Search This Blog

De Omnibus Dubitandum - Lux Veritas

Showing posts with label Redistricting. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Redistricting. Show all posts

Monday, May 22, 2023

New NC Supreme Court Majority Overturns Prior Majority’s Unconstitutional Interference in Redistricting

Hans von Spakovsky / /

In a detailed, 146-page opinion by Chief Justice Paul Newby, the newly composed North Carolina state Supreme Court vacated and overturned a prior decision by the same court that was a prime example of political interference by activist judges, who were fully prepared to ignore the law and the constitutional limitations on their authority............ 

In a 4-to-3 decision issued in February 2022, the majority—all judges who had been elected as Democrats—held that partisan gerrymandering violated the free elections, equal protection, free speech, and free assembly clauses of the state constitution, overturning prior precedent cited in the lower court decisions that partisan redistricting did not violate the state constitution and there were no judicially manageable standards in any event...........But something else very important happened in the November elections: Two of the Democrat elected North Carolina justices who were in the original majority were defeated in their reelection bids and were replaced by two Republican judges, swinging the court from a 4-to-3 Democratic majority to a 5-to-2 Republican majority............To Read More....

My Take - The Democrats have practiced blatant partisan redistricting in every state where they had the power to do so, and thought it was just fine and wonderful.  However, what was fine and wonderful when they did it is now "shameful manipulation of fundamental principles of our democracy and the rule of law.”.   

What remarkable hypocrisy and as usual, their hypocrisy is accompanied by vacuous self-righteous indignation.   But their outrageous emotional protestations are meaningless according to the  Constitution, which gives total and complete authority to the state legislatures regarding redistricting.    

While the courts have done so in the past, in point of law, they absolutely have no right to interfere with the legislature's prerogatives on redistricting.  That falls under the purview of state legislatures in that arena, not the judicial or the executive branches. 

 


Monday, February 19, 2018

Pennsylvania’s Constitutional Crisis

By Frank Ryan February 19, 2018

In a repeat of the state’s extraordinary role in the 2016 presidential election, this year Pennsylvania will be the center of a serious constitutional challenge. At stake may be the entire congressional balance of power between Democrats and Republicans.

Democrats in PA are attempting to do through the courts what they were not able to do at the ballot box.

They are assuming that the woes of their cause are due to redistricting, not to failed policies repudiated by the electorate. Trump’s stunning statewide victory in Pennsylvania in 2016 had absolutely nothing to do with gerrymandering.

As background, the Supreme Court of Pennsylvania in 2018 ruled that the 2012 redistricting of Pennsylvania’s congressional districts was unconstitutional. The Court gave the legislature until February 9 to submit a plan of redistricting to the governor for approval. The governor would then have until February 15 to accept or reject the map.

The governor has rejected the map, and in its decision the Supreme Court reserved the right to draw the boundaries of redistricting on its own accord or to select one of many competing plans .......As soon as the Supreme Court intercedes and adopts a new map, a constitutional crisis immediately ensues. Seldom in our nation’s history has a state Supreme Court usurped the constitutional role of the legislature in drawing congressional boundaries.............The damage to our republic when a judiciary not only legislates from the bench but manipulates elections makes the interference by Russians pale in comparison.........Read more