Molly O'Toole
The retired four-star Marine general will leave the administration on Wednesday. First as Homeland Security chief and then in 18 months at the White House, he presided over some of the Trump administration’s most controversial immigration and security policies.
In the phone interview Friday, Kelly defended his rocky tenure, arguing that it is best measured by what the president did not do when Kelly was at his side.............. Kelly said he made sure that Trump had access to multiple streams of detailed information before he made a decision — even if the president says he often relies on his gut, rather than U.S. intelligence. “It’s never been: The president just wants to make a decision based on no knowledge and ignorance,” Kelly said. “You may not like his decision, but at least he was fully informed on the impact.” ..........
Trump sometimes pressed his advisors on the limits of his authority under the law, often asking Kelly, “‘Why can’t we do it this way?’” But Trump never ordered him to do anything illegal, Kelly stressed, “because we wouldn’t have.”..............Unlike Kelly’s friend James N. Mattis, the retired Marine general who resigned as secretary of Defense with a public letter rebuking the president for abandoning allies and undermining alliances, Kelly kept his counsel..........
Asked why he stayed 18 months in the White House, despite policy differences, personality clashes, the punishing schedule, and a likely lasting association with some of Trump’s controversies, he said simply: duty............To Read More....
My Take - I've not agreed with Kelly for some time on a lot of issues, but he's demonstrating character in his departure - a class act - and I respect him for that. I hope he stays that way. As for his departure being "worrisome"? The graveyard is filled with indispensible people, and I'm willing to bet Kelly would agree.
Search This Blog
De Omnibus Dubitandum - Lux Veritas
Showing posts with label General Kelly. Show all posts
Showing posts with label General Kelly. Show all posts
Tuesday, January 1, 2019
Monday, June 11, 2018
‘Drama, Action, Emotional Power’: As Exhausted Aides Eye the Exits, Trump Is Re-Energized
By Maggie Haberman and Katie Rogers
President Trump has gone overseas to embark on some of the most consequential diplomatic negotiations of his tenure, threatening an all-out trade war with allies and seizing a chance to make peace with a nuclear-armed menace.
But back home, he left behind a West Wing where burned-out aides are eyeing the exits , as the mood in the White House is one of numbness and resignation that the president is growing only more emboldened to act on instinct alone.
Mr. Trump, a former reality television star, may soon be working with a thinned-out cast in the middle of Season 2, well before the midterm elections. Several high-profile aides, including John F. Kelly , the president’s chief of staff, and Joe Hagin, a deputy of Mr. Kelly’s, are said to be thinking about how much longer they can stay. Last week, Mr. Kelly told visiting senators that the White House was “a miserable place to work,” according to a person with direct knowledge of the comment...........To Read More......
My Take - Making former Generals Chief of Staff wouldn't be the direction I would go. First of all, there are two groups of people everyone thinks of as leaders. Military officers and PhD's. Both conclusions are wrong. These are usually very competent intelligent people who got to the top of their professions by going along to get along.
Give them a mission and they'll carry it out with great ability, and probably successfully. However, military officers who stand against their superiors don't get promoted - especially if they prove their superiors wrong. PhD candidates don't get promoted by telling other PhD's they're all wrong, and prove it, during their oral dissertations. Being the rock in the current is completely alien to them.
Don't ask them to stand against consensus. That's not who they are by nature and experience in life. And the habits of a life time are as strong as life itself.
If Kelly doesn't like it he should leave, and it wouldn't be to another high ranking job in govenrment as he may be wanting if it were up to me. Perhaps he need's to just go home. But one thing is clear. Trump will not change and he's had a great many people around him in his businesses for decades. Apparently it can't be that bad. And it's clear he likes stirring up the pot if for no other reason he doesn't trust those around him, and he has good reason. They're bureaucrats, and if a bureaucrat hates anything more than change I don't know what it is because that means they'll have to think and work.....at the same time.....and that's just asking too much of bureaucrats, especially Washington's Deep State bureaucrats, many of whom are still there from the Obama administration.
As for this idea the Chief of Staff is to "serve as the president’s confidant and gatekeeper". That's for the President of the United States to decide, not the New York Times, and not the Chief of Staff.
President Trump has gone overseas to embark on some of the most consequential diplomatic negotiations of his tenure, threatening an all-out trade war with allies and seizing a chance to make peace with a nuclear-armed menace.
But back home, he left behind a West Wing where burned-out aides are eyeing the exits , as the mood in the White House is one of numbness and resignation that the president is growing only more emboldened to act on instinct alone.
Mr. Trump, a former reality television star, may soon be working with a thinned-out cast in the middle of Season 2, well before the midterm elections. Several high-profile aides, including John F. Kelly , the president’s chief of staff, and Joe Hagin, a deputy of Mr. Kelly’s, are said to be thinking about how much longer they can stay. Last week, Mr. Kelly told visiting senators that the White House was “a miserable place to work,” according to a person with direct knowledge of the comment...........To Read More......
My Take - Making former Generals Chief of Staff wouldn't be the direction I would go. First of all, there are two groups of people everyone thinks of as leaders. Military officers and PhD's. Both conclusions are wrong. These are usually very competent intelligent people who got to the top of their professions by going along to get along.
Give them a mission and they'll carry it out with great ability, and probably successfully. However, military officers who stand against their superiors don't get promoted - especially if they prove their superiors wrong. PhD candidates don't get promoted by telling other PhD's they're all wrong, and prove it, during their oral dissertations. Being the rock in the current is completely alien to them.
Don't ask them to stand against consensus. That's not who they are by nature and experience in life. And the habits of a life time are as strong as life itself.
If Kelly doesn't like it he should leave, and it wouldn't be to another high ranking job in govenrment as he may be wanting if it were up to me. Perhaps he need's to just go home. But one thing is clear. Trump will not change and he's had a great many people around him in his businesses for decades. Apparently it can't be that bad. And it's clear he likes stirring up the pot if for no other reason he doesn't trust those around him, and he has good reason. They're bureaucrats, and if a bureaucrat hates anything more than change I don't know what it is because that means they'll have to think and work.....at the same time.....and that's just asking too much of bureaucrats, especially Washington's Deep State bureaucrats, many of whom are still there from the Obama administration.
As for this idea the Chief of Staff is to "serve as the president’s confidant and gatekeeper". That's for the President of the United States to decide, not the New York Times, and not the Chief of Staff.
Sunday, March 18, 2018
Is the Red Team dead? Maybe not
March 16, 2018 by David Wojick, Ph.D., 0 Comments
The ever-green New York Tines is trying to report that the climate change Red Team exercise proposed by EPA Administrator Pruitt is dead. I say “trying” because if you read their long article carefully it may not be so. What is really going on is a bit of a political struggle within the Trump Administration. What eventually happens remains to be seen.
Pruitt has been talking about the Red Team exercise for a long time now. The idea is to have an official public debate over climate science, between alarmists and skeptics. As Pruitt repeatedly says, Americans have a right to know about this deep debate, which was carefully hidden from view by the Obama Administration.
According to the NYT, the Trump White House chief of staff is trying to stop the Red Team exercise. Here is the NYT article’s very first sentence. While long it clearly says the effort is killed:
“Don’t rock the boat in an election year” is a political maxim and a Red Team debate would certainly rock a lot of political boats. But the climate change issue is far too important to sweep under the political rug.
In fact the NYT piece mentions toward the very end that Pruitt may well be moving ahead with the exercise. They say this:
The ever-green New York Tines is trying to report that the climate change Red Team exercise proposed by EPA Administrator Pruitt is dead. I say “trying” because if you read their long article carefully it may not be so. What is really going on is a bit of a political struggle within the Trump Administration. What eventually happens remains to be seen.
Pruitt has been talking about the Red Team exercise for a long time now. The idea is to have an official public debate over climate science, between alarmists and skeptics. As Pruitt repeatedly says, Americans have a right to know about this deep debate, which was carefully hidden from view by the Obama Administration.
According to the NYT, the Trump White House chief of staff is trying to stop the Red Team exercise. Here is the NYT article’s very first sentence. While long it clearly says the effort is killed:
“John F. Kelly, the White House chief of staff, has killed an effort by the head of the Environmental Protection Agency to stage public debates challenging climate change science, according to three people familiar with the deliberations, thwarting a plan that had intrigued President Trump even as it set off alarm bells among his top advisers.My take is that this is an election year and the Trumpers are focused on showing in November that they have helped, not hurt, the Republican Party. That was the focus of the State of the Union speech.
“Don’t rock the boat in an election year” is a political maxim and a Red Team debate would certainly rock a lot of political boats. But the climate change issue is far too important to sweep under the political rug.
In fact the NYT piece mentions toward the very end that Pruitt may well be moving ahead with the exercise. They say this:
“In the weeks since that meeting, however, Mr. Pruitt said the red team, blue team debates were still under consideration. In January, he told Congress that a report in E and E News, a news organization focusing on energy and the environment that first reported that the White House had killed the plan, was false. White House opposition to the debates was “untrue,” he said under questioning by a senator.”What they fail to mention is that Pruitt and the EPA do not answer to the President. EPA is what is called an “independent agency,” like the Federal Reserve. It is not part of the Trump Cabinet and it does not take orders from the White House chief of staff. So Pruitt can, and may well, go ahead with the Red Team exercise. He might even wait until after the November elections.
One wonders how a journalist writing this last paragraph could have written the first. Clearly the real story is about the disagreement between Pruitt and Kelly. Maybe the NYT “buried the lead” because they preferred the possibly false story that the Red Team is dead.
The NYT article also talks about having to involve the whole range of federal science agencies in a Red Team exercise, which would certainly then fall under the White House jurisdiction. But in reality EPA is the only federal agency that is truly under the climate change gun.
Pruitt is facing the Obama-era EPA false finding that CO2 endangers our health and welfare. This so-called “endangerment finding” requires him to regulate CO2 as a pollutant under the Clean Air Act, which it most certainly is not. This forced false move is by far the biggest thing going on at EPA. No other federal agency is facing anything remotely like this, so it makes perfect sense if EPA alone runs the Red Team exercise.
In fact the NYT acknowledges this extreme situation, but in passing as usual. They say this of the endangerment finding and the Red Team:
“That finding is the legal backbone for almost all federal climate policy and requires the government to regulate greenhouse gas emissions in some manner. A government critique of climate science could lay the groundwork for challenging the endangerment finding in court.”So all things considered it would make perfect sense if EPA Administrator Pruitt told White House chief of staff Kelly “You’re not the boss of me” and went ahead with the Red Team exercise. Let’s hope that he does, even if it means waiting until after the November elections. Climate change alarmism is far too dangerous to simply ignore on political grounds.
About the Author: David Wojick, Ph.D.
David Wojick is a journalist and policy analyst. He holds a doctorate in epistemology, specializing in the field of Mathematical Logic and Conceptual Analysis.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)