts. His crime? A long-expired bookkeeping misdemeanor rejected by three authorities but somehow sculpted into a still-undefined felony – based on the testimony of a convicted liar and concocted by a Manhattan district attorney who campaigned on a promise to get Trump by whatever means availed themselves.

So Alvin Bragg has now reached the promised land, and the left has finally achieved what it has thirsted for from the moment Donald Trump claimed the presidency: to label him a convicted felon, thought to be the one surefire way to drive him out of politics. Judge Juan Merchan – a donor to Democrats with an activist family who defied astronomical odds by miraculously landing not one, but all three Trump-related cases in what was supposed to be a random selection process, and as an acting judge no less – closed the deal with consistent rulings favoring the prosecution and silencing the defense. He then gave voluminous instructions which seemed to encourage jurors to conclude there was some amorphous stain of guilt on the defendant – which they could determine themselves. The actors out to take down Trump with their stacked deck played their hands effectively to a willing judge and jury.

But at what cost to the republic?

The Trump Verdict: The Undoing of Our Country?

The Rubicon has been crossed. The once-unthinkable has happened. The distance between the United States of America and any of the world’s many lawless banana republics has just significantly narrowed. Make no mistake, the magnitude of the jury’s swift and unanimous verdict has sent shockwaves around the world. The many who love or hate the 45th president are predictably giddy or outraged at the verdict, but how about the many everyday Americans without strong opinions either way who have always believed their nation is based on the rule of law and not subject to the political persecution of those who dare to threaten the established order? Have we not always believed that we were above the tactics of petty tyrants in a prototypical one-party state?

Ask yourself this simple question, the answer to which should remove any lingering doubts about the justice of the verdict and the trial itself: Would anyone else in the entire country have been indicted, not to mention convicted, on these novel, paper-thin charges? And remember, this was long thought by the left to be the weakest of the four cases brought against their archenemy. The beleaguered prosecutors targeting Trump in three other venues – long under pressure to advance their cases – will undoubtedly be energized by this verdict despite delays that threaten to deaden the desired political impact of their own prosecutions.

And now, with the twisted outcome in hand, and just to make sure the political impact of the verdict sticks, the notorious – or heroic, depending on your viewpoint – Judge Juan Merchan set sentencing for July 11, conveniently four days before the start of the Republican National Convention. Nothing is left to chance when Trump is in the crosshairs.

Only God knows the consequences for the loser of what has now officially become, unlike the many proclaimed as such before, the most important election of our lifetime. The one thing on which Americans have always counted, the rule of law, not to mention the very credibility of our elections in the wake of a lawfare campaign designed to disqualify a hated rival, is now undoubtedly on the line. The progressives who have been calling the shots in the Biden administration have won the battle – though not yet the war – and they will now be emboldened beyond measure to continue deconstructing the American way of life.

The 2024 presidential election, if it wasn’t already, has become boom or bust for both sides, the stakes and consequences now more consequential than ever. But for the American system of justice, the damage has already been done. Former Congressman Trey Gowdy said of the verdict on Fox News what so many have undoubtedly thought in the aftermath of the stunning verdict: “It may be the undoing of our country.” Indeed, it is impossible to calculate the cascading effects of the historic turn of events on May 30, 2024 – a day that, as Franklin D. Roosevelt once said of the attack on Pearl Harbor, will live in infamy.

 
Read More From Tim Donner

The Sentencing Singularity – Examining the Trump Guilty Verdict

What comes next for the former president?

by | May 31, 2024 @ Liberty Nation News, Tags: Articles, Crime &

Former President Donald Trump was found guilty on all 34 charges of falsifying business records in the first degree on Thursday evening, May 30. This is the first time a former president has been convicted of a felony, let alone almost three dozen. Judge Juan Merchan set the sentencing date as July 11th, just four days before the Republican National Convention, which begins July 15. What does this mean for Trump’s presidential campaign? What are his options going forward, and what sort of sentence might he face? We go to Liberty Nation’s Legal Affairs Editor Scott D. Cosenza, Esq., to answer this and more.

James Fite: Scott, the first question that comes to mind is what sentence awaits Trump now that he has been convicted on 34 Class E felonies? What does the sentencing guideline suggest, and what seems likely in this case?

Scott D. Cosenza: There are five felony classes in New York, and E is the least serious. By definition, felonies are crimes carrying potential incarceration terms of a year or more. These were non-violent felonies committed by someone with no criminal record, however. District Attorney Alvin Bragg declined to state what sentence he would request in post-trial comments. No custodial sentence is required here, and Juan Merchan will not likely sentence Trump to any time behind bars. That would be consistent with what NY-based attorneys report with other first-time offenders convicted of non-violent class E felonies.

Defense motions on sentencing are due in court by June 13, while the state has until June 27 to respond.

The Trump Appeal Pathway

James: What are the former president’s options for appeal? What would that process look like, and how long might it delay the sentencing should any appeal prove successful?

Scott: Donald Trump’s defense has an abundance of pathways that may lead to a successful appeal. Lead defense attorney Todd Blanche filed a motion for acquittal immediately after the guilty verdict, which Merchan just as quickly denied. That’s the last time Merchan will be deciding such matters, however. Future appeals from Trump will be in state appellate courts and, eventually, federal court if needed.

Jury Finds Former President Donald Trump Guilty On All 34 Counts In Hush Money TrialNEW YORK, NEW YORK - MAY 30: Former U.S. President Donald Trump arrives at Trump Tower on May 30, 2024 in New York City. The former president was found guilty on all 34 felony counts of falsifying business records in the first of his criminal cases to go to trial. Trump has now become the first former U.S. president to be convicted of felony crimes.(Photo by Stephanie Keith/Getty Images)

(Photo by Stephanie Keith/Getty Images)

We should expect to see Trump’s pleadings challenging all manner of things, including many of Judge Merchan’s rulings that prejudiced the defendant’s fundamental rights. Another thing that springs to the front of my mind is Merchan allowing the jury to hear multiple times that Trump violated campaign finance laws and have that presented as a fact rather than a prosecution theory.

James: Donald Trump is a convicted felon – at least for now – but the Constitution doesn’t prohibit felons from running for and, therefore, becoming president. If Trump wins in November as the polls suggest he will, how might his sentencing affect his taking office in January? Alternatively, if he appeals and that delays his sentencing beyond Election Day, how might a win in November affect the eventual sentencing should his appeal fail? Finally, as president, would Trump be able to pardon himself?

Scott: The President may grant pardons for federal convictions. Trump cannot pardon himself unless he becomes Governor of New York. If he wins, he will likely be able to appeal sentencing until after his presidency. There is no printed rulebook for this kind of thing, and avoiding chaos and perhaps a genuine Constitutional crisis are great reasons to wait.

 
Read More From Liberty Nation Authors

Today's Scorecard For New York's Kangaroo Legal System

@ Manhattan Contrarian  

(Editor's Note: I can't properly reproduce the picture in this article, so to see it follow the link to Manhattan Contrarian. RK)

The kangaroos’ request shown above, as reported yesterday on X by the Babylon Bee, may not be completely justified with respect to the U.S. federal justice system. It remains to be seen how the prosecutions of our ex-President play out in that arena. However, the kangaroos’ request is 100% justified with respect to the justice system of the State of New York. Here in New York, the recent actions of our prosecutors and legal system make “kangaroo courts” look wise and sensible by comparison.

Somewhere in the mid-2010s, New York prosecutors and regulators decided that all previous norms and ethical restraints had been abolished, and it was now OK to use all resources of their offices to bring down disfavored political targets by any and every means they could think of. As the most notable example, they decided that it was now completely OK even to seek office on the specific promise to destroy one man, Donald Trump, even if they did not know at the time what legal wrong he may have committed. Both our current Attorney General, Letitia James, and our Manhattan District Attorney, Alvin Bragg, campaigned on such specific promises to “get Trump.” Previously, such conduct would have been thought the most grievous ethical violation that a prospective prosecutor could possibly commit. Today, the organized New York bar — once the most prestigious in the country — to its shame, declines to speak out on the issue at all.

Yet all is not necessarily rosy for our sub-kangaroo-level abusers of the legal process. Granted, as you have probably already seen, ex-President Trump was convicted today by a Manhattan jury on some 34 counts of “falsifying business records,” or some such made-up crime that nobody but he would ever be prosecuted for at all on similar facts. Score one for the sub-kangaroos. But on the same day, the sub-kangaroos of New York also lost one in the U.S. Supreme Court. Today’s Supreme Court decision is an important one, and a bad omen for the whole program of progressive prosecution of political enemies, not just in New York. The Court’s decision even gives a glimmer of hope that there may be at least some accountability for the abusers of the legal process.

The Supreme Court decision in question is National Rifle Association of America v. Vullo, issued today. The case arises out of the efforts of a New York regulator, Maria Vullo, then Superintendent of the New York Department of Financial Services, to destroy the NRA by threatening regulatory harassment against banks and insurance companies under her regulatory jurisdiction unless they agreed to stop doing business with the NRA. Vullo’s conduct, as set forth in the Supreme Court’s decision, was quite shockingly thuggish, at a level that you would think would cause even the crazed leftists in New York State government to slow down and think twice. But they operate in a bubble where no voices of sensible outsiders are able to penetrate.

Perhaps the most significant thing about the Supreme Court’s Vullo decision is that it is unanimous. All three “liberals” joined, and the opinion is even written by perhaps the most consistently lockstep of the lockstep leftists on the Court, Sonia Sotomayor. This one was too much even for her.

In 2017 to 2019, Vullo carried out a program to bully and harass banks and insurance companies to stop dealing with the NRA. The NRA sued Vullo and the Department of Financial Services in the Northern District of New York, alleging violation of its First Amendment rights, asserting that Vullo’s program was intended to restrict and shut down its constitutionally protected advocacy. Defendants moved to dismiss, and the District Court declined to grant the motion. However, the defendants appealed that to the Second Circuit Court of Appeals, which allowed the appeal, and reversed, thus dismissing the case. The Supreme Court now revives the claim against Vullo and sends it back to the District Court for trial.

The statement of facts in Justice Sotomayor’s opinion is dry, but still gives a remarkable sense of just how much Ms. Vullo thought she could get away with in going after a political enemy under the guise of her jurisdiction of “regulating banks and insurance companies.” Here are some allegation of Vullo’s conduct with respect to Lloyd’s of London and Chubb, insurance companies that were working with the NRA to underwrite gun-liability insurance policies:

Vullo brought a variety of insurance-law violations to the Lloyd’s executives’ attention during a private meeting in February 2018. The violations included technical infractions that allegedly plagued the affinity insurance market in New York and that were unrelated to any NRA business. . . . Vullo allegedly said she would be “less interested in pursuing the[se] infractions . . . so long as Lloyd’s ceased providing insurance to gun groups, especially the NRA.” . . . Vullo also told the Lloyd’s executives she would “focus” her enforcement actions “solely” on the syndicates with ties to the NRA, “and ignore other syndi- cates writing similar policies.” . . . The message was therefore loud and clear: Lloyd’s “could avoid liability for [unrelated] infractions” if it “aided DFS’s campaign against gun groups” by terminating its business relationships with them.

In 2018, Vullo issued so-called “guidance letters” to the entire insurance industry, advising all companies to avoid “reputational risk” by ceasing to do business with the NRA:

Just like in her meeting with the Lloyd’s executives, here too Vullo singled out the NRA and other gun-promotion organizations as the targets of her call to action. This time, the Guidance Letters reminded DFS-regulated entities of their obligation to consider their “reputational risks,” and then tied that obligation to an encouragement for “prompt actio[n] to manag[e] these risks.” . . . Evocative of Vullo’s private conversation with the Lloyd’s executives a few weeks earlier, the press release revealed how to manage the risks by encouraging DFS-regulated entities to “‘discontinu[e] their arrangements with the NRA.’”

This case now goes back to the trial court — a federal court in upstate New York, with a jury pool drawn largely from rural areas. (Obviously the NRA is smart enough to pick a potentially-favorable forum.). Ms. Vullo is a defendant personally. She could get hit with some serious liability.

Meanwhile the case against Trump has probably zero chance of surviving all appeals. However, that will take a long time to play out. Trump’s first appeal will go to something called the Appellate Division, First Department, an appellate court also sitting in Manhattan. From there, the next appeal will be to the New York Court of Appeals, and then (if the case is still alive) to the U.S. Supreme Court. Yes, there is a real issue for the Supreme Court, should the case get that far, which is whether the New York DA has jurisdiction to prosecute a federal election law crime, which underlies his theory that Trump’s bookkeeping violations can be raised to a felony.

Anyway, if the Supreme Court was disgusted enough by Vullo’s abuse of her powers to reverse in the NRA case, it would be quite likely that they would reverse in Trump’s case. Indeed, even the New York Court of Appeals is likely to be sufficiently outside the bubble to reverse. The Appellate Division I’m not so sure.

Thursday, May 30, 2024

Is Merchan The Most Corrupt Judge in American History?

“When statesmen forsake their own private conscience for the sake of their public duties, they lead their country by a short route to chaos.” Sir Thomas More in A Man For All Seasons.

By Rich Kozlovich

One of my favorite movies is a Man For All Seasons, with Paul Scofield as Sir Thomas More, a movie I wish was shown more often, and particularly now.  A corrupt judge, corrupt prosecution, lying witnesses, and a predetermined verdict with a selected jury, against a man who truly believed in the rule of law.  In his discussion about the importance of adhering to the rule of law, More's challenged:

William Roper: “So, now you give the Devil the benefit of law!”

Sir Thomas More: “Yes! What would you do? Cut a great road through the law to get after the Devil?”

William Roper: “Yes, I'd cut down every law in England to do that!”

Sir Thomas More: “Oh? And when the last law was down, and the Devil turned 'round on you, where would you hide, Roper, the laws all being flat? This country is planted thick with laws, from coast to coast, Man's laws, not God's! And if you cut them down, and you're just the man to do it, do you really think you could stand upright in the winds that would blow then? Yes, I'd give the Devil benefit of law, for my own safety's sake!”

Let's face it, in no way can Alan Dershowitz be considered a conservative, but it appears he, like Sir Thomas, really believes in the rule of law, and was shocked at what he saw going on in Judge Merchan's court saying he'd 'Never seen such a spectacle'! 

Merchan was castigating Costello for rolling his eyes, as the Fox News host then pointed out "I'm my rolling my eyes just hearing about what's going on in that courtroom!" Dershowitz then confirmed to Hannity he's never seen anything like this in the years he's practiced law.  Dershowitz himself rolled his eyes and stared him down, he explained, who had been sitting in the very front row, "when the judge made some rulings that were absurd," adding "any first year evidence student would understand that he was making biased rulings in favor of one side." 

Justice Merchan has gagged witnesses who were vital to Trump's defense on more than one occasion, including a former FEC commissioner, but allows Bragg's star witness, Michael Cohen, a convicted serial liar and a admitted thief, who ends up destroying Bragg's case.
A case of made up charges for a made up crimes.  That becomes important, since normally it's the job of the prosecution to define the crime committed by the defendant.  Since Bragg's case is in shambles, Merchan has transferred that responsibility over to the jury.  Imagine that! 
 
Trump......was never told which of the underlying crimes he supposedly committed in the courtroom, so he was not able to defend himself from them, which according to some legal observers violates the equal protection clause. His instructions actually were illegal, based on a recent Supreme Court case in an opinion written by left-leaning Justice Stephen Breyer that right-leaning Justices Antonin Scalia and Clarence Thomas concurred with, regarding the critical need for unanimity regarding an underlying crime:
 
They were in effect told to just find a crime, any crime, make one up if you have to.  This is part of the lawfare conspiracy, with the mentality as long as you find him guilty of, something, anything,  it's fine with me.
None of this is normal, or legal!  Now under "Merchan's Rule" it will now only take four jurors to convict Trump in an "unanimous" decision.   Four jurors can be a unanimous decision?  Where in any law in the land is that valid?  Only in Merchan's courtroom, and here's how he will rig this "unanimous" decision.

"Judge Merchan has ruled that the jury does not have to agree on what that crime is. The jury could split into three groups of four on which of the three crimes were being concealed and Merchan will still treat it as a unanimous verdict," George Washington University Law Professor Jonathan Turley, who has been inside the courtroom, writes. "The jury has been given little substantive information on these crimes, and Merchan has denied a legal expert who could have shown that there was no federal election violation. This case should have been dismissed for lack of evidence or a cognizable crime." 

"You read that right: 4-4-4 is a unanimous verdict. The only thing that’s criminal in this trial is the trial itself."

What if Justice Merchan has been compromised? - Given what we know about what has been going on in Justice Juan Merchan’s Manhattan courtroom, including the preposterous, over-the-top bias of this judge for the prosecution and his overt antipathy for the defendant, Donald Trump, what explains his willing destruction of his own reputation as a judge? 

Each and every legal scholar who has weighed in on the course of the trial, from Alan Dershowitz to Jonathan Turley and countless others, (with the exception of those paid by CNN and MSNBC) is gobsmacked by Merchan’s thoroughly unconstitutional rulings, gag orders, contempt charges, exclusion of practically every witness with relevant testimony for the defense, and his allowance of non-relevant witnesses like Stormy Daniels.  He allowed her testimony, too, even though she knew nothing about the issue being tried, to spew her pornographic filth that could only come from the mouth of a porn star actress.

At the end of A Man For All Seasons Sir Thomas More asks, Richard Rich, who perjured himself against More, what was the chain of office he was wearing.  Judge Cromwell says he's been appointed Attorney General to Wales.  More's response?   
 
 “For Wales? Why Richard, it profit a man nothing to give his soul for the whole world. . . but for Wales!” 
 
It will be interesting to see how all this plays out for Merchan in the future, but I betting if Trump is re-elected, he's in big trouble, right along with the rest of the corrupt prosecutors and judges.   Make no mistake, this is a RICO case.  

As a side bar, what happened to Cromwell?  He was "a totally ruthless, unscrupulous, political operator" and became Chancellor rising to great political heights of power,  until the King became displeased with him, and had him beheaded on false charges, without trial.  The perverter of the rule of law met his doom via the perversion of the rule of law....." in his last personal address to the king..... "Most gracious Prince, I cry for mercy, mercy, mercy."

Sir Thomas More: “Oh? And when the last law was down, and the Devil turned 'round on you, where would you hide, Roper, the laws all being flat? This country is planted thick with laws, from coast to coast, Man's laws, not God's! And if you cut them down, and you're just the man to do it, do you really think you could stand upright in the winds that would blow then? Yes, I'd give the Devil benefit of law, for my own safety's sake!”

Friday, May 21, 2021

Democrat stooges: 35 House Republicans jump in to Nancy Pelosi's latest kangaroo court scheme

In a way, it's kind of good that 35 Republicans jumped in to House Speaker Nancy Pelosi's phony "9/11-style" commission on the Capitol riot of Jan. 6.

According to Axios:

The House of Representatives voted 252-175 on Wednesday to pass a bill to set up a bipartisan 9/11-style commission to investigate the deadly Jan. 6 Capitol riots.

Why it matters: Minority Leader Kevin McCarthy and GOP leadership oppose the commission, but 35 House Republicans voted in support of the bill, underscoring the fault lines within the party in the aftermath of the insurrection.

That's because now we know who they are: 

  • Rep. Don Bacon (Neb.)
  • Rep. Cliff Bentz (R-Ore.)
  • Rep. Stephanie Bice (Okla.)
  • Rep. Liz Cheney (Wyo.)
  • Rep. John Curtis (Utah)
  • Rep. Rodney Davis (Ill.)
  • Rep. Brian Fitzpatrick (Pa.)
  • Rep. Jeff Fortenberry (Neb.)
  • Rep. Andrew Garbarino (N.Y.)
  • Rep. Carlos Gimenez (Fla.)
  • Rep. Tony Gonzales (Tex.)
  • Rep. Anthony Gonzalez (Ohio)
  • Rep. Michael Guest (Miss.)
  • Rep. Jaime Herrera Beutler (Wash.)
  • Rep. French Hill (Ark.)
  • Rep. Trey Hollingsworth (Ind.)
  • Rep. Chris Jacobs (N.Y.)
  • Rep. Dusty Johnson (S.D)
  • Rep. David Joyce (Ohio)
  • Rep. John Katko (N.Y.)
  • Rep. Dan Newhouse (Wash.)
  • Rep. Adam Kinzinger (Ill.)
  • Rep. David McKinley (W.Va.)
  • Rep. Peter Meijer (Mich.)
  • Rep. Mariannette Miller-Meeks (Iowa)
  • Rep. Blake Moore (Utah.)
  • Rep. Tom Reed (N.Y.)
  • Rep. Tom Rice (S.C.)
  • Rep. Maria Salazar (Fla.)
  • Rep. Mike Simpson (Idaho)
  • Rep. Chris Smith (N.J.)
  • Rep. Van Taylor (Tex.)
  • Rep. Fred Upton (Mich.)

What a collection of jackasses............To Read More.....