Search This Blog

De Omnibus Dubitandum - Lux Veritas

Thursday, September 6, 2012

History Lesson For the Day: Shay's Rebellion

____________

Shays' Rebellion was an armed uprising that took place in central and western Massachusetts in 1786 and 1787. The rebellion was named after Daniel Shays, a veteran of the American Revolutionary War and one of the rebel leaders.

The rebellion started on August 29, 1786. It was precipitated by several factors: financial difficulties brought about by a post-war economic depression, a credit squeeze caused by a lack of hard currency, and fiscally harsh government policies instituted in 1785 to solve the state's debt problems…..At a meeting convened by aggrieved commoners, a farmer, Plough Jogger, encapsulated the situation….. "I have been greatly abused, have been obliged to do more than my part in the war, been loaded with class rates, town rates, province rates, Continental rates and all rates ... been pulled and hauled by sheriffs, constables and collectors, and had my cattle sold for less than they were worth ... The great men are going to get all we have and I think it is time for us to rise and put a stop to it, and have no more courts, nor sheriffs, nor collectors nor lawyers."

Governor James Bowdoin instituted a heavy tax burden and stepped up collection of back taxes.

Overlaid upon these financial issues was the fact that veterans of the war had not received much pay during the war and were having difficulty collecting back pay owed them from the state or the Congress of the Confederation. Some of these soldiers, Daniel Shays among them, began to organize protests against the oppressive economic conditions. Shays was a poor farmhand from Massachusetts when the Revolution broke out. He joined the Continental Army, saw action at the Battles of Lexington and Concord, Bunker Hill, and Saratoga, and was eventually wounded in action. In 1780, he resigned from the army unpaid and went home to find himself in court for the nonpayment of debts. He soon found that he was not alone in being unable to pay his debts and began organizing for debt relief…..

Follow the link to Wikipedia for the many links in the article.

There is a much expaned view of Shay's Rebellion Here that is worth reading.  Make sure to scroll all the way down. 

###

Wednesday, September 5, 2012

This Day in History

________________________________________________________________
September 5, 1972 - Arab terrorists take Israeli hostages at the Olympics

On this date a Muslim Terrorist organization called Black September took nine Israeli athletes, coaches and officials hostage in their apartments. Two of the hostages who resisted were killed in the first moments of the break-in; the subsequent standoff in the Olympic Village lasted for almost 18 hours.

Late in the evening of September 5, the terrorists and their hostages were transferred by helicopter to the military airport ostensibly to board a plane bound for an undetermined Arab country. The German authorities planned to ambush them there, but underestimated the number of terrorists and were thus undermanned. During a botched rescue attempt, all of the Israeli hostages were killed. Four of them were shot, then incinerated when one of the terrorists detonated a grenade inside the helicopter in which the hostages were sitting. The five remaining hostages were then machine-gunned by another terrorist.

All but three of the terrorists were killed as well. Although arrested and imprisoned pending trial, they were released by the West German government on October 29, 1972 in exchange for a hijacked Lufthansa jet. Two of those three were supposedly hunted down and assassinated later by the Mossad.  Jamal Al-Gashey, who is believed to be the sole survivor, is still living today in hiding in an unspecified African country with his wife and two children.

Source: Wikipedia Here.
###

Tuesday, September 4, 2012

Voters Abandon Global Warming Fears

  
By Alan Caruba

This first appeared Here.  I wish to thank Alan for allowing me to post his work.  RK
Former President Jimmy Carter will address the Democratic Party convention via a televised address, but former Vice President Al Gore and candidate for President will be no where in sight.

The leading advocate for global warning will be conspicuous in his absence, but that doesn’t mean that the greatest hoax of modern times will not be mentioned. It has been a consistent theme of the Obama administration, particularly to justify the Environmental Protection Agency’s efforts to attack the energy and business sectors of the nation’s economy.

As this is being written, the morning of the start of the Democratic Party convention, one wonders if the tired, thoroughly debunked claims that carbon dioxide (CO2) is causing a warming that does not exist and that humans are also causing it will be mentioned.

On the night that Obama had won his primary victory over Hillary Clinton’s bid to be the party’s presidential candidate, among his promises and claims, he said, “This was the moment when the rise of the oceans began to slow and our planet began to heal.” You cannot get more absurd than that. It would translate into the administration’s push for cap-and-trade legislation (regarding CO2 emissions) that was rejected by a Democrat-controlled Senate.

Obama’s claim did not go unnoticed by Mitt Romney who, during his acceptance speech, said, “President Obama promised to slow the rise of the oceans and to heal the planet. My promise is to help you and your family.” The global warming hustlers were apoplectic in their denunciations of Romney, but his promise received a standing ovation.

The administration has become famous for the billions wasted on so-called green jobs, green energy, and controlling greenhouse gases. It is essential to understand that CO2 has never caused any of the warming cycles the Earth has been through over 4.5 billion years. It shows up after climate cycle change occurs. Moreover, the oceans that cover 71% of the Earth surface both stores and releases CO2.

Prior to Earth Day in 2011, a Gallup poll revealed just how Americans felt about various environmental issues. Asked about a variety of concerns, the respondents rated global warming dead last with 48% saying they were either not much or not at all concerned about it.

The decades of apocalyptic claims and warnings have given way to reality. There have been no massive famines, no complete melting of the north or south poles, no increase in natural phenomenon such as hurricanes, no mass extinctions of various species. By 1998, the planet began a new cooling cycle, one that panicked the perpetrators of the global warming myth.

In 2009, the leak of emails between the researchers whose deliberately false “data” was the basis for global warming claims revealed that the cabal behind the United Nations’ Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change reports were plotting to suppress the truth. The leak would become known as “Climategate.”

Just prior to the Democratic Party convention, President Obama issued yet another Executive Order, this one calling for “investment”, i.e., more spending, on cogeneration plants in order to reduce carbon dioxide emissions by deploying “cleaner and more efficient energy production in the country by working around political resistance to climate change and ‘green’ energy legislation on Capitol Hill.”

In reality, you cannot “save” energy. You can only use less of it and the Obama administration has done everything in its power to ensure that there will be less by deterring the construction of the Keystone XL pipeline from Canada—estimated to generate 20,000 new jobs—and by waging a war on coal. Coal mines and coal-fired plants are being closed. Oil continues to be discovered in the U.S. but not on federally controlled lands, nor can it be explored and extracted offshore where billions of barrels exist.

In effect, the Obama administration has been the most anti-energy administration in recent times while, at the same time, wasting billions on solar energy companies that have gone bankrupt and on wind power which, combined, represent less than 3% of the electricity generated nationwide and which would not exist were they were not, like ethanol, completely dependent on government mandates and subsidies.

It will be interesting to see how many of the convention speakers make any reference to global warming, carbon dioxide, or the real sources of energy, coal, oil, natural gas, and nuclear power..

Throwing a bone to the environmentalists, it is likely that President Obama will make a passing reference to global warming and energy, but it is not likely that the “planet will begin to heal” as it grows colder in a completely natural cooling cycle that threatens to tip over into a new ice age.

There are real problems to be addressed, high unemployment, a lagging “recovery”, a fiscal crisis that will occur on January 1st unless Congress acts to extend tax cuts and puts off a massive sequestration of funding to defense and other sectors. In the end, it is likely we will be told that the last four years were all George W. Bush’s fault.

© Alan Caruba, 2012

If you have been thinking of helping support Warning Signs, your donation will be especially helpful. Donate Here! Thank you!

###

Observations From the Back Row



Thought For The Day

Organic pesticides and “organically produced” foods, create thinking that they would not contain any pesticides. Most people are not aware that organic gardeners can legally use a great many pesticides, so long as they are not man-made. They can use nicotine sulfate, rotenone, and pyrethrum (derived from plants), or any poisons that occur naturally, such as lime, sulfur, borax, cyanide, arsenic, and fluorine.
_____________________________________

As the weeklong international conference on water concluded Friday, it was left to one of the keynote speakers from the United Nations to focus on a much neglected perspective on water and food security: the role of women.  Lakshmi Puri, deputy executive director of U.N. Women, told delegates that development can be neither sustainable nor inclusive if it does not free women and girls from “carrying heavy buckets of water every day”.  In Sub-Saharan Africa, 71 percent of the burden of collecting water for households falls on women and girls, says the U.N.’s 2012 report on Millennium Development Goals (MDGs).  Currently, women in Africa spend an estimated 200 million hours per day collecting water. Worldwide, it’s a whopping 40 billion hours per year.

My Take – What amazes me is that we know this is what happened all over the world before industrialization; the very thing the Non Governmental Organizations at the U.N. are trying to destroy.  The very thing the IPCC is trying to destroy.  This is what the greenies desire for the entire world.  This next article falls under the "We have lost our minds category!" RK



Monday, September 3, 2012

Green Weenies of the Week: Just About Everybody

 
Perhaps you recall the Nobel Peace Prize being given as a group award a few years back to Al Gore and the 1,200 scientists who contributed to the IPCC climate change report (though, strangely, I know several people who were part of the IPCC process and whose names are in the report, but who never saw any of the Nobel cash—seems Al Gore and the IPCC top bureaucrats kept it all, surprise, surprise).  Well, this week we are compelled to emulate the Nobel committee and give out Power Line’s coveted Green Weenie Award to . . . just about everybody in sight. 
The only people who had a bigger meltdown than Chris Matthews last week were environmentalists everywhere who were shocked and appalled that the subject of climate change came up . . . not at all during the Republican convention.  Hmmm, maybe Republican leaders have figured out what environmentalists haven’t—namely, that no one cares about this issue any more....(To continue reading...... )


###

Dr. Tim Ball's Web Site


  
Someone said if you think education is expensive – try ignorance. This website is dedicated to helping people understand the world and the ways it works. We’re in an information revolution because the Internet is democratizing information.

Everyone knows that information is power, but it’s exploitation of power that has allowed a few to control and exploit people. Exploitation can be financial, but more disturbing and controlling is the exploitation of power…..To Continue Reading

Here is his latest post. RK


by Dr. Tim Ball on September 2, 2012

Recently I identified a counterattack trying to defend the failed anthropogenic global warming (AGW) hypothesis. Claims about Arctic ice melt this summer (2012) are another example. Data and analysis are wrong, but they need to scare a disinterested public......


###

Dr. Tim Ball's Thoughts on Global Warming

By Rich Kozlovich
Those who have been reading Paradigms and Demographics know that I have been following the lawsuit instigated by Mike Mann against Tim Ball.  I recently came upon a new site (new to me) called Principia Scientific International, that you may find worth your time.

They really seem to believe scientific principles have been abandoned and are concerned about that abandonment.  Is it to be principles over politics or visa versa?  Perhaps the question I should be asking is;  is it truth and integrity over grant money and false fame?
 
Grant money is now the holy grail of science, not truth.  From this site I have linked some articles by Tim Ball that are worth taking the time to read.  I think it is worthwhile to find out what Ball has to say since so much of what he has said, and will say,  may have a major impact on the global warming hucksters.   Here is some foundation for those who are new to this issue or my site. 

I Will Huff and Puff and Blow Your House Down
A complete list of things caused by global warming

In some of these articles there are more links that are worth exploring, and I am impressed with Tim Ball's analyses.  I can't wait for the decision from the Canadian courts in this lawsuit since Ball's defense is "the truth" defense under Canadian law!

Why do ‘official’ climate scientists need spin doctors? Because they practice politics not science. Climategate like Watergate was completely undone by the cover up of disgraceful behavior disclosed in emails leaked from the Climatic Research Unit (CRU) in November 2009. The first 1000 emails included some selected to expose behavior unacceptable even without knowledge of climatology. Others show how the anthropogneic global warming (AGW) science was conjured. Exposure of CRU members was important because they dominated and controlled the major portions of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) Reports. The leaks achieved their objective of derailing the political program of the Conference of the Parties (COP) 15 in Copenhagen. The COP was in a bind because they’re starting point is IPCC science.

George Hadley (1685 - 1768), an Age of Enlightenment citizen, lawyer and amateur meteorologist made a major contribution to climatology through an interest in the Trade Winds. He worked inductively using ships weather logs to produce a theory about atmospheric circulation. Named after him, the Hadley cell is the only portion of the atmospheric circulation we understood in concept for 250 years. Its role is a major factor in global weather and climate yet is completely inadequately covered in Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) computer models. The error in coverage exceeds any possible human impact and is one more factor causing consistently failed predictions.  

Claims of human produced CO2 causing climate change are based on output of computer models of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC). Programmed to produce predetermined results their output is used for global and national policies on energy even though projections have been consistently wrong. Failures caused a switch from predictions to scenarios, but it didn’t help. Most recent scenarios projected increases between 1.3 and 2.8°C, but temperatures declined as CO2 increased. Since 2000 the trend is wrong and for the last five years is below the lowest IPCC projection.
 
 

Sunday, September 2, 2012

The "Untold Story": Did Muhammad Live?

By Rich Kozlovich
I have known about this for some time, but I have deliberately shied away from it because I just don’t have much confidence in historical deconstructionists and “higher criticisms” because they seem to be mostly nitpicking with a goal.  Much like scientific studies that are more conclusions in search of data than a search for truth.
 There are those who claim that Moses didn’t write the Pentateuch, for among other reasons, he used different words at different parts of the Pentateuch.  “The differences in style as suggested by the JEDP Theory of Documentary Hypothesis are easily explained even with examples of modern literature where authors change style according to subject matter. There is also substantial unity in the documents which cannot be explained by multiple authors of vastly different time periods.”   I have used different words as I grew older and Moses is reported to have lived for 120 years. 
All the criticisms have been largely dismissed by reasonable people.  “The evidence, together with clear statements in the texts themselves point to Moses as the author and final editor in the case of Genesis, of the first five books of the Bible.”
There are those who have criticized Biblical historicity for decades because “leading scholars” had no archeological information to substantiate statements in “The Book”.  As the years have gone by each of the claims made against Biblical historicity has fallen.  There is still controversy about Jericho, however in the seventies the absolute historicity of Sodom and Gomorrah was established after they broke into a chamber filled with clay receipts mentioning those cities.   Apparently they already had large commercial dealings with Babylon and the rest of the Middle East.  Based on “archeological” history; I think we will find the answer to Jericho also. 
This brings me back to the point. Did Mohammad actually live?  In England a scholar named Tom Holland had a documentary presented on British TV called the “Untold Story” that says that there is absolutely no evidence that he did. 
“Since it was screened last week, presenter Tom Holland, a historian with a double first from Cambridge, has been subjected  to a torrent of abusive tweets, some of which have included physical threats.”….”Untold Story has triggered nearly 550 complaints to both the television regulator Ofcom and Channel 4 itself. ……It has also sparked a bitter war of words on Twitter involving leading historians and Islamic scholars.”
Mr. Holland said: ‘The origins of Islam are a legitimate subject of historical inquiry and this film is wholly in keeping with other series and programmes on Channel 4.   Historians have rallied to Mr. Holland’s defence…..One persons described “the programme as ‘a triumph’, tweeting: ‘Dear angry, mad people –  it is conceivable that you know more than the world’s leading scholars, but very unlikely.’”
I believe that research on this subject is absolute worthy of scholarly inquiry.  I believe that programming on this subject is worthy to be presented.  If it is acceptable to do so for other religions it certainly is acceptable to do so regarding Islam.  So what is the big difference?  
The BIG difference is that Islamists have the tendency to kill those who say things they don’t like. 
One of their own, Salmon Rushdie, incurred the absolute wrath of Muslims worldwide for writing “The Satanic Verses” in 1988.   Death threats were made against him, including a death sentence issued by Ayatollah Ruhollah Khomeini, the Supreme Leader of Iran, on 14 February 1989, and set a $5.2 million bounty on Rushdie's head.”
“Radio Tehran went on, declaring in the Iranian government's name Feb. 15, 1989 a "day of national mourning . . . in protest against the new conspiracy of the great Satan (the United States) to publish poisonous and insulting subject-matter concerning Islam, the Koran and the blessed prophet." Within 72 hours, six people died and more than 160 were wounded in violent demonstrations against the book in Pakistan and India.”
Now back to Holland’s claim that there is no evidence that Mohammad ever lived.  I can’t say either way, but I find it difficult to believe such a large movement could have sprung up overnight, and created an empire of loosely united kingdoms that "in fewer than one hundred years stretched from the Iberian Peninsula to India", and there was no one in charge at the beginning of it all. 

If we accept the idea Mohammad didn't exist, then we have to believe that all of this was accomplished by a conspiracy so enormous as to unhinge the imagination.  That is far too irrational and incomprehensible to be believed.  Clearly, we need to be able attach a valid scientific explanation for all of this.  I would use Occam's Razor.  "The simplest explanation is probably the correct one."
As for the claim that it is unlikely that others “know” more than the leading scholar on the subject - that is a logical fallacy known as “Appeal to Authority”, and authorities have been proven to be …..well…. really stupid in the past. 
So, am I defending the Islamists?  No!  What I am saying is that Islam isn’t a “made-up religion” as stated.  I’m saying that Islam isn’t a religion at all.  When a “religion” requires its adherents to kill, rape and rob in the name of their faith then it isn’t a religion; it is a criminal organization masquerading as a religion.  No less so than the Thuggee of India, which was a gang of murderers and thieves who “would join travelers and gain their confidence. This would allow them to then surprise and strangle them by tossing a handkerchief or noose around their necks. The killings were performed in honour of the goddess Kali and were very ritualistic.  They would then rob the bodies of valuables and bury them.” “In the 1830s they were targeted by William Bentinck, along with his chief captain William Henry Sleeman, for eradication. They were seemingly destroyed by this effort.”  They were defined and recognized for what they were by their actions.  Thieves and murders!
Religions that promote violence as a part of their credo will eventually incur violence in opposition to their credo.  In Muslim controlled countries we see those who profess to be Jews, Christians, and even different Muslim sects, being murdered by the local population for their beliefs; clearly with the spoken or unspoken approval of the ruling authorities.  This kind of madness cannot exist in a vacuum.  Eventually opposition forces will gain arms and expertise to defend themselves and to attack their opponents; much like what occurred in Lebanon in the 1970’s and 1980’s.   All of this internal criminality is one of the reasons their economies are a mess.  Take away the oil and they would revert to Middle Age cultures all over again. 
 I almost wish that they could prove that Mohammad really didn't exist and that Islam is a made up religion; then maybe people would regain their sanity and stop the slaughter of so many innocent people. 

Editor's Note:  You may wish to peruse the following material.


###

Saturday, September 1, 2012

A Fellow Ohioan

By Rich Kozlovich

Normally I wouldn't post anything about Neil Armstrong because this is a story that everyone in the country is publishing. However, Armstrong was a fellow Ohioan and he is from "Wapak", which is what people from Wapakoneta call their town. And since I have family living there I thought I should say something. I can tell you that this is truly a "small town boy makes good" story.

When my sister-in-law and her husband first moved there they still had public phones that only cost a nickel. That's right....a nickel. You could only call in town but it was still....just a nickel. I always chuckled about that; not because I thought ill of "Wapak", but it just tickled my fancy, and was indicative of how small "Wapak" really was and how close the community is.

Small towns are the same all over the country. Small towns have big relationships....literally. Once you scratch the surface you find that the percentage of residents related to each other is amazing; and personal relationships go back for generations, and are almost as binding as family. That is the kind of society Armstrong knew, understood and was foundational to forming his view of reality.

In his article, The Man From Wapakoneta, Christopher G. Adamo notes that Neil Armstrong became a hero;
 "as the institutions and beliefs that formed the heritage of the nation were being systematically dismantled by countercultural revolutionaries, those who held such things in high regard fervently sought for inspiring reminders of America’s enduring greatness."
He goes on to say that;

"the pop culture of the late 1960s had to offer in response were its own icons of social collapse, as epitomized by Bob Dylan and Abbie Hoffman. The flag was routinely being publicly desecrated, and contempt shown towards every building block of the American ideal. Nihilism and anti-Americanism appeared to be winning the day."
The reality is that these leftist icons weren't as popular as it may seem. They certainly weren't to me...I pretty much despised them, and my contempt hasn't even been moderated by age. I just finished reading the book "The Politically Incorrect Guide to The Sixty's", which made me aware that I wasn’t alone. In fact I was in the majority; by quite a lot. The media made the radicals seem like the typical student in the 60’s. The reality is the student radicals represented a very small minority who intimated weak and cowardly college administrators and educators. In fact the radicals in every aspect of American life represented a very small minority whose views and philosophy seemed to have taken over the country because the media made them bigger than life.

Neil Armstrong represented another generation much different from the baby boomers. Adamo goes on to say;
“Unlike so many among the ensuing “boomer” generation, and in stark contrast to the modern day narcissists who predominate the pop culture and more alarmingly, the highest levels of government, Armstrong was never prone to self-absorption, regarding his role as nothing other than a man doing the job he had trained to do. With the mission ended, the parades passed by, and the spotlights faded, he seemed altogether happy to return to relative obscurity."
I can attest to his unwillingness to draw attention to himself and what he accomplished. Wapakoneta decided to honor him in some parade…either as a Neil Armstrong Day or have him appear at some holiday parade…(I don't remember the details any longer) but he refused to come. Initially I thought it was arrogance, which was the case in other small towns attempting to honor a famous son. But with Armstrong it was different. The man was truly unimpressed with himself, and he just didn’t like all that attention.

The man had dignity, honor, humility; and the man had class!

I wish the other Armstrong in the news had even a fraction of his class. Actually I would like to see all the professional athletes have a fraction of Neil Armstrong’s class. 

I will say this.  Being involved in my industry's affairs I can honestly attest that the mentality and attitude displayed by Neil Armstrong is far more prevalent than we may think.  The amount of people who humbly, unassumingly, quietly work behind the scenes to defend the pest control industry; without fanfare or compensation (even for out of pocket expenses) is astounding.  Neil Armstrong represented the depth of who we are as a society and what we believe. 

And he did it so well.

Logical Fallacy of the Week, Week 40: Historian's Fallacy

The Historian's fallacy – not to be confused with Historical fallacy - is a logical fallacy that occurs when one assumes that decision makers of the past viewed events from the same perspective and having the same information as those subsequently analyzing the decision. It is not to be confused with presentism, a mode of historical analysis in which present-day ideas (such as moral standards) are projected into the past.
The fallacy was outlined in 1970 by David Hackett Fischer, who suggested it was analogous to William James's psychologist's fallacy. Fischer did not suggest that historians should refrain from retrospective analysis in their work, but he reminded historians that their subjects were not able to see into the future.
As an example, he cited the well-known argument that Japan's surprise attack on Pearl Harbor should have been predictable in the United States because of the many indications that an attack was imminent. What this argument overlooks, says Fischer, citing the work of Roberta Wohlstetter, is that there were innumerable conflicting signs which suggested possibilities other than an attack on Pearl Harbor. Only in retrospect do the warning signs seem obvious; signs which pointed in other directions tend to be forgotten. (See also: hindsight bias.)
My Take - While in principle I agree with this presentation I find the Pearl Harbor analogy somewhat inaccurate.  There were those who rightly predicted the attack in great detail because of the events which occurred during the Russo-Japanese War. The Japanese conducted a sneak naval attack on Port Arthur without any declaration of war.  Although the Japanese attempted to have a declaration delivered at the last minute to the United States government, the mentality, the strategy and the views of the Japanese was almost identical. 
Those who predicted this attack were not uninformed radicals.  One of them was Col. Billy Mitchell, who caused so much public controversy regarding his views on the future of air power "his superiors sent him to Hawaii".....to quell the resultant fury of the battleship admirals and get Mitchell off the front pages."  
 "However, he returned with a scathing report on the inadequate defenses he saw there. He also went to Europe and the Far East to study the advances being made in aviation. After returning from the latter trip in 1924, he wrote a shocking 323-page report–probably the most prophetic document of his career–that stressed that, when making estimates of Japanese air power, 'care must be taken that it is not underestimated.'
"Mitchell believed that Japan was the dominant nation in Asia and was preparing to do battle with the United States. He predicted that air attacks would be made by the Japanese on Pearl Harbor and the Philippines and described how they would be conducted.  His report was received with all the enthusiasm of 'a green demolition team approaching an unexploded bomb,' according to one writer. The report was ignored; it is said that even his boss did not read it for two years."

He was later court marshaled for his publicly outspoken views of the incompetence of higher ranking commanders with no understanding or vision.  Yet everything he said came true. 

What is worse of course, it is clear that FDR should have known of the "sneak attack" at least three days before and didn't inform Admiral Husband Kimmel and General Walter Short, the commanders at Pearl Harbor, of the depth of his knowledge.  There is one part of this that has intrigued me for years. 

In William Stephenson's book, A Man Called Intrepid, he certainly gives the impression that Churchill had intelligence of the attack and informed FDR.  I will have to go back and read that book. 

The thirty years secrets act had expired, so he wrote it to explain their decisions during the war.  There was also a fifty years act....which I was really looking forward to seeing expire.  As I recall it was extended indefinitely.  That's scary since they deliberated picked thirty and fifty years respectively because then all the parties would be dead.  Clearly there are prominent families that had dirty...no....let's amend that....potentially filthy laundry that needs hidden, like Joe Kennedy. 

Get the book....it is worth the read.
 
 

Logical Fallacy of the Week, Week 39: Gambler’s Fallacy

The Gambler's fallacy, also known as the Monte Carlo fallacy (because its most famous example happened in a Monte Carlo Casino in 1913), and also referred to as the fallacy of the maturity of chances, is the belief that if deviations from expected behaviour are observed in repeated independent trials of some random process, future deviations in the opposite direction are then more likely.   The incorrect belief that separate, independent events can affect the likelihood of another random event. If a coin flip lands on heads 10 times in a row, the belief that it is "due to land on tails" is incorrect.  
 

Friday, August 31, 2012

ANWR: Let’s Go!

If only their hot air could be converted into usable energy.

Drilling won’t generate production overnight. But it will ensure steady new supplies a few years hence. Unlike electricity generation from wind and solar, hydrocarbon development is not an intermittent process. It is 24-7 every month, every year.

Simply announcing that America is finally hunting oil again would send a powerful signal to global energy markets. It would also tame speculators, many of whom bet that continued U.S. drilling restrictions will further exacerbate the global demand-supply imbalance and send prices even higher for “futures” (under which a person pays a specific amount today, with the expectation of selling a commodity on a future date at a higher price).

Pro-drilling policies would likely bring lower prices, as did past announcements that Brazil had found new offshore oil fields, that Iraq would sign contracts to increase oil production, and that hydraulic fracturing had unlocked enormous new U.S. supplies of natural gas.

Conversely, news that supplies are tightening – because of sabotage in Nigeria’s delta region, for example, or continued bans on leasing American petroleum – will send prices upward.

Resourceship

We really don’t know how much petroleum we have. When “experts” discuss U.S. oil and gas resources and reserves, they are basing their estimates on outdated seismic, drilling, and other data and technologies. They often cite reserve estimates that were proven wrong years ago, or treat oil reserves as a fixed number, when in reality reserves are constantly changing and usually increase over time.

“Resources” are the total amount of petroleum geologists believe may be in underground formations, based on what they can “see” with seismic data. “Reserves” are the amount of oil or gas that can be produced at a given price, with existing technology, at a particular point in time, based on actual discoveries and well data, where drilling is permitted and has taken place. One could also say “reserves” are what our government allows us to find and extract.

Seismic provides a cross-sectional view of subsurface structures and rock formations that may hold oil, and technological improvements over the past decade have dramatically increased what we can “see,” in areas where companies are allowed to do seismic work. 3D and now 4D seismic (how rock formations change over time) paint vivid moving pictures of the subsurface and tell exploration geologists there is much more oil down there than previously estimated.

However, only two-thirds of the Gulf of Mexico and small parts of Alaska are open to offshore operations. The rest of America’s offshore areas, along with most onshore federal lands, are off limits to seismic work and drilling. That means we have up-to-date information on only a small portion of our potential energy base.

If we can’t even use seismic to “see” the vast majority of our underground prospects and resources, we cannot possibly estimate what is actually there. The one thing we can say is: Our current estimates of U.S. oil and gas resources are wrong, and are almost certainly much too low.

Understanding resources “in place” is just the first step. To estimate reserves accurately, we have to recognize that drilling technology has also evolved rapidly over the past decade. “Directional drilling” now allows companies to drill wells a mile deep and five miles long, and steer drill bits to penetrate multiple oil zones and hit targets the size of basketball courts. This accuracy, coupled with the ability to fracture rock formations and stimulate them to produce far more oil, natural gas and natural gas liquids than previously possible, is simply revolutionary.

In short, our ability to find and capture more of the oil in place has increased our reserves dramatically.

Arctic National Wildlife Refuge

One of the USA’s best prospects is Alaska’s Arctic National Wildlife Refuge (ANWR), which geologists say likely contains billions of barrels of recoverable oil. If President Bill Clinton hadn’t bowed to Wilderness Society demands and vetoed 1995 legislation, we likely would be producing a million barrels a day from ANWR right now. That’s equal to U.S. imports from Saudi Arabia, at nearly $40 billion annually.

Leasing ANWR prospects would get new oil flowing in 5–10 years, depending in large part on how many lawsuits and other delays prevent drilling. That’s far faster than benefits would flow from supposed alternatives: devoting millions more acres of cropland to corn-based or (still non-existent) cellulosic ethanol, persuading millions of people to buy expensive hybrid and flex-fuel cars, building a dozen new nuclear power plants, and blanketing thousands of square miles with wind turbines and solar panels.

These alternatives would take decades to implement, and all face political, legal, technological, economic and environmental hurdles.

Drilling in ANWR and other Alaskan areas would also ensure sufficient production to keep the Trans-Alaska Pipeline (TAP) in operation. Right now, declining North Slope production threatens to reduce oil in the pipeline to the point where it cannot stay sufficiently warm to flow under months-long Arctic winter conditions. The TAP needs between 200,000 and 300,000 barrels of oil per day to stay open. If there are inadequate supplies, the pipeline will be abruptly shut down – and even torn down, because current laws require complete removal of the TAP if it stops functioning.

That would result in the sudden elimination of a sizeable portion of our national oil production. It would mean billions of barrels of already discovered oil would be left in the ground and unavailable to American businesses, motorists and other citizens – representing a terrible way to “conserve” energy. It would create a huge disincentive to future Arctic oil leasing and development.

All of this might please the Sierra Club and Greenpeace, but it is hardly in the national interest.

Opening Oil Reserves

ANWR is the size of South Carolina. Its narrow coastal plain is frozen and windswept most of the year. Wildlife flourish amid drilling and production in other Arctic regions, and would do so near ANWR facilities. Inuits who live there know this, and support drilling by an 8:1 margin. Gwich’in Indians who oppose drilling live hundreds of miles away – and have leased and drilled nearly all their own tribal lands, including caribou migratory routes, to generate revenue for the tribe.

Drilling and production operations would impact only 2,000 acres (one-twentieth of Washington, D.C.), plus narrow roads between drilling sites, to produce some 15 billion gallons of oil annually. Each drill “pad” would support multiple wells that have the capability to reach miles in all directions.

Saying this tiny footprint would spoil the refuge is like saying a major airport along South Carolina’s northern border would destroy the entire state’s scenery and wildlife. Moreover, the roads would allow caribou and other animals to move around more easily during long, frigid, snowy winters; that would reduce death tolls from starvation and predation, and increase wildlife populations, just as happened elsewhere along the North Slope and TAP route.

Drilling in ANWR is a far better bargain than producing 13 billion gallons of ethanol annually from corn grown on an area nearly as big as Missouri (44 million acres) – using massive amounts of water, pesticides, fertilizer and fossil fuels, and sending corn, food and food aid prices higher and higher. It’s far better than using wind to generate enough electricity to power New York City, which would require blanketing Connecticut (three million acres) with turbines, and putting thousands of eagles, hawks, falcons, whooping cranes and other species at risk of being sliced up by turbine blades.

Proved Reserves

Anti-drilling factions often claim that “U.S. energy prices are high, because Americans consume 25% of the world’s oil, while possessing only 3% of its proven oil reserves.” The rhetoric is clever, but misleading, even disingenuous, and ultimately harmful.
Possession has nothing to do with prices, any more than owning a library, but never opening the books, improves intellectual abilities; or owning farmland that’s never tilled feeds hungry people.

The 3% claim refers to now-outdated information about conventional (traditional) oil resources that drilling has confirmed exist and can be produced with then-current technologies and prices. However, American politicians, regulators and courts have made numerous prospects off limits to leasing and delayed or rejected multiple seismic and drilling applications. In so doing, they have ensured that an estimated 170 billion barrels of oil resources in the Outer Continental Shelf, Rockies, Great Lakes, Southwest, ANWR and other areas never become “reserves.”

In fact, conventional reserves will decrease, as we deplete existing deposits and don’t replace them – or we force the TAP to close down, thereby making billions of barrels of proven oil reserves unavailable.

Despite anti-hydrocarbon policies, the United States is still the world’s third largest producer of oil, and its largest producer of natural gas. US oil production is actually increasing today, thanks to production from unconventional deposits, mostly on state and private lands. Moreover, our inability to explore unproven areas onshore and offshore has improved exponentially. If unconventional oil and gas reserves are included, the United States will remain a dominant player in world energy markets.

For example, horizontal drilling and hydraulic fracturing (“fracking”) has unlocked billions of barrels of oil and trillions of cubic feet of natural gas that just a few years ago were thought to be inaccessible, and have done so with minimal environmental impacts. The new technology has created tens of thousands of direct oilfield jobs, generated billions in revenues, and slashed the price of natural gas by more than 75 percent. Expanded supplies and lower prices for natural gas have spurred a US manufacturing and petrochemical renaissance, creating thousands of additional jobs and billions in additional revenue, and increasing the likelihood that many vehicles will soon run on compressed natural gas.

Applying 3D seismic, fracking and other new technologies to ANWR and other Arctic prospects would likely increase their reserves and ultimate yield many times over.
The U.S. Geological Survey and Congressional Research Service say it’s 95% likely that there are 15.6 billion barrels of oil beneath ANWR. With today’s prices and fracking technology, 60% of that is recoverable. At $100 a barrel, that represents nearly $1 trillion that we would not have to send to overseas. It means lower prices and reduced risks of oil spills from tankers carrying foreign crude to America.

Stimulating the Economy

Producing ANWR’s oil riches represents hundreds of billions in state and federal royalties and corporate income taxes, over the life of the fields, plus billions more in lease sale revenues, plus thousands of direct and indirect jobs, in addition to numerous jobs created when all this money is reinvested in the USA.

In fact, after the IRS, the single largest contribution to the U.S. treasury is oil company oil and gas royalty payments. Companies that produce from federal onshore and offshore leases pay royalties of up to 18% of wellhead prices, and then pay corporate taxes on profits and sales taxes at the pump. Wind and solar companies, by contrast, require perpetual subsidies, taken from profitable sectors of our economy.

Leasing and drilling also translates into additional billions in income tax revenues that oilfield, refinery, manufacturing and other jobs would generate, plus new opportunities for minority, poor and blue collar families to improve their lives and living standards. It means lower prices for gasoline, heating, cooling, food and other products.

Factor in America’s other locked-up energy, and we’re talking tens of trillions of dollars that we either keep in the United States, by producing that energy … or ship overseas.
This energy belongs to all Americans. It’s not the private property of environmental pressure groups, or of politicians who cater to them in exchange for re-election support.

This energy is likewise the common heritage of mankind. Politicians and eco-activists have no right to keep it off limits – and tell the rest of the world: “We have no intention of developing American energy. We don’t care if you need oil, if soaring food and energy prices are pummeling poor families, or if drilling in your countries harms your habitats to produce oil for US consumers.”

Those attitudes are immoral and intolerable. They show disdain for American workers and taxpayers, and for the world’s poor. They are bad for the global environment.

It’s time to drill safely and carefully again here in America – onshore and off, in Alaska and the Lower 48 States. We should and must do so, while also developing economically and environmentally sensible new technologies to improve energy conservation, and provide alternatives to petroleum if Earth’s hydrocarbon deposits really are depleted a century or more from now.
__________

Paul Driessen is senior policy advisor for the Committee For A Constructive Tomorrow and Congress of Racial Equality, and author of Eco-Imperialism: Green power ? Black Death.